Zerodha....

[respectinvestor]

@ ZERODHA...

From what I could make out from your ealier post ..you have intra-day
leverage in call options and put options also...@40% of margin required to carry on these positions overnight...(its applicable when a sell position is also taken)....JUST wanted to listen it from horse's mouth once again...kindly reconfirm....

You simply do not realise how much difference you have bought to the mindset of trading community....now everyone can tell his existing broker if they can do it why not you? ultimately benefitting even people not associated with Zerodha also...You have heralded a revolution :clap::clap:

Regards

 

[Newbie Day-Trader]

@ZERODHA.....

Great work in terms of reduction in brokerage...:thumb:

and now that you have given a new meaning to the term brokerage...

we demand everything from you.....

why not charge stamp duty .002% even though karnataka govt. levies .01% or rs.50 whichever is lower...

why not give a charting platform like Amibroker or Metastock even though subscription to them costs anywhere from 15000-40000 :annoyed:

We expect you to do social service by giving freebies to some newbies....so that they neither pay stamp duty, get a wonderful charting platform @ zero cost....it would be better still if you charge zero brokerage from them...but again who will bear the statutory costs...we can make a pool and everyone contributes to it so that they trade for free...and since you yourself decided that you are going to charge so less who else but Zerodha to blame for raising our ambitions

Do it as soon as possible so that we get rid of someone who does not want to pay anything...and better still if you can contribute around 1 lac so that he can trade also:clapping::clapping::clapping:

When are you going to stop making fool of yourself?

Seriously, you've embarrassed yourself enough with your earlier arguments with Ravichandra, PGDIMES, Zerodha & others.

I've NOT asked Zerodha to pay Stamp Duty out of their own pockets, I've just asked for a possible workaround, if any such thing can be worked out, that's all. And as has been clear from your earlier posts, you just keep spouting off your non-sense without even trying to understand what the other person is saying :annoyed:

As for my MetaTrader comment, as you can see, it got a few Thank Yous because it's a WISH that most traders in India have, it's NOT a DEMAND & that's that.

And for your kind information, it was me who'd first suggested that Zerodha should merge both of its Pricing-Plans, A & B into a single "0.01% or Rs.20" Plan, which'll benefit not only the traders but it'll greatly benefit Zerodha as well to generate higher brokerage WITHOUT robbing its traders dry & you can see my explanation for it too. Here's the link - http://www.traderji.com/brokers-trading-platforms/47790-zerodha-427.html#post585738

You've nicknamed yourself "respectinvestor" but it seems that you don't believe in respecting other people & personally attack them as is visible a few pages back & try to unnecessarily pick fights with everyone. Good day.

 

[Zerodha]

@ ZERODHA...

From what I could make out from your ealier post ..you have intra-day
leverage in call options and put options also...@40% of margin required to carry on these positions overnight...(its applicable when a sell position is also taken)....JUST wanted to listen it from horse's mouth once again...kindly reconfirm....

You simply do not realise how much difference you have bought to the mindset of trading community....now everyone can tell his existing broker if they can do it why not you? ultimately benefitting even people not associated with Zerodha also...You have heralded a revolution :clap::clap:

Regards

@respect, little misunderstanding here...

For buying options you need the entire premium for both intraday and overnight...

For writing options, intraday margin required is 40% of overnight margin requirement... For overnight, you need the entire exchange stipulated margins.... When I say overnight, we mean 3pm everday, coz that is when we start running our intraday square offs... cheers..

 

[respectinvestor]

When are you going to stop making fool of yourself?

Seriously, you've embarrassed yourself enough with your earlier arguments with Ravichandra, PGDIMES, Zerodha & others.

I've NOT asked Zerodha to pay Stamp Duty out of their own pockets, I've just asked for a possible workaround, if any such thing can be worked out, that's all. And as has been clear from your earlier posts, you just keep spouting off your non-sense without even trying to understand what the other person is saying :annoyed:

As for my MetaTrader comment, as you can see, it got a few Thank Yous because it's a WISH that most traders in India have, it's NOT a DEMAND & that's that.

And for your kind information, it was me who'd first suggested that Zerodha should merge both of its Pricing-Plans, A & B into a single "0.01% or Rs.20" Plan, which'll benefit not only the traders but it'll greatly benefit Zerodha as well to generate higher brokerage WITHOUT robbing its traders dry & you can see my explanation for it too. Here's the link - http://www.traderji.com/brokers-trading-platforms/47790-zerodha-427.html#post585738

You've nicknamed yourself "respectinvestor" but it seems that you don't believe in respecting other people & personally attack them as is visible a few pages back & try to unnecessarily pick fights with everyone. Good day.

@New Born Trader:

Since you have used some words which shows you in great lights..I would like to clarify:

I stand by whatever I have written earlier and I have just stated the facts

I was just seconding your demands..even I want great charting facility,no stamp duty everything @Rs. 20 /trade..

I had just written about some newbie who wanted everything for free..but now since you have come in open I suppose its you who wants everything for free...:clapping::clapping:

You call yourself newbie...but rather you are a freebie...so I went a step ahead and asked Zerodha to contribute

Since you are a newly born trader it gives you privilege to brand anyone as annoying or a fool...at the same time you are unable to see how much fool you have made of yourself already:clap::clapping:

and why this conflict dear..even I want everything for free..I was just seconding your highly justified demands..

 

[respectinvestor]

@ New born trader:

Since you have speciifically mentioned Ravi Chandran, PGDIMES and ZERODHA I would like to clarify:

Ravi chandra: He never came back to the forum with his reply when I asked him to post his transaction statement for 3 months with his backtesting ..He used to pay 5 paisa with Share khan and posted a contract note in which he paid 10 paisa with Indiabulls...unfair comparison for sure...and he had also mentioned in his post that he is not posting his contract note with share khan because Indiabulls is better cost wise(so someone charging 10 paisa is more cost effective than someone charging 5 paisa):annoyed:

PGDIMES..well he is a really nice guy..a knowledgeable person..working hard and he had some genuine querries...I have read some of his post so I know he writes from his heart...his intentions were never to confront me ..he only wanted some clarification..thats it..and I like this person because of the effort he is taking to become a good trader ..I salute him..:clap:

@ ZERODHA...look here Zerodha is Sachin...so I know he understands each word of every sentence I write...he is one person who truly understands the message behind my humouristic remarks as well as the irony behind my statements..he has been in the markets long enough...and look at the ability of this man...he has been able to impress me enough even though I may have stated some unpleasant realities of trading world which no broker wants to discuss..

I had decided not to write essays any more ..but if I am compelled I will write..I write facts..sometimes unpleasant....

and you can write whatever you feel like...this is is a public forum...I respect your views about me and You should respect my views about u...that u r a freebie...so I asked Zerodha to contribute 1 lac(gift hampers)..so that you can trade...for stamp duty transaction charges..we will make a public fund so that u do not pay anything...how strange....I am fighting for you and you get annoyed:

 

[Trader J]

I got Brokerage Calculator....Thnaks

I wonder to see Transaction Charges as below

Cash Equity Rs 540 per Crore Instead of Rs 350 per crore

Future Rs 540 per Crore Instead of Rs 190 per Crore

Option Rs 8000 per Crore instead of Rs 5000 per Crore

Cost of Transaction Charges for One Lot of Nifty @ 5000 would be Rs 27 Instead of Rs 9.5, Its mean I have to pay Rs 8.75 per Lot of Nifty future Extra ( Rs 17.5 for Buy & Sale)

Please let me know if any wrong calculation....Thanks

 

[Newbie Day-Trader]

I was just seconding your demands..even I want great charting facility,no stamp duty everything @Rs. 20 /trade..

Further proof that you don't actually read others' posts & spout non-sensical straw man arguments. I've ALREADY said -

it's a WISH that most traders in India have, it's NOT a DEMAND & that's that.

I can't "demand" anything from Zerodha, I can only wish, request & suggest them, they may or mayn't deem it feasible for them & accordingly, may or mayn't agree on it & accordingly, I may or mayn't deem it profitable enough to trade with them but having said that Zerodha does so well on brokerage-front that SD mayn't be as big a factor but still that does NOT mean that further cost-optimization can't be considered.

I had just written about some newbie who wanted everything for free..but now since you have come in open I suppose its you who wants everything for free...

Since you are a newly born trader it gives you privilege to brand anyone as annoying or a fool...at the same time you are unable to see how much fool you have made of yourself already:clap::clapping:

Are you really this childish to not realize that so many people opposed your ridiculous arguments because all of your arguments were foolish!

Ravi chandra: He never came back to the forum with his reply when I asked him to post his transaction statement for 3 months with his backtesting ..He used to pay 5 paisa with Share khan and posted a contract note in which he paid 10 paisa with Indiabulls...unfair comparison for sure...and he had also mentioned in his post that he is not posting his contract note with share khan because Indiabulls is better cost wise(so someone charging 10 paisa is more cost effective than someone charging 5 paisa)

May be Mr. Ravi Chandra figured that there's no point arguing with you & non-sensical comments :rofl:
Other than that, he's covered all of your baseless arguments in one post & the number of thank yous he's received shows that many Traderji members agree with him which shows that most people here recognize that your attacks against him were baseless & pointless.
http://www.traderji.com/brokers-trading-platforms/47790-zerodha-445.html#post589229

PGDIMES..well he is a really nice guy..a knowledgeable person..working hard and he had some genuine querries...I have read some of his post so I know he writes from his heart...his intentions were never to confront me ..he only wanted some clarification..thats it..and I like this person because of the effort he is taking to become a good trader ..I salute him..

And the people you find worthy of your "salute", you refer to them by using mean words such as "distraction"? That's been used as a demeaning term. That gives us some idea of what "respect" stands for in your nick :rofl:
http://www.traderji.com/brokers-trading-platforms/47790-zerodha-441.html#post588557

@pgdimes..you are a useful distraction from my trading activity...

Here's PGDIMES having a laugh.....AT YOU.....& rightly so :rofl:
http://www.traderji.com/brokers-trading-platforms/47790-zerodha-442.html#post588565

@ ZERODHA...look here Zerodha is Sachin...so I know he understands each word of every sentence I write...he is one person who truly understands the message behind my humouristic remarks as well as the irony behind my statements..he has been in the markets long enough...and look at the ability of this man...he has been able to impress me enough even though I may have stated some unpleasant realities of trading world which no broker wants to discuss..

Oh, so now your love is pouring out for Zerodha, is it?

Here's you suggesting to go for other "tried & tested" brokers like ICICI (who've been overcharging their traders) & NOT with Zerodha.
http://www.traderji.com/brokers-trading-platforms/47790-zerodha-439.html#post588227

let their system mature a bit...till then try to stick with tried and tasted....

Here's you suspecting Zerodha of flooding the forum to fake members to get good reviews.
http://www.traderji.com/brokers-trading-platforms/47790-zerodha-440.html#post588372

it creates a doubt in my mind whether someone has purposely foated this forun and giving great reviews.....

http://www.traderji.com/brokers-trading-platforms/47790-zerodha-441.html#post588515
Here's you accusing Zerodha of "acting smart".

I have seen a tendency on part of ZERODHA to act smart when someone is putting across a view which may not suit you

You accusing Zerodha of being arrogant.

but you cant display your arrogance in the replies

Again.....& also asking him to "grow up"

grow up..and show a bit less of arrogance

Here's Zerodha destroying your stupid argument that ICICI charges less than Zerodha :rofl:
http://www.traderji.com/brokers-trading-platforms/47790-zerodha-444.html#post589108

And here's Zerodha has said about you & he's SO RIGHT about you :thumb: All you do is invoke unnecessary confrontation.
http://www.traderji.com/brokers-trading-platforms/47790-zerodha-444.html#post589108

I understand that you want to add value to the forum, but right now it feels more like you are just looking for a confrontation

Here's CASPER destroying your stupid argument about the trader losing more money with Zerodha than IndiaBulls :rofl:
http://www.traderji.com/brokers-trading-platforms/47790-zerodha-444.html#post588751
http://www.traderji.com/brokers-trading-platforms/47790-zerodha-444.html#post588910

You call yourself newbie...but rather you are a freebie...

I write facts..

that u r a freebie...

Oh, and you like "facts" so much, right? You always say in every second post of yours that you always talk "facts", etc etc so tell me what makes me freebie? Where have I asked anything for free? I've NOT. I've merely suggested Zerodha to see if they can minimize the Stamp Duty by finding a workaround/loophole to Karnataka Stamp Duty & thereby further optimize costs for smaller & intermediate traders & here are the FACTS of it - http://www.traderji.com/brokers-trading-platforms/47790-zerodha-431.html#post586639

KINDLY LEARN TO READ & COMPREHEND OTHERS' POSTS BEFORE YOU POST STRAW MAN ARGUMENTS

 

[mithoon]

hi has anyone been using zerodha on windows 7,pro or ultimate,if yes please let me know in case there are any issues or sticking with windows xp is best.

 

[respectinvestor]

@ New born Trader....

It took quite an effort from your side and all you posted was pure crap

..you never saw what Casper wrote ultimately when he got the message I put across...you could have taken pains to just read a few pages more and then comment..Casper is also a good trader so he understood what I wrote:clapping:

...Ravi Chandra could never defend himself ..neither his paying 10 paisa brokergae nor his backtesting..

PGDIMES...I maintain he is a wonderful person ...and I had written that he is a useful distraction from my trading activities...read it again...I never meant that he is distraction...work on your vocabulary dear.. he is a knowledgeable person working very hard..:clapping:

Zerodha..I am a trader to whom reliability of platform matters more instead of brokerage...so no harm ...Zerodha understood every bit of what I wrote and since he has been in the markets long enough...he got the message

Now @New- Born trader...will you spare the ordeal for Zerodha which has done a wonderful work of heralding a revolution in broking ..

You do not read anything..you never try to understand any thing...Read whatever I have written after a year of trading again...and you will get it..

Again ..whats the harm if I also suggest Zerodha to not charge brokerage from some newbies...I know you will love it ..after all you have been able to find the holy grail of trading...no brokerage..no stamp duty...no transaction charges...no service charges...and thats sure shot way of making money..I am just extrapolating you wish list....

 

[mithoon]

Works like a breeze on mine. Have a pre-loaded Windows 7 64 bit on my Lenovo Ideapad. It has worked smoothly so far along with realtime Amibroker charts with data feed from GDFL.

could you also advice on which version of windows 7 you are using