A plunge in Indian Stock market

sspms2002

Well-Known Member
#81
Today was a normal day when the Nifty was not moving much. (at least till i watched ) So stocks were also moving very slow and it was difficult to find good stocks.

I traded less today.
I started with a Profit of 500 in my first trade , but then keep on dwindling between 400 and 700. Finally i closed at 12 PM.

Stocks Traded: HINDPETRO , JINDALSTEEL
P&L : Green 544 after commissions.

Also I tried today to use MACD in My trading decisions...But i think today may not be a good day to analyse MACD..or it may be a good day to find some disadvantages abt MACD...
 

sspms2002

Well-Known Member
#82
MACD :

Back Ground:
Developed by Gerald Appel in the late seventies, the Moving Average Convergence/Divergence oscillator (MACD) is one of the simplest and most effective momentum indicators available. The MACD turns two trend-following indicators, moving averages, into a momentum oscillator by subtracting the longer moving average from the shorter moving average. As a result, the MACD offers the best of both worlds: trend following and momentum. The MACD fluctuates above and below the zero line as the moving averages converge, cross and diverge. Traders can look for signal line crossovers, centerline crossovers and divergences to generate signals. Because the MACD is unbounded, it is not particularly useful for identifying overbought and oversold levels.

My Analysis: (brief) :
It seems MACD was designed for Long term Trading.
It seems it works well on a long term time frame..provided we look into stocks which are not range bound..

But for Intraday, it may be a bit hazy to use it alone. I think it is difficult to use it for time frames 5 minutes and less...
On 5 minutes and above time frames it can be utlised..but we cannot purely depend on it..

Because it is a Momentum indicator...it may change momentum up or down before a stock actually turns in that direction. So for Shorter time frame traders...then it depends on other factors what action he wants to take..exit from trade or remain in Trade..

But having said that...if also forshadows that trend may reverse based on above implication (as the momentum is not going with Price..)

But usually the above is applicable for a stock that is in trend...for a Stock that is in Range..i am assuming with my limited knowledge..that it is difficlut to Use MACD alone..or for that sake difficult to use any indicator..the Risk ir more than Reward in Whipsaws...

Also i see that MACD Crossovers are very good points of activity..as many people are watching it..(it is just EMA crossovers)..so it is a good decision point...usually what is feel/see it if the momentum is at a good angle (around 45 degrees) and MACD crossovers happens..it gives a good decision to ENTER trade...also see the impact of it after it cross the 0 line...

I want fellow traders to also comment as they have seen all aspects of MACD..and how useful it is.

I usually Trade on a 1 min / 2 min/ 5 min Time Frame..and would like inputs from Traderji... if MACD can be utilised better there....
 

sspms2002

Well-Known Member
#83
I got up early after working late last night and just found out that its Holiday today for NSE....

Anyways, I will have some time now to know study a few other indicators...
 

sspms2002

Well-Known Member
#84
Today seemed to be a good day for trading. Although the NIFTY was not up much, but stocks were moving well..

I traded SSLT , HINDPETRO , JINDALSTEEL...I think i have left half of my profits on the table and booked the other half..

But iam satisfied with today..i only made 4-5 Trades today and closed for the day at 10.30 AM.

Stocks Traded: SSLT , HINDPETRO , JINDALSTEEL
P&L : Green 802 after Commissions.
 

sspms2002

Well-Known Member
#85
Hey Moonlite..have you started real trading ???
 
#86
Hi sspms2002,

Read your note on made, and agree its a long term tool.

Attempted to start off but faced some hic ups with my TRD a/c. Will inform kick off and keep writing.
 

sspms2002

Well-Known Member
#87
Hi sspms2002,

Read your note on made, and agree its a long term tool.

Attempted to start off but faced some hic ups with my TRD a/c. Will inform kick off and keep writing.
Ohh Ok..

I tried MACD with different parameters, not the standard ones today..and it behaved in an optimal way..though not all signals were good...
I think MACD can be used to confirm our decisions and we should avoid positions when its not supporting our decisions.
 
#89
I at the moment am trying to keep matters as simple as possible. I am just looking at the hi & lo after an hour into the mkt, and using them as my support and resistance levels.
 

sspms2002

Well-Known Member
#90
I at the moment am trying to keep matters as simple as possible. I am just looking at the hi & lo after an hour into the mkt, and using them as my support and resistance levels.
Thats quiet straightforward...It seems there is thread around those High and low values also in Traderji..But there he is utlising some calculations..
 

Similar threads