By problem I meant it as confusion. Every intraday trader has his own strategy and which is far beyond the conception/s of position trade. As for today, Sunil rightly pointed out the 4315 level, but for me that was not my level to square off. Here the positional and intraday trader clashes. It creates confusion .. and as the intraday traders always are in toes, this clash results his anger even loss in trade. So it is better not to mix intraday trading with positional trading in one pot.
and yes, one bounce from good support level in over-sold condition has still not ended this short term downtrend; though it has given a breather to the intermediate uptrend (temporary or what, will be answered tomorrow)...
As of now, the stop for this short term downtrend, which has been forming LL LH since last Tuesday from 4650, is now yesterday's HOD (ie 4447).
This is where I appreciate Satyajit da's patience & experience with a trend. (Satyajit da, please never ever think that any of your posts or charts are unwanted - your hourly charts keep us informed about everything in one single thread).
He rightly mentioned that intraday trading posts (which is the main purpose of this thread) create noise/confusion in minds of positional traders - and there's an imminent clash between two mindsets. If one is bearish for short term, then it does not mean, one cannot anticipate/enter intraday reversals.
It's not that i am against positional trades/posts, but one should understand & realise that many of our trading posts are meant for intraday trading. I, myself, seldom carry forward any FUT position (i prefer optons for this). Asish da, himself, resisted from posting his positional trades here - and now I realise the reason behind it.
This confusion can only be avoided by someone if he knows/understands what is the timeline of his particular position a la Satyajit Da. If one is only a positional player with a bearish view, then one should leave these intraday bounces to scalpers/intraday trades, etc. In fact, I would add, that if one is very clear abt the bearish short term view (for eg), then one should add more short positions on such intraday bounces a la Saint sir.
Realise whether a particular post is for a 5 min trade or a 60 min trade, and trade/ignore according to your own mindset & position.
As of now, the stop for this short term downtrend, which has been forming LL LH since last Tuesday from 4650, is now yesterday's HOD (ie 4447).
This is where I appreciate Satyajit da's patience & experience with a trend. (Satyajit da, please never ever think that any of your posts or charts are unwanted - your hourly charts keep us informed about everything in one single thread).
He rightly mentioned that intraday trading posts (which is the main purpose of this thread) create noise/confusion in minds of positional traders - and there's an imminent clash between two mindsets. If one is bearish for short term, then it does not mean, one cannot anticipate/enter intraday reversals.
It's not that i am against positional trades/posts, but one should understand & realise that many of our trading posts are meant for intraday trading. I, myself, seldom carry forward any FUT position (i prefer optons for this). Asish da, himself, resisted from posting his positional trades here - and now I realise the reason behind it.
This confusion can only be avoided by someone if he knows/understands what is the timeline of his particular position a la Satyajit Da. If one is only a positional player with a bearish view, then one should leave these intraday bounces to scalpers/intraday trades, etc. In fact, I would add, that if one is very clear abt the bearish short term view (for eg), then one should add more short positions on such intraday bounces a la Saint sir.
Realise whether a particular post is for a 5 min trade or a 60 min trade, and trade/ignore according to your own mindset & position.
and dearest satyajit da...
your hourly charts can NEVER confuse an intraday trader....
infact, postings of positional trades should not disturb any intraday trader in any way, i feel...
but yes, the reverse is true... intraday trades' posts do confuse / create noise for not-so-experienced positional traders
your hourly charts can NEVER confuse an intraday trader....
infact, postings of positional trades should not disturb any intraday trader in any way, i feel...
but yes, the reverse is true... intraday trades' posts do confuse / create noise for not-so-experienced positional traders
I would again say that it has never been intra vs positional for me...
satyaji da, czar, raj, i would always be happy if u post your positional/hourly charts here only... these up to date charts actually help an intraday trader, not confuse him.... we come to know whether most of our trades should be "buy on intraday dips" or "sell on intraday rallies".. It's only sometimes that when a particular level comes up, you have to indulge in a bit contra-trend intraday trading...
Asish da's FUT 4455 (recent example) came in handy to me 3 times in 2 days... and i used that level twice for selling and once for buying. Spot 4315 is again once such level - it's like a chokidar/watchman - never letting pass easilly.... it only gets broken by gap openigs....
So, i would request satyajit da, czar, raj & others to continue their positional trade sugestions here... but i will leave the ultimate decision to majority. I would really appreciate EVERYTHING about NIFTY here, so that all can benefit w/o having to look/search in other threads about nifty trading.
I am just emotionally attached to this thread, and I rarely post in other threads... If work is worship, then this thread, I feel, is like a temple built by a man who taught me to pray & do my karam (intraday trading).
[my "kiddin" yesterday was directed towards renu as answer to her "court cases", i didn't expect such emotional outburst from my friends - i am very sorry for such behaviour]
I would also request renu, milkyblack, debdeeps, devasish & above all, Asish da, to continue with their active intraday nifty trading guidance here.