Yes...are they well trained to do Technical Analysis. Assuming broker is not a fake firm, and if we deposit any amount is there any guarantee that they return atleast our principal ?? forget abt profit...
atherya, i think u r mixing broker and wealth/fund manager(including small, fake ones). icicidirect, sharekhan, zerodha etc each and every one who can facilitate you with a trading a/c is a broker.
what shivangi did for khushi was call-n-trade. Mainly 6 ways possible for trading - software based, web based, mobile app, micro website(LBS), offline office facility, call-n-trade. some broker provide all, some not. for ex- zerodha provide online, web based, mobile app, LBS microsite and over phone (call-n-trade). but at zerodha call-n-trade is chargeable (20rs/order).
benefit of call-n-trade option is that if u cant access system or there is a internet/system failure, then it come handy. for over phone or offline, broker have Dealers (RM also can do). They dont need to be a TA qualified, their duty is just to fill orders on client's behalf but needed to take consent from client. If they didnt took consent, and client deny the trade, then broker have to bear loss. But if they trade with consent or you trade and loose money, they have right to recover from you.
some brokers also provide fund management/trading facility for that they have separate department.