General Trading Chat

[Rehab]

Da !!!

He shared EMA pivots in his thread.. .it marks almost 80 % vis-a vis VP manual...aren't people expecting too much in the name of sharing from his hard work..


he also told in old post that that vp matchs upto 80%

if people really work hard then method can be learned if that hard work and learning is absent then AFL will also turn into another search engine

IF I were THAT SMART..mai yaa to Smart_trade hota yaa kam se kam XRAY28 hota bhai..
kuchh people ko Pipal ka zaad aur Imli ke zaad me ka difference tak nahi samaz me aata..I'm one of those people bhai

 

[Smart_trade]

My understanding is that 'discretion' is an essential part of IDF, Afl can mark pivots (at times approximately) but you can't take discretion out, it's not entirely mechanical.

Discretion in deciding whether we are in a trending phase or sideways phase.Rest of the things pretty mechanical....profit taking will come by experience.

ST

 

[vivektrader]

Discretion in deciding whether we are in a trending phase or sideways phase.Rest of the things pretty mechanical....profit taking will come by experience.

ST

That is a big 'Discretion', major cause of steep learning curve.
Most of us beginners get tossed around both ways in sideways.

 

[XRAY27]

IF I were THAT SMART..mai yaa to Smart_trade hota yaa kam se kam XRAY28 hota bhai..
kuchh people ko Pipal ka zaad aur Imli ke zaad me ka difference tak nahi samaz me aata..I'm one of those people bhai

ok sir ji point noted !!!

 

[arsh22g]

The code is looking something like this

Buy = Cross(StochK(14,14) , StochD(14,14,14)) AND C>MA(C,50);
Sell = Cross(StochD(14,14,14) , StochK(14,14)) AND C<MA(C,50);

But I dont have MCX Crude Oil Data with me I have NF data only.

Testing on NF data looks quite impressive, Pls see the attachment

There was one google drive with MCX data. But now it required access.

https://drive.google.com/folderview...dwb3EzZTM2UDBIM2oySzN2XzVHNkJlUFU&usp=sharing

yes.. it had huge database running in gb, so couldn download. now its not accessible.

I checked ur afl. in recent months data it gave 66% accuracy.

nifty spot result not impressive though. few stocks gave 20% accuracy, some 50%.
looks like it is more suited for crude only.

Thanks for following up on this :clapping:

Yes, it suits Crude only. Even on Pi, NS results weren't that great.

 

[vijkris]

Thanks for following up on this :clapping:

Yes, it suits Crude only. Even on Pi, NS results weren't that great.

thanks for clarification.

 

[lemondew]

Do we have any steps shared in deciding trending phase

1> Indicator 1
2> indicator 2

and so on

Discretion in deciding whether we are in a trending phase or sideways phase.Rest of the things pretty mechanical....profit taking will come by experience.

ST

 

[Smart_trade]

Do we have any steps shared in deciding trending phase

1> Indicator 1
2> indicator 2

and so on

Tried that with some trend indicators ,but the entry gets delayed considerably thereby diluting the edge. Our own eyes and VWAP bands work the best.

ST

 

[vivektrader]

Tried that with some trend indicators ,but the entry gets delayed considerably thereby diluting the edge. Our own eyes and VWAP bands work the best.

ST

Do you routinely use vwap bands when employing IDF for trading, or only
when in doubt 'visually'?

 

[Smart_trade]

Do you routinely use vwap bands when employing IDF for trading, or only
when in doubt 'visually'?

Most days are sideways and very few days are trend days. So start the day assuming that it is sideways on VWAP bands.Only when bands indicate trends, shift to trend mode.And in trends use pivots method.

ST