Status
Not open for further replies.
@mayank,

You are always on my mind!!!! ;)..

As I said, there is a limitation for having a third party for DP.. You would have to manually pledge the shares...

The other way out is where when you purchase the shares we don't send it to your demat but keep it in the pool and give margins... This is not a compliant procedure and you should be happy that we don't do un-compliant activities...

I might have a solution.. Can you leave your number once again on [email protected], attn: Sachin...
Dear sachin what do u have in mind for margins against Shares can i also E mail you regarding this if you have found some way out

The new broker on Forum ( rksv) i have read also says they will give margins in 2 months , they also have DP with ILFS how can they do something in 2 months you are not able to do in 2 years

AS the other person wrote we trust you more then them as you are old
we will definitely trust them also once they have some good words about them and some proven work

SO if there is some way you have find out for margins please let us know
 

TraderRavi

low risk profile
I also face the same problem with NOW..... I always have to exit from task manager ... by END process.

My also WIN 7 Ultimate.
I use NOW in win7 and winXP....no probs in XP except nestplus not working...:eek:......but NOW hangs on exit in win7 ..:(..if we wait for long time say 5 mins than it closes...otherwise from task manager to end...
 
Re: Zerodha Stamp Duty....

BUZZ, believe me there are traders like me who have sat back and watched 2 lakhs go up in smoke in a couple of hours, hoping for God to descend from the sky and turn the market in my favor so that I can save 10 thousand and plan my next trade, instead of acting, as stoploss after stoploss got taken out.
Remember trading is kind of legal gamble. You are only responsible for your capital. there is no confirmed profit or loss in any case.

However, I am not discussing about the day trade or positional trade issues here.

The Issue is:

First of all I dont know why you need to answer my post, Why Zerodha can not? ( This is really annoying). I am sure Zerodha already read it.

Please dont take it personally but I want Zerodha to answer my all queries all the time. (this was mentioned before, its again gentle reminder to Zerodha and fellow members)

Now come to the point:

As I mentioned in my earlier post that why IL&FS and Zerodha do not communicate each other and provide margin against their shares held in demat a/c?

Call us whatever you want to. Given that there are many more like me, you know why Zerodha wouldn't want to take the risk just because their clients want to bet big. Don't you see the positive side of it? They are saving the trader from taking risky bets too. It is better to avoid punching above our weight is what I've learnt after burning a lot more than just fingers in the markets.
Let me put this in that way: A offers you 1 lakh per day to you ( subject to the conditions, i.e Loss or gain you bear at the end of the day).
What you will do? (this Question is only for newbie12345),


Your 3k per lot is mouth watering indeed. Could you name your broker ;) ?
Maybe you are a gifted cum disciplined trader who only makes winning trades.
Except Zerodha , most of the famous and well established broker do that.

I'd love it if you could share your market views and trading calls with all of us :)
I am sorry about that.

Nifty hit lower circuit within a few hours in 2008. There is no guarantee that it won't happen again. Better to be safe than sorry. This comes from someone who hasn't always been on the winning side.
Is that new? I think we know that already. We are only responsible for any gain and loss in capital.
 

Zerodha

Well-Known Member
Dear sachin what do u have in mind for margins against Shares can i also E mail you regarding this if you have found some way out

The new broker on Forum ( rksv) i have read also says they will give margins in 2 months , they also have DP with ILFS how can they do something in 2 months you are not able to do in 2 years

AS the other person wrote we trust you more then them as you are old
we will definitely trust them also once they have some good words about them and some proven work

SO if there is some way you have find out for margins please let us know
As long as we use a third party dp, the issue faced will be the same...

We don't like to keep any stocks in the pool and give margins, like a lot of other brokers because it is not compliant and an experienced person will tell you how risky it is to keep your stocks in the pool... It is like mortgaging your property without even owning it...

We are already in the process of applying for dp and April is when we are looking at giving you an online module like an icicidirect etc who provide a complaint way of pledging your shares...

Till then, way out is by manually pledging the shares...
 

Zerodha

Well-Known Member
Re: Zerodha Stamp Duty....

Remember trading is kind of legal gamble. You are only responsible for your capital. there is no confirmed profit or loss in any case.

However, I am not discussing about the day trade or positional trade issues here.

The Issue is:

First of all I dont know why you need to answer my post, Why Zerodha can not? ( This is really annoying). I am sure Zerodha already read it.

Please dont take it personally but I want Zerodha to answer my all queries all the time. (this was mentioned before, its again gentle reminder to Zerodha and fellow members)

Now come to the point:



Is that new? I think we know that already. We are only responsible for any gain and loss in capital.
@buzz,

Page 566 post 5659...

I have answered and you have replied...

For someone who doesn't trade with us, you sure spend a lot of time on this thread!! ;) ... I am not obliged to answer all your queries, if you have any that has to be answered, send it to [email protected] or call us...

I don't understand why you are so pissed with me or Zerodha.. ;) even without trading with us... Cheer up brother, happy trading!!!

@ desi, brother, my job unfortunately is not only answering on this forum!! ;)... so if you put up something, have some patience to get an answer!!! if there is something that can't wait, give us a buzz, oops I meant don't give us buzz because he is angry with us, but call us up ;) ...

We never say only zero brokerage... It is always Rs 20 per trade, Zero brokerage.... actually by saying it is 20 per trade, it may seem like we charge more, but we actually charge Rs 20 per executed order...U didn't seem to notice it, did you?? In india traditionally brokerage has been %brokerage and hence we say zero brokerage Rs 20 per trade...

Anyways, cheer up brother!! if you want an explanation on the product send your contact on [email protected], will call you up... If you don't want to trade with us, best of luck with your trades wherever you are trading...

Cheers
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads