Going with the Intraday Mini-Flow!!

[manojkch]

Re: Miniflow Trades Today: Saint's Method

Rakesh,

I was indeed shocked that the mini-flow thread has been closed down What is even more upsetting is that this thread will not be online guidance but EOD discussions. Only when the person gains expertise he can effectively discuss.

I have been watching this thread for the last 3 months off & on when my husband was on it and found it interesting. He is no longer in the country and asked me to participate in my own ID.. I did papertrading for all these days but with money since last one week. There is a lot of difference in both. Application multi TF based rules need a lot of practice to locate and identify action. Initially this needs help of seniors.

I have seen your on line posts to saint for clarifying doubts but now you tell us come at EOD. What kind of pleasure will any one get in people making losses due to wrong decisions, while you and others seniors reap profits. Will any one like me be willing to lose money every alternate day and yet come to EOD discussions.

I request you to reconsider your decision and keep this thread alive on line so that in case of some intricate moves like muti reference to TFs the seniors may simply tell us what is to be done and discuss this in the EOD. We willnot interfere at all unless we have a problem. I donot find any thing wrong in only one senior indicating the SAR levels whenever they change. This will help us tally with our own decisions and make us more perfect.

Similarly you may advice lv gandhi to post the first min H & L. I see too many people posting this and add to clutter and at the end we follow lvg's levels only.

Since everyone like me is trading with real money and would like to make more please hold our hands for some time. After 6 months or so we become more confident individuals, you get bored, but many more new people get added on, then you may hand over the baton to some one else. And life will on

Pl look at my views which represent hundreds like me in righ earnest.

Chippu

Yes Chippu, I also agree with your suggestions. As rakesh sir pointed out about discussion at eod, I would suggest that before starting to discuss the trades at eod, any one menber , may be (Hari,Santosh, Alex, Rajendrani who are good at posting the chart )should take the responsibility to post the eod charts of the day for 15/20/30/60 min so that it will help ther readers and newcomers to understand the whole discussion. Also it will also be helpful for those who don't have access to NF charts ( without charts, it is very dificult to understand the things). Preferably , it would be better if the charts are posted with whitbackground instead of black,as white bakground is best for printing purpose.

I would have done the jod of posting 15/20/30/60 chart ,but I don't have access to NF charts. I am learner and learning through this thread. I am sure there are many who don't have access to NF charts ( reasons may be different for each one) but are learning this method seriously. This suggestion will be really helpful for all those.

Thanks & regards.
Manoj

 

[touchraj16]

Re: Saint's Intraday Miniflow - live discussion

Thanks a lot dear lvgandhi, hope this thread will gain more confidence in me n other new comers. Also, Please see if someone can post charts regularly every half / one hour charts. That will also help better. Thanks again.

touchraj

 

[ASHA SHUKLA]

Re: Miniflow Trades Today: Saint's Method

Dear All,
As the name suggests, this thread will be a place to share the trades as per Saint's miniflow method.....

Why start a new thread, when the original one can serve the same purpose? Well...a little introspection would make it clear to all of us about the reasons what made Saint so perturbed to take this step. I am not going to debate all the reasons here.

A few things need to be made clear about what this thread will do and what it wont do...and also what is expected from the members visiting this thread:

1. The aim of this threads is to make the newcomers conversant with correct application of Saints Miniflow method....without spoonfeeding them. It is expected that everyone visiting this thread is conversant with the rules stated by Saint in the main thread.

2. This thread will NOT be active during the market hours. I request everyone neither to post the levels for trades...nor seek guidance about what needs to be done at a particular price during the market hours.

3. The trades for a particular day would be posted in the evening so that every one learns and understands the correct application of the various rules.

4. Request to all members.....your queries regarding the trades taken are most welcome...but kindly desist from discussing your personal tweaks here. If you need to do that...you can do so via a PM to Saint or any senior member.

5. Queries would, time-permitting, be answered by me and a few other members who have been actively trading the system. For the moment...lets seek our answers from ST, Kapil, MJ, NC, MB. Of course, Saint would be here to guide us at all steps. As we go along..we would be looking up at you to take this thread ahead, so that we can just be with our own trades.

6. Kindly desist from any clashes/arguments in this thread. If you dont agree with anyones view..kindly ignore. A mess in this thread will lead to its closure....and that would be a loss for all of us.

Thats it.....hope I live up to your expectations.

Thanks a lot,
Rakesh

Thank you Rakesh for starting the new Daughter thread. What new comer like us wants that some seniors should post their trade after market hours( If possible with reason) so that we can compare our trades with correct one and learn day by day. It is not possible for Saint Sir or any senior to spoon feed the juniors. I think you people have made great sacrifices and should not be compelled to continue to do the same. We have to survive in the market with little guidance from seniors and it is our responsibility to learn if we want to succeed. It is not the responsibility of Saint Sir or seniors to teach us.
More over happening in the last few days were very much disgusting and any sensible person will not tolerate them. My only request to you seniors is to guide us like Light House on sea shore and sailors will recognise the source and take suitable decisions to change the direction of ship if they are wrong. Thank you.

 

[ASHA SHUKLA]

Re: Saint's Intraday Miniflow - live discussion

I felt after saint closing the thread intraday miniflow and Rakesh starting, as Saint desired, only EOD discussion on intraday, there is a need for a thread for live discussion regarding Pivots, SAR levels without room attached and nature of trade only for new comers to gain confidence. Hence this thread. It is not duplicating Rakesh thread. I request also seniors to air their view and guide if some posts are giving wrong direction, of course with gentle compassion.
This will help many newcomers to understand by hand holding as done in mother thread.
Don't comment on other's post sarcastically or with aim of becoming one up. Aim is to help newcomers for gaining confidence.

Thank you very much. Hope you will continue the great tradition of Saint Sir to guide the new comer and extend your experienced helping hand during market hours. Thanks once again

 

[debdeeps]

Re: Saint's Intraday Miniflow - live discussion

This was a real need for Mini flow particularly for new comers. Thanks lvgandhi for starting this thread. Will frequently visit this thread for clues.

 

[chippu]

Re: Saint's Intraday Miniflow - live discussion

Dear Chippu,
Most welcome.
I am doubtful whether I can ask somebody to stop posting and to decide who is senior or who is junior. Trading needs discipline in addition to skills. I feel with my experience 90% because of discipline only one can suvive in the markets.

lvg,

AS a moderator you have every right to define the rules for participation. You are not barring entry to any one. You will only be warning those who want put in their own views online and those who do chitchatting. Even thank you posts should not be allowed. Their is a button available for this. Pl form these rules and permit only seniors to post. You know who the seniors are who contribute. You can select them.

Chippu

 

[rkripal]

Re: Saint's Intraday Miniflow - live discussion

saint had said there will be no live discussion (during market hours). more over he had also said that without his presence people can misinterpret various aspects of the method.

so, this thread, handle with care.....

kripal

 

[lvgandhi]

Re: Saint's Intraday Miniflow - live discussion

lvg,

AS a moderator you have every right to define the rules for participation. You are not barring entry to any one. You will only be warning those who want put in their own views online and those who do chitchatting. Even thank you posts should not be allowed. Their is a button available for this. Pl form these rules and permit only seniors to post. You know who the seniors are who contribute. You can select them.

Chippu

I am not a moderator. Just a poster. Started. Let us wish for good. God will help us.

 

[lvgandhi]

Re: Saint's Intraday Miniflow - live discussion

saint had said there will be no live discussion (during market hours). more over he had also said that without his presence people can misinterpret various aspects of the method.

so, this thread, handle with care.....

kripal

Dear Kripal,
Yes. That is why this new thread not to pollute Original thread. Main aim As I said is to help newcomers gain confidence.

 

[gunavadhi]

Re: Saint's Intraday Miniflow - live discussion

I have due respect to Mr.saint and all seniors here. I have read intraday mini flow thread more than 10 times. But still i confused how to trade following that method. If some senior member post the trades with charts everyday with explanations why that trades were taken for about ten days then it will be clear how to follow miniflow. Will any seniors do this everyday for some time. Thankyou all.