project

[riya311]

i need a project on "comparitive analysis of brokerage houses".......
can sombody help me???



waiting for the reply..........

 

[d_s_ramesh]

'Comparative Analysis of Brokerage Houses', a good concept that you have selected. I feel that will be useful for many traders and investor as I know many of them need knowledge on this side.

We can work to find what you are willing to find. Give us a brief picture about the thoughts you have in mind, probably that will give more ideas and proceed in your work.

Thanks
D S Ramesh

 

[riya311]

hi.....
actually i m thinking of making comparison of religare,motilal oswal,unicon securities ltd.and two more companies with respect to brokerage,services provided by them..............







thanks
Riya

 

[d_s_ramesh]

Good work my suggestion would be to add more big ones, make a list like Investor friendly, trader friendly etc.

I think this is an useful project, I would like to join in your work. Since I am using icici and india infoline. I have details about them. I have friends who trade and invest using almost all the brokerage houses.

Lets take their help in getting the required data. And may I know the purpose of this work. Are you intending to publish this data or is it going to be used for ascertaining the results for personal use and sharing between friends. Or maybe it is somewhere related your subject of study.

If you would like to do this as a joint effort, please let me know. I would be privileged to work on this project.

 

[riya311]

i am a mba student ,and i need to submit a summer training project report.and i have selected this topic for the same.......

i will b happy if u help me in this.........

 

[d_s_ramesh]

Oh! that's nice. Sure I can help you, but would you tell me when is the schedule to submit the report. And also PM me your mail Id we shall start working from today itself.

One sincere request, we are joining in your endeavour in spite of having our regular works, so I request you to have the best use of the work.

 

[riya311]

i have to submit the report in the mid of sept.
my id is

[email protected]


sure.. i will make best use of this work.......
thanku...

 

[d_s_ramesh]

Lets begin the work!!! if we are motivated the work is half done, then passion and love for the work will do the rest. the final outcome will just be one joy ride of experiences.

 

[rkkarnani]

Lets begin the work!!! if we are motivated the work is half done, then passion and love for the work will do the rest. the final outcome will just be one joy ride of experiences.

You are awesome!!! :clapping:

 

[rkkarnani]

hi.....
actually i m thinking of making comparison of religare,motilal oswal,unicon securities ltd.and two more companies with respect to brokerage,services provided by them..............


thanks
Riya

Hi Riya, Ramesh has very kindly volunteered to help you. It is so nice of him. If you watch his posts on the Forum, you will know how busy he is and not to mention his own Trading and guidance.

Maybe you can begin by doing a Search in this Forum itself. Search for "Brokerage" (Titles only), you will get the Threads that have the word "brokerage" in it. Have a look in the proper thread for some material for your Paper.

One such Post I found , a 2008 Post :By Asish Lodhi
Here is the link : http://www.traderji.com/brokers-tra...ect-sharekhan-india-bulls-geojit-5-paisa.html

******************************************

Comparison between major brokerage firms


ICICI Securities HDFC Securities UTI Securities 5 Paisa (Indian Infoline) Indiabulls
Account Opening Charges Rs.750 Rs.750 Rs.600 Rs.750 Rs.500
Brokerage (%) Delivery Intraday Delivery Intraday Delivery Intraday Delivery Intraday Delivery Intraday
0.75 0.15 0.75 0.15 .80 .15 0.251 0.071 0.5 0.10
With all taxes and other charges per 100 0.92 0.19 0.92 0.19 0.97 0.19 0.87 0.12 0.64 0.12
Transaction Charges (selling) Rs.20 or 0.04% of transaction, whichever is more Rs.23 or 0.04% of transaction, whichever is more Rs.23 or 0.04% of transaction, whichever is more Rs.23 or 0.04% of transaction, whichever is more Rs.17
Exposure on Cash NIL 4 times NIL 4 times NIL NIL NIL NIL 2/4 times 12 times
Exposure on Securities NIL NIL NIL NIL 75% 0f the Market Value
Minimum Margin - - Rs.10,000 Rs.2,500 NIL
Annual Maintenance Charges Rs.350 Rs.500 Rs.250 Rs.300 NIL
Banking facility ICICI Bank HDFC UTI Bank - All Banks
Net Banking facility ICICI Bank HDFC UTI Bank - HDFC/ICICI/
Citibank
Charting NA NA NA Thru software2 Thru Software
Historical Data NA NA NA NA Available for the last 4-5 yrs & linked to the s/w
Intra day cut off time 3 pm 3 pm 3 pm 3 pm 3:10 pm
Relationship Manager N.A. N.A. NA NA Assigned to every client

* 1. The brokerage will be charged on the condition of Monthly fixed fee of Rs.800/- or Yearly Rs.8, 000/-. And whatever trading you did the brokerage will get deducted from this amount with the mentioned rate. I.e. you are require to trade approx volume of Rs.14, 00,000 per month to get the benefit of this already paid amount.

* 2. Only intraday[/SIZE][/SIZE][/SIZE]