Status
Not open for further replies.

Zerodha

Well-Known Member
need advice about your "link to excel" feature.

followed steps. Works fine. The rates update on the same column instead on a new row and new column.

the idea was to have chart displayed with this feature in excel itself.

any ideas?
Once data is on excel, you can write a program to capture this data...There is nothing wrong with it as long as you are doing this for your personal use, unfortunately we can't tell you how to do this, because apparently then it becomes a business interest for us... It is a very simple task, there are a few vendors selling you a plugin as well, which can fetch data from this and convert it to a format which can be used on popular charting tools....

Cheers...
 

CASPER

Well-Known Member
Respectinvestor...,

Your earlier post was much elaborate and I get what you are trying to Convey ..:thumb:

Am i Hurt ..., Oh !! No Definitely Not....:D, I was Just Seeking Some Clarifications

Regards,

Dear @CASPER
did you really understand what I was trying to convey or you just gave up..I do not know really...at the same time I hope I did not hurt you in any way..look here...I am a full time share trader and life of a trader is very lonely...although I had made an account in traderji way back in 2006 I think.... I was never active...facebook and now traderji are useful distractions from my activities 80% of which is spent on a terminal....and I have seen this market for quite long...so since I have started posting very recently...I am unable to stop myself from writing whenever I find that facts are being presented in a twisted form...I want people to be understand the realities of trading and not the imaginary or illusionary aspects of it which some people try to convey for their own benefit....Happy Trading and Best of Luck...Regards...
 

2021

Active Member
Zerodha is improving typing skills of many here with so many essay type replies. :D

As someone suggested earlier, I too wish if Zerodha can bring down FnO charges for percentage based users at rs 10 per lot if they (customers) agree. All who choose % slab are small investors and buying 1 ITM option or 1 lot future is too costly in compare to RKG. Zerodha should actually work on this idea as during this high volatile market options are profitible more than equities. Damn I couldn't buy those puts.
 
R

respectinvestor

Guest
What the!!! What's this about?

Did I address the post to you specifically? I don't think so...

Was there something wrong done in posting two of MY OWN CONTRACTS from two different brokers to show why I'm happy with Zerodha? No, I have the right to my opinion.

Is there something wrong with me running a thread here on TraderJi? No, TraderJi allows me to do so freely as it is an open forum.

Then why is it that you're so objectively orchestrating a baseless personal attack against me?

Yes I have been paying 5 paisa per leg, is that a crime... yes it is a "crime" against me but definitely not against you, or others in the trading community. The only reason that I pay for it is because when I negotiated the brokerage I ended up getting delayed quotes and some other rubbish from them along with lower brokerage... but what has that got to do with you and how is it a question on my "credibility"???

Reading the contract... now here's something else that you've got wrong, the loss on the trade is just because of a loosing trade and it does not depend on the brokerage firm, you place a right trade and you win you place a wrong trade and you loose... it's that simple. The brokerage is just part of the costs you pay for the trade and anyone sane would like to minimize these costs so as to be able to save on costs. Lower or higher brokerage costs are just something that help with overall costs of trading/investing. You don't seem to have every traded or invested in anything, else you would know such a basic thing.

You personally attack me and you're questioning my credibility!?!? You credibility definitely went out the window the second you decided to be both rude and judgmental, without a shred of evidence about me or the work that I do. You work for a broking firm and you're taking about credibility while criticizing, spamming and harassing other members on the forum and another credible broker? It's clear that it's your job to do what you're doing on the forum, sadly you have a moral less, ethic less and a foolish job and existence when you have to exist as a egomaniac, who has to concoct stories and baseless slander about others just to be noticed.

Now to some of your other senseless "points". You could have done better than just reading 2 lines of our intro on our thread. I'm an individual who trades/invests and along with my wife we make a couple, who both trade/invest... is that simple enough for you to understand? I'm here with my real name and my real self, unlike you and your phoniness with a name like 'respectinvestor' and your utter disrespect for everyone here. I do not wish for people to follow me as there is no benefit in it for me, everything on my thread is free, we post our views for the pleasure of it and to encourage other traders & investors by letting them know that it is possible to be a successful trader/investor. To give back, is something that you would not know I'm sure.

Reasons to follow us on our thread are not clear from this contract (it doesn't have to be as it's a contract to illustrate brokerage charged), they're in-fact clear from the hundreds (that's right hundreds) of posts that we've posted here, which if you would have read, it would have been very clear to you what credibility is all about.

Was it a position that was carried over? That does not make any sense, now if you knew how to read a contract, you would be able to see that it was also squared off. The contract is from a day trading system that I'm testing, I'm testing something or the other continuously to improve... you'd know that if you were a real trader/investor. Most of my positions (about 80%) are positional trades (you would know that if you'd invested in reading my thread intro completely or any of my posts) and I trade using ShareKhan now as I have paid an advance brokerage amount and I make use of their charting a little too for entry and exit points and iBulls as they have the quickest interface. I'll be shifting all my trades to Zerodha once I'm done with the advance brokerage paid, probably in a month or so, so until then just the testing on the Zerodha platform... which I'm very comfortable with. All this must be SO complicated to your little defensive mind.

Now for some more credibility, for that you'd have to read the many thank you posts from our thread readers and many of our pm's where people request for more posts and information... or according to you they must all be wrong as you're so superior and above all of us and you somehow understand something that does not exist in reality but is just in your own imaginary mind.

How did you go from and example of brokerage charged to all this? Maybe you just like to build castles in the air in your little imaginary world, or probably you're just an egomaniac who thinks that the whole world revolves around you and for some reason other members need to consult with you before they like a page, or before they post anything or before they twitch in their seats. Funny enough that you like someone's post while you disagree with them and are attacking them... weird!

Credibility is something you lack and made it amply clear in your posts and now in your post directed specifically at me, where you've targeted me deliberately and without any reason and that shows your lack of respect of others too. The funny thing here is that you're here with a phoney name called "Respect Investor" and a superiority complex with which you just disrespect everyone and everything (pretty much what every other broker other than Zerodha does, just like you're being paid to do so here by your employer).

Now let me give you some advise to make yourself better, what you could have done is take someone's post as being informative, learn something from it, like the many wonderful members at TraderJi do and as I do, and lived an infinitely better life. But you had to be rude and ridicule yourself in-front of everyone here. It's a privilege to be able to interact with such a wide variety of people and to be educated enough to do so, but it's very clear that you've not developed a a shred of decency by interacting with others or by educating yourself.

Well good luck with all of you, because it's just you who has to live with yourself.

I'm done with the discussion and had enough of your foolishness (surprising that it was our very first interacting :lol:).
@ Ravi Chandra:

Yes dear my posts did attack you deliberately because:

1.)by your own admission you are paying 5 paisa as brokerage with Share Khan and posted a contract note in which you were charged @ 10 paisa by Indiabulls....(so you contradict youself in the very first line of your reply)...and you negotiated these charges after being a trader/investor for 4 years.....and you want people to believe this crap? I seriously doubt your intentions behind paying 10 paisa as brokerage as nowadays 3 paisa/4 paisa is the norm:D

2.)I feared the rise of another Jessi Livermore and Rakesh Jhunjhunwaala and after seeing your back tasted results in Zerodha as well as Indiabulls (you lost more than Rs. 4000 in two lots of Nifty) my resolve to stop you from making more money from the markets got further strengthened .....and after realising how you can make others also super rich like you ..through back testing.... I decided that I must stop this person from making people richer:clap::clap:

3.)You are present in traderji by own name...you do not have fake identity...and I have a fake identity because I fear that after backtesting your superb results you will start a news letter asking people to subscribe to it @Rs. 500 per month..and so I have a fake identity because once people start calling you by real name it gets personal and difficult to say no to such get rich soon package...:clapping::clapping:

4.) I have seen more than enough of your variety...unable to make money yourself start advisory services ...I take this privilege to ask you to post your transaction statement for last three months where it will be revealed how much you made throgh backtesting....and I bet results will be similar to one you posted...and you can't do it...and you will have enough reasons not to tell to the world how profitable your strategies have been:D

baby...I appreciate your enthusiasm ....at the same time read my entire posts and then come to any type of conclusion...I have written logical things...earlier you understand them....better for your trading....Happy Trading and Regards:thumb:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads