how helpful these so called analysts(SMS call givers) are?

[daitya]

Don't know about so many experts but here is a summery of calls I am getting from somebody :-

disturbed devil (12/17/2007 10:06:43 AM): Short Nifty Future cmp 6018 or higher s/l 6037 target 5962
disturbed devil (12/17/2007 10:09:13 AM): Nifty future 5996
disturbed devil (12/17/2007 10:13:31 AM): use trailing stop now
disturbed devil (12/17/2007 10:14:49 AM): nifty fut 5990
disturbed devil (12/17/2007 10:17:23 AM): Nifty fut 5980
disturbed devil (12/17/2007 10:22:20 AM): nifty fut 5959
disturbed devil (12/17/2007 10:23:58 AM): NF 5948, it can go down upto 5900 levels cheers, hold with trailing stop
disturbed devil (12/17/2007 10:39:24 AM): ACC short cmp 1124 or higher s/l 1133 target 1110
disturbed devil (12/17/2007 10:40:37 AM): AACC 1116.25 use trailing stop now
disturbed devil (12/17/2007 10:48:40 AM): NF 5934
disturbed devil (12/17/2007 10:58:51 AM): MTNL short at cmp 191 or higher s/l 192 target 186
disturbed devil (12/17/2007 11:04:02 AM): MTNL 189.7
disturbed devil (12/17/2007 11:04:49 AM): MTNL 189.25

How do u get those calls?

 

[expertspeaks]

I have tried it once with Dharmesh Bhatt who claims to be the best technical analyst for 10k a month.. And second subscription was with Kaamdhenu.

Now things are not that rosy as they seem to be when you read the their calls next day on their webpages. Dharmesh usually deals only in Large Caps and mainly futures. He will not mention the calls which triggered stop loss(except one or two to increase the credibility), has absolutely no command on Midcaps and small caps. It is very easy to say next day "and the stock remain rangebound" that rangebound means that stop loss did not trigger but stock was below the buy price. Now think while dealing in future how much loss a diffrence of 2-3 rupees (in each "rangebound")stock can make.

Kaamdhenu is reasonaly priced with just RS. 1500 per month. Gives some great calls in between, specially for midcaps and small caps. But you do not know which call would be the great one when you are bombarded with 20 calls a day, and not to forget their favourite sentence in between" exit all intraday positions immediately".

Somebody has very well mentioned in this thread that they have to send calls as this is their business. Believe me it is such a headache to follow these calls and trade, that many times you will shut down your computer and vouch that you will never ever trade in this life.