General Trading Chat

[stock72]

From 8100 to 8740 ...good run ..guess some rest need

 

[Jai Mata Di]

Is there Freedom of Speech in India(biggest democratic country)?

My valuable comment about market sentiment, got deleted probably because it was with a heading 'Finance Minister is not confident enough to face Live Market' during Budget Presentation. :annoyed:

I think there is Freedom of speech in India. India called the biggest democratic country. But probably TJ moderators think otherwise.

We are traders. We must have freedom to comment freely about market sentiment on various financial situations(like Budget & Rate Cut) in a trading forum(new SEBI Rule don't prevent us to do so, pretty aware of the Rules :lol.

I think there was nothing wrong in my comment which got deleted by Strict Head Master. Can delete this one too.

If now rules in TJ are changed, then TJ admin must clearly say what are the rules, so that we don't waste our valuable time writing here. Without giving the cause, deleting a valuable post for other trader friends is pretty irritating.

Number of Good participants on TJ are decreasing everyday, because of restricting Freedom of Speech recently every now and then(without any valid reasons :annoyed. TJ admin must think of it [give a proper reason(mention objectionable part) before deleting a good post].

I am seriously considering visiting TJ very less, bcoz spending time in TJ is not entertaining as before.

Best Wishes to ALL & Happy Trading.

H.C.

 

[sudoku1]

Re: Is there Freedom of Speech in India(biggest democratic country)?

My valuable comment about market sentiment, got deleted probably because it was with a heading 'Finance Minister is not confident enough to face Live Market' during Budget Presentation. :annoyed:

I think there is Freedom of speech in India. India called the biggest democratic country. But probably TJ moderators think otherwise.

We are traders. We must have freedom to comment freely about market sentiment on various financial situations(like Budget & Rate Cut) in a trading forum(new SEBI Rule don't prevent us to do so, pretty aware of the Rules :lol.

I don't think there was nothing wrong in my comment which got deleted by Strict Head Master. Can delete this one too.

If now rules in TJ are changed, then TJ admin must clearly say what are the rules, so that we don't waste our valuable time writing here. Without giving the cause, deleting a valuable post for other trader friends is pretty irritating.

Number of Good participants on TJ are decreasing everyday, because of restricting Freedom of Speech recently every now and then(without any valid reasons :annoyed. TJ admin must think of it [give a proper reason(mention objectionable part) before deleting a good post].

I am seriously considering visiting TJ very less, bcoz spending time in TJ is not entertaining as before.

Best Wishes to ALL & Happy Trading.

H.C.

agree wid d red.:thumb:

It wud b fair enough if d post as a whole stays there bt d illicit text /images are blurred wid d reason tag at d bottom

 

[raul12]

Very well said Jai Mata Di.

I believe The moderator should open a new thread or something and list all the rules there for everyone to read. The Moderator can keep updating that thread will latest and current rules time and again as the need be.

Also there should be a brief information message which need to be shared with the members explaining why the Post is reported as inappropriate.

P.S: None of my posts have been reported/deleted so far but I have been reading about deletion of posts of few senior members which is resulting in irritation amongst them.

Hope the mods take some action for the benefit of the TJ family! :thumb:

 

[cloudTrader]

Blessed R those who giv without remembering. N blessed r those who take without forgetting .

True , I didn't forget the contribution of Traderji ...that is what matters the most ..

 

[cloudTrader]

There is nothing new except what has been forgotten.
.

The ID is new ..

 

[sabharwal_RK]

There is a news that the Budget will be presented on 28th Feb.which is a Saturday. So unless BSE/NSE keep a special budget trading session on Saturday, we have to see gap up/down on Monday. They should have presented on Friday 27th Feb as usual....but some changes this year it seems.Normally budget is presented on a working day.

Smart_trade

I remember an instance where budget was on saturday and trading was allowed to be conducted on Saturday....

 

[kiran_thiru]

Re: Is there Freedom of Speech in India(biggest democratic country)?

My valuable comment about market sentiment, got deleted probably because it was with a heading 'Finance Minister is not confident enough to face Live Market' during Budget Presentation. :annoyed:

I think there is Freedom of speech in India. India called the biggest democratic country. But probably TJ moderators think otherwise.

We are traders. We must have freedom to comment freely about market sentiment on various financial situations(like Budget & Rate Cut) in a trading forum(new SEBI Rule don't prevent us to do so, pretty aware of the Rules :lol.

I think there was nothing wrong in my comment which got deleted by Strict Head Master. Can delete this one too.

If now rules in TJ are changed, then TJ admin must clearly say what are the rules, so that we don't waste our valuable time writing here. Without giving the cause, deleting a valuable post for other trader friends is pretty irritating.

Number of Good participants on TJ are decreasing everyday, because of restricting Freedom of Speech recently every now and then(without any valid reasons :annoyed. TJ admin must think of it [give a proper reason(mention objectionable part) before deleting a good post].

I am seriously considering visiting TJ very less, bcoz spending time in TJ is not entertaining as before.

Best Wishes to ALL & Happy Trading.

H.C.

 

[Smart_trade]

Re: Is there Freedom of Speech in India(biggest democratic country)?

My valuable comment about market sentiment, got deleted probably because it was with a heading 'Finance Minister is not confident enough to face Live Market' during Budget Presentation. :annoyed:

I think there is Freedom of speech in India. India called the biggest democratic country. But probably TJ moderators think otherwise.

We are traders. We must have freedom to comment freely about market sentiment on various financial situations(like Budget & Rate Cut) in a trading forum(new SEBI Rule don't prevent us to do so, pretty aware of the Rules :lol.

I think there was nothing wrong in my comment which got deleted by Strict Head Master. Can delete this one too.

If now rules in TJ are changed, then TJ admin must clearly say what are the rules, so that we don't waste our valuable time writing here. Without giving the cause, deleting a valuable post for other trader friends is pretty irritating.

Number of Good participants on TJ are decreasing everyday, because of restricting Freedom of Speech recently every now and then(without any valid reasons :annoyed. TJ admin must think of it [give a proper reason(mention objectionable part) before deleting a good post].

I am seriously considering visiting TJ very less, bcoz spending time in TJ is not entertaining as before.

Best Wishes to ALL & Happy Trading.

H.C.

Though I have not seen the subject post so I do not know the contents of it. But the heading of the post probably indicates what was the content.

We are a public forum and we must behave responsibly. Just because the budget presentation is kept on Saturday does it indicate 'Finance Minister is not confident enough to face Live Market'.There could be some other compulsions which you and we do not know ....and what confidence are you talking about ? Whether he presents the budget on Saturday or Sunday , if the budget is bad he will face the criticism on the media, TV,news and even markets when they open for trading.He has to face all that later, he cannot escape it. But we cannot pass judgements without knowing the reasons....the reasons will come in 1-2 days. NSE/BSE can keep special sessions on Saturday etc could be worked out....but criticising the central ministers in a public forum dedicated to trading is not proper.

There is a difference with a social forum and a forum like Traderji.If people think that it is their birth right to make allegations on constitutional functionaries then the forum does not support that thinking. There is no new rule but such post will not pass through old rules also.But even on social forums dont make such baseless allegations...it not only is in bad taste, it may land you in trouble with the law enforcing agencies....so beware

Let us think as responsible people and ask ourselves..." Is the deletion of a post accusing a Finance Minister of the country we come to the conclusion that spending time in TJ is not entertaining as before. " It will certainly not be any more entertaining if that is the idea of freedom which we have.

Smart_trade

 

[TracerBullet]

Re: Is there Freedom of Speech in India(biggest democratic country)?

'Finance Minister is not confident enough to face Live Market' during Budget Presentation. :annoyed:

The world does not revolve around the stock market. I think its importance is overstated.
Worrying about stock market is not Finance Minister's job, there are much more important things. ( But Maybe congress FM had to do index management )

Freedom of speech is also sadly not a given in India, say something that the self appointed cultural, political and religious leaders, the senas and the navnirman senas etc etc dont agree to and you get tamasha the next day without any major repurssion on them.