Zerodha - Number One Discount Broker in India

[Zerodha]

Thanks!
The real query was whether the AMC of Rs. 1021.21 due will be waived off as not one trade was done ever.

Chirag, This is IL&FS who charges for this.. If you can send an email out to [email protected], with this as a request, we will forward it to ILFS and see what can be done..

Also keep [email protected] in cc

 

[Zerodha]

Are you kidding me?

Have you compared a decent Charting application like esignal/tradestation with charts in NEST trader?

Not only is NSE lagging behind in technology , but so are the brokers. This is very clear now.

As I said throway, comparing esignal to NEST is comparing a porsche to a civic.

What I am trying to say is, if the idea is to drive at 40km/hr, a civic is good enough...

Definitely not comparing, but most people that we have seen, use charts to only see charts, which is not the purpose of a charting software...

 

[blisscapital]

We have actually done this on Zerodha margins:

http://zerodha.com/margin-calculator/Futures/

Can you see stocks in red, those are the ones in ban period..

you should flash such messages in trading terminal like u flash msg for options on expiry day.

 

[throwawayacc123]

Definitely not comparing, but most people that we have seen, use charts to only see charts, which is not the purpose of a charting software...

I must be doing something wrong with the charts then...

Care to explain what is the real purpose of a charting software?

 

[Zerodha]

@zerodha its asking mobile trading login ...tried login credentials of ZT but no use

Your trading ID at Zerodha is the same across all platforms including EXE, web, and mobile. What you need to know is where your account is enabled. If you are enabled on NOW, you cannot login to the Zerodha Mobile platform.

If your account is on ZT like you mention, please share your login details with us to [email protected] and [email protected]. We'll look into it.

 

[Zerodha]

Yes, we open website in mobile the "Download" Button appeared, but not appearing when we open in CPU......

Application looks like same as old one.............

Trader J - yes, the application looks like the same old one but this is totally upgraded to work better and respond faster. Yes, the download button appears depending on which device you use to access the mobile platform download page.

 

[Zerodha]

I must be doing something wrong with the charts then...

Care to explain what is the real purpose of a charting software?

It is a personal view, but I guess the real purpose of technical analysis and a charting software, with your ami's meta's etc is the ability to be able to code your technical analysis strategies, be able to backtest them under various market conditions, run multiple strategies at the same time so you get the power to watch not 1/2 chart but maybe 20 at a time which is humanly not possible. Some of the latest softwares have pattern recognition, and neural networks, which even go to the extent of using Artificial intelligence to predict the winning probability of the next signal...

But there are brilliant traders, who just read the tape, that is just look at a chart, market depth and trigger some fantastic trades..

What I was trying to say was, if the idea is to look at a chart, add a couple of Moving average lines, a RSI, and look at candles, it is probably not financially viable to spend 30k on a software and then pay 4k/month on data feeds.
As I said earlier, that would be like buying a porsche and driving at 60km/hr.

 

[nithxp]

Your trading ID at Zerodha is the same across all platforms including EXE, web, and mobile. What you need to know is where your account is enabled. If you are enabled on NOW, you cannot login to the Zerodha Mobile platform.

If your account is on ZT like you mention, please share your login details with us to [email protected] and [email protected]. We'll look into it.

Im using ZT only but How can i share the login details?? U meant to say User id ??

 

[Zerodha]

Im using ZT only but How can i share the login details?? U meant to say User id ??

Getting someone to call u, your USER id is on PM

 

[throwawayacc123]

It is a personal view, but I guess the real purpose of technical analysis and a charting software, with your ami's meta's etc is the ability to be able to code your technical analysis strategies, be able to backtest them under various market conditions, run multiple strategies at the same time so you get the power to watch not 1/2 chart but maybe 20 at a time which is humanly not possible. Some of the latest softwares have pattern recognition, and neural networks, which even go to the extent of using Artificial intelligence to predict the winning probability of the next signal...

But there are brilliant traders, who just read the tape, that is just look at a chart, market depth and trigger some fantastic trades..

What I was trying to say was, if the idea is to look at a chart, add a couple of Moving average lines, a RSI, and look at candles, it is probably not financially viable to spend 30k on a software and then pay 4k/month on data feeds.
As I said earlier, that would be like buying a porsche and driving at 60km/hr.

So you are talking about the features of a charting application.

What i m trying to say that it is very hard to find a charting application to even draw basic trend lines and other lines tools for the indian markets.

Ami is worst charting app for price action traders, its good for mechanical system traders who prefer to trade on buy/sell signals. So only alternative left is esignal, because they provide data for indian markets. if you try to use the line tools , you can see how messed up Amibroker.


I currently use esignal and i only use line tools with it . I do not use any other feature(EFS programming ,back testing..etc). I do use replay feature, but that should be a part of any TA software. Esignal has made it very easy to use line tools and trust me i have used/tested every possible TA software out there before settling with esignal. Only issue is the price. But there is simply no alternative in the current market.

I also tried using charts in NEST trader, but its a joke.

Do you know any decent charting application that is easy to use for price action traders with reliable data feed?