Zerodha....

[vikrit]

................
The best you can ask for is higher ticks, which is there in NOW, so you can push it into Amibroker. Yes, there is a small monthly cost of about 300 odd rs, but if you are an active trader, does 300 rs matter?

If it does, then maybe you have to suspend trading till the time some broker provides a good charting platform free of cost.

BTW, I doubt many people use pirated version of Amibroker, so all you are paying is 300 odd rs per month.

agree with you on all points. but confuse about 300rs.!!? for what? is it for tool to transfer data.

if yes post the link or tell more about where can get, is backfill possible? how many scrips we can add? As these two thing limit many tools i have tried, but these things have importance.

You must be aware of Sudris's tool, which is also essentially the same thing (NOW-Excel-AB). There do seem to be many more such tools/methods available on the internet which transfer NOW data to Amibroker or Metastock etc.

have tried some. know about sudris, but limitation of scrip no.s and no backfill.
do you know some way to overcome these limitation then plz share?
otherwise for me sometimes can't open system in morning and also trade in many scrips. sometimes b/c of hanging problem or something else have to restart.

.

 

[vikrit]

............... Their concept is of a retailer, and any scheme they bring out should be designed to cover the majority of customers.

............... Maybe their next scheme will be based on turnover/business generated by each customer, rather than winning percentage. That makes more sense coming from a broker. That is, if any discount scheme is brought about. Or they could offer .... well, the ideas a endless, maybe they should ask a consultant in Retail trade

They promote that they don't discriminate. so how come now they can start doing what others are doing?

Whatever anybody will say, the business/marketing truth is that brokerage/commission/spread return type of 'regular' schemes where decision based on winning/loosing or turnover in trading industry create unjust feelings among groups. As a result company loose business.

Anyways if still Zerodha will continue, i will claim my brokerage for 2nd round too.

.

 

[timepass]

They promote that they don't discriminate. so how come now they can start doing what others are doing?

Whatever anybody will say, the business/marketing truth is that brokerage/commission/spread return type of 'regular' schemes where decision based on winning/loosing or turnover in trading industry create unjust feelings among groups. As a result company loose business.

Anyways if still Zerodha will continue, i will claim my brokerage for 2nd round too.

.

They are already discriminating, based on on the customer's performance.

 

[vikrit]

They are already discriminating, based on on the customer's performance.

strange, i was about to edit my post to add same thing -

(by the way they already did b/w winners & losers

 

[vikrit]

Even Nature discriminates between winners and losers based on performance. Why should you expect anything different? And that too in an endeavor like trading? The whole concept of trading is based on winners and losers!

that statement was addition in post no. 8110. i.e. zerodha say they don't discriminate..........

now ans to your ques- i am different, and obviously it's my will and my expectation.

 

[timepass]

Even Nature discriminates between winners and losers based on performance. Why should you expect anything different? And that too in an endeavor like trading? The whole concept of trading is based on winners and losers!

The nature discriminates, true, but on what basis does a broker discriminate ??

 

[TraderRavi]

But what if I made 40% on a capital of 2000 rs

u will get your 40 rs back by check.....bank charges 50 rs.....

 

[kickass]

pardon me for my ignorance about esignal and ninjatrader . Plz tell me what is your data source, and if it is that much reliable then provide 8th may flash trade whole day data for nifty future only OR post that day tick data chart for same.

Please also provide a full fledged broker name who provide good charting software with correct tick data.

I will advice you, as costs doesn't a matter for you then buy official and most reliable data from nse - checkout rates http://nseindia.com/supra_global/content/dotex/data_products.htm.

By the way i was talking about small trader's cost. And agree with you that there is a cost for doing a business, but who was talking about business? Anyways hope if ever you will start any business with sufficient funds, you will get all success. if considering trading as 'business' then please tell require sufficient amount acc. to you b/c 'sufficient' doesn't clear how much, it will help new ones....

dude i use esignal data. they are oficial data vendors for nse. cost is approx
6500-7000 per month depending on usd exchange rate. www.esignal.com
ninjatrader is free. maybe u shud read my post properly once again. i have said no broker provides accurate charting software.

 

[vikrit]

Different from? Rationality or just plain Challenged?

by your last post thought you have misunderstood that one line post.
seems your purpose is different. anyways read the posts before asking questions.

and cool down, you forget you don't care about any challenge, prize money and certificate??? what you care about is privacy!!! so now started caring????

plz don't bother what people are expecting from zerodha. and if want to bother then open ur eyes and try to understand.

FYI, zerodha said to be fair to all traders, this type of competition conflict their own words. And whenever they choose to reward all winners i always will be one of them to get prize.

 

[vikrit]

dude i use esignal data. they are oficial data vendors for nse. cost is approx
6500-7000 per month depending on usd exchange rate. www.esignal.com
ninjatrader is free. maybe u shud read my post properly once again. i have said no broker provides accurate charting software.

thanks for reply and info, i didnt know about esignal & ninjatrader already told you.

.......... i use esignal with ninjatrader coz every platform available here has inaccurate data. t......!

b/c of above line i asked about tick data/chart accuracy with your provider and asked for full fledged broker here or anywhere. now you have changed words - accurate charting software. Before you said every platform has inaccurate data. (assuming NOW comes under every) and also i have seen some paid vendors data including, they all are having problem of missing ticks real-time. some update/change/correct EOD.

anyways, i am not an expert in this. so, leave it.

but if esignal gave you accurate data, and hoping you will have no problem then post tick chart of 8 may just for helping to see the volume and movement. thanks in advance.

and whatever you have edit, if that's true for my post then people should stop asking questions/query at Traderji. I will keep in mind before asking and answering. anyways thanks for your all efforts.