Volume Spread Analysis

[nimish_rulz]

Great thread and great post thanks Karthik sir and Bunny and everyone who is actively involved hope we make this a long lasting thread.

 

[nishant1011]

Hi santosh,

Which version of Ami are you using? That part of the afl does not work on older versions.

Anyway that part of the afl is used used to display the back ground text. You can delete that section and use the afl. If you still have problems please let me know.

Regards

HI Karthik,

Thanks for you wonderful thread. :clapping:

I am also using Ami 4.80 verson(as santosh). I have deleted some line as priscribed by u in on post as it was showing error 30. but it is not showing support and resistance line.

Have I done anything wrong?

thanks,
Nishant

 

[razzbarry]

I don't know if you have an answer yet or found the problem but error 30 is a syntax error. If the code is being developed on Ami release 5 or later that could be the problem or you may have something wrong on the line. I usually debug by eliminating part of the line until I find the error. If you can send the code I still have Ami 4.9 on my system and can see if I can find the error.

My email is razzbarry at imageview dot us

Cheers
Barry

 

[razzbarry]

I am new to this forum and I can't find a way to start a thread so I am replying to the first message. Maybe that is for the VSA thread.

Is this thread still being used? I see the most recent post was in Nov 09. If it is still being used I have a couple of questions.

Where can I find the latest version of the AmiBroker VSA formula. I found what I think are errors, since I am new to VSA the error I found may be me.

What is a pseudo upthrust and what information does it provide?

Is there a download area and if so where is it?

Thanks,

Barry

 

[niksos]

hello everyone,
i dint have time to go through the entire thread. anyways let me add my view on VSA.
well vsa is nothing new and always has been there, it was kept a close secret among the syndicate brokers untill recent past. Most of the professional money/smart money manipulate the market based on VSA.
No matter what anyone says, once u can learn a bit about VSA then ur sure to crack in profits i.e having a trading mind is essential to become successful no matter what system is followed.
And calling VSA a advanced trading system is a under statement, in my view its the way in which the markets are moved by the professional money.
And coming to my story, i entered the markets with a lot of indicators on my indicators and etc etc and i WIPED OUT 15% of my account in 3 trading days. I abandoned all trading activity and have been studying VSA since a few months.

If anyone wants the book on VSA written by the guy who brought these principals to the common trader the one and only TOM WILLIAMS then let me know.

Thanks,
Nik.

 

[niksos]

and i also suggest everyone to read the book TRADING IN THE ZONE by MARK DOUGLAS. its about training ur mind to be a successful trader, a must read for every full time trader.

 

[sumotrader]

Is VSA a lot different from how OBV works?

 

[bunny]

Is VSA a lot different from how OBV works?

OBV = On Balance Volume?

If so, certainly. OBV is just one of the common technical indicators.

VSA is an entire trading system/approach like technical or fundamental analysis.

 

[sikandar]

OBV = On Balance Volume?

If so, certainly. OBV is just one of the common technical indicators.

VSA is an entire trading system/approach like technical or fundamental analysis.

Hi bunny
How one can one develope a trading system with vsa perspective.please add some insights.

 

[trading4p]

Hi NIksos i would like a copy of the book. If it's in pdf please provide the link. :thumb:

hello everyone,
i dint have time to go through the entire thread. anyways let me add my view on VSA.
well vsa is nothing new and always has been there, it was kept a close secret among the syndicate brokers untill recent past. Most of the professional money/smart money manipulate the market based on VSA.
No matter what anyone says, once u can learn a bit about VSA then ur sure to crack in profits i.e having a trading mind is essential to become successful no matter what system is followed.
And calling VSA a advanced trading system is a under statement, in my view its the way in which the markets are moved by the professional money.
And coming to my story, i entered the markets with a lot of indicators on my indicators and etc etc and i WIPED OUT 15% of my account in 3 trading days. I abandoned all trading activity and have been studying VSA since a few months.

If anyone wants the book on VSA written by the guy who brought these principals to the common trader the one and only TOM WILLIAMS then let me know.

Thanks,
Nik.