Trade Vinayak of s2alnalytics.com

[GAIV]

Does anyone over here have experience of "TRADE VINAYAK" OF S2ANALYTICS.COM.

If so please share experience. Is it worth subscribing?

 

[arvvasu]

Been using trade vinayak for sometime. It has 2 signals for Nifty based on 30 min and 60 min charts.

The 30 min signal isn't good enough. Keeps whipsawing. It will work well in a trending market but how to know if the market is going to trend or not is the question.

The 60 min signal just gives a level - which says long above or short below. It doesn't give any stops or targets. This apparently has a success rate of around 65-70% - so they say. I don't know how they calculate that, since it doesn't give a stop or a target.

The 30 min gives a stop, target, new entry and volatility.

If you do buy it, I suggest you take trades based on the 60 min signals.

 

[rkkarnani]

Been using trade vinayak for sometime. It has 2 signals for Nifty based on 30 min and 60 min charts.

The 30 min signal isn't good enough. Keeps whipsawing. It will work well in a trending market but how to know if the market is going to trend or not is the question.

The 60 min signal just gives a level - which says long above or short below. It doesn't give any stops or targets. This apparently has a success rate of around 65-70% - so they say. I don't know how they calculate that, since it doesn't give a stop or a target.

The 30 min gives a stop, target, new entry and volatility.

If you do buy it, I suggest you take trades based on the 60 min signals.

Vasu, Welcome to the Forum ! How did 60 min. go for your trading?

 

[arvvasu]

Thanks Rkkarnani. I haven't been following trade vinayak very well, though I paid for it. I am trying out my own method of trading.

My observation is that 60 min signals are relatively ok. The 30 min signals are horrendous, keeps whipsawing.