Zerodha Part 2

[prabit]

Currently, you CAN'T directly transfer funds from NSE to MCX. You should first transfer to your bank account and then transfer back again to the relevant exchange segment (MCX etc..)

This should be a feature which Zerodha should add to their to-do list.

And this process will cost you RS20 and 2 days. Ofcourse if you have a/c in hdfc, I think it will same day and no cost, zerodha will confirm.

 

[veekay304]

And this process will cost you RS20 and 2 days. Ofcourse if you have a/c in hdfc, I think it will same day and no cost, zerodha will confirm.

Any deposit to Zerodha will attract Rs. 9+service tax (approx Rs. 11 total). No charges for withdrawl, if I am right.. Hence the total outgo is approx Rs.11, asuming one withdrawl and one deposit

 

[Zerodha]

Unable to see my limits and trading account balance from ZTrader web platform(all showing zeros and no holdings are displayed)
and backoffice platform is down ??

Anyone else facing same issues ??

Superman, we might be running testing on weekends, when you may not be able to check these..

 

[Zerodha]

Zerodha ,

I'm bit confused regarding my client id .... earlier I had NOW user ID and Backoffice ID same.


after ZT migration I find .... Backoffice userid , ZT userid are different.


Query 1 : Is it normal ? Is not both of them should have been similar ?

Query 2: If your executive asks for Client Id which ID I should provide ? ZT / Backoffice ?

On the backoffice, for example if my id is HODS0001, you can login to bo with both HODS0001 and DS0001.. Ideally just use DS0001 for both trading and backoffice..

Mention either of the id's to our executive he will know..

 

[Zerodha]

IL&FS has updated my a/c balance ....now they have a due to me !! .....They have updated a/c suddenly after 6 months and bill to be paid is -negative now


But real trouble is ...Delivery trading with Zerodha is not recommended ....reason is ... they don't have facility to generate Profit/Loss Report for Equity Segment in their backoffice software :annoyed:

You'll never know whether you are in profit or loss in Delivery trading with Zerodha....also will be inconvenient for tax calculation later....We don't have time to purchase separate tools and generate these reports externally from ECN.....normally all broker's provides P/L reports........Zerodha should seriously think about upgrading their back office.



Zerodha To Do List
-------------------
Zerodha Trader HTML version. - [medium priority]
Zerodha Mobile Platform. - [highest priority]
Zerodha Bracket Order facility for Equities. - [medium priority]
Zerodha BackOffice upgrade - [highest priority]

I don't think Zerodha would require a NSE approval for last one ....its a long pending work by Zerodha

There is a link called volume analysis which shows you the p&L..

 

[Zerodha]

actually in this letter I got new login id...so migration to ZT seems complete ...although RMS not showing any money in account , however little is left.....
and there are two separate accounts shown for mcx and nse.....I guess there is no need to maintain two capitals in ZT, for mcx and nse ....?...

Yes commodity and equity has to be kept separate as per exchange regulation.. Transfer between equity to Commodity, we want to enable, but the exchanges are not approving this process anymore.. If you'd see all the big brokers in the country have already stopped this.. We are working on any loophole without going against the exchange regulation..

 

[Zerodha]

i am having problem in cover order.say i place a cover order buy when banknifty is 11540 with a sl of 11500.the buy triggered at 11540. and i can see my sl order at 11500 in order book.in the order book when i try to modify i can modify the sl cover order to any rate between 11500 to 11540.say now the rate is 11580.now i want to trail the sl order.when i modify the sl oder to any rate above my buy price 11540 the order is accepted but when i check the order book again only the order i placed which is below 11540 is there.that is when i want to trail my sl to 11560, the order is accepted but when i check the order book again only the order i placed which is below 11540 is there. even when i tried to trail my sl to 11540.10 too, the order is accepted but when i check the order book again only the order i placed which is below 11540 is there.when contacted zerodha customer care, they asked me to click on EXIT in the order book.when i do that the position is sold at 11580.now i cant book the upward movement if the rate goes to 11600.if any traders experience this? sachin pl clarify this and dont neglect this problem as usual you doing to my user id..

Kumudhan, don't neglect your query, am down with a viral and half the team is on a holiday and hence the delay in replying..

Have forwarded this query of yours and will post it as soon as I have the answer..

 

[dashr]

Kumudhan, don't neglect your query, am down with a viral and half the team is on a holiday and hence the delay in replying..

Have forwarded this query of yours and will post it as soon as I have the answer..

Sachin, take rest buddy. Don't work in front of the screen till you recover. Get well soon. :thumb:

 

[shiv2012]

Anyone facing issue with the Intraday charts? I am getting a blank screen for the past few days. Historical charts were never there right from the beginning, but for the last few days the intra day chart is not showing up.. Can someone help?

 

[abliss_ready]

Hi Zerodha,

Today I made a short sell of few stocks using MIS order.. I expected the positions to get auto squared off at 3.20 pm but it did not happen..Can I please know the reason. When and for what price will the stocks be bought in an auction..

Can you please throw more light on the auction process. Does is happen during the market hours? The stock will be bought at market price? what is the penalty?how much margin will be blocked till the short sold stock are bought in the auction.

Thankfully the short position was squared-off without loss(other than charges like delivery STT).

From what I have read on the net, losses/penalty can be upto 20% if there are no buyers in the auction(Should not happen for a liquid stock)