Confused - Sharekhan vs Icicidirect vs Hdfc vs Kotak vs Indiabulls vs 5paise

[pkjha30]

HI

Surprise of all surprises here ICICIDRIECT is the most favoured online trading portal with 36 votes as per opinion poll and even Traderji had voted for it.This is despite most of the forum members have low opinion of ICICIDIRECT . Any reason for it.


Sharekhan and Indiabulls are neck to neck with 33 votes.


Regards
Pankaj

 

[gold_ranjit]

Hi,
The reason being very simple. No matter how much people make complains and how much you cry with its bad services when it comes of holding your long and very long positions in demat and the facilites of 3 in one account makes it more easy and one feels safe. with Long term investors Demat is the main issue after signing in the POA who the hell on this earth will never get nighmares who knows........ and ICICI is a bank not a broker who will be interested with you shares.... Take the case of an Investor who one fine day found his 5000 blue chip company shares gone from Indiabulls DP and his 1 crore value left over was just 300 RS. so I still feel safe with my long and very long even medium term positions in ICICI. As far trading goes i have a fast on line broker but only for trading and taking short delivery.

ANY THING ELSE.....

Regards,
gold_ranjit

 

[trader31339]

Indiabulls, provides brokerage rate of 0.03% intraday and 0.2% for delivery.

No monthly volumes or brokerage comittment required.

No monthly software charges.

Instant payment transfer ( payout) .

Life time free dmat account( no annual charges)

The trading platform is very very fast and no complains at all.

If sharekhan is providing you the above brokerage without any comittment of volumes or brokerage, alongwith free trading platform( ie no monthly charges) then you can consider sharekhan.Else play blind go with indiabulls.

NB:The brokerage rates mentioned above are their base rate so you dont have to apply any maska palish for them.They will themself offer yo the above mentioned rates without any negotiation from your side.

 

[VICKY_SEEKINGINR]

Hi,
..... POA who the hell on this earth will never get nighmares who knows........ and
ANY THING ELSE.....

Regards,
gold_ranjit

Hi Ranjit..

Please give some information on POA...

Thanks

 

[gold_ranjit]

Hi Ranjit..

Please give some information on POA...

Thanks

Hi,

You can get information using this link below what POA game is all about.

http://fecolumnists.expressindia.com/full_column.php?content_id=110557

 

[pkjha30]

Hi Ranjit..

Please give some information on POA...

Thanks

Hi

its Power Of Attorny

Whereby you handover power of decision to somebody else.
Pankaj

 

[silly]

Check utisecurities provided by UTI bank. They are providing tradeanywhere.exe for trading brokerage is 0.5 paisa one side for square off type and 0.40 paisa for delivery..... they provide UTI bank zero balance acoount trading account and DP account for amount Rs. 300 only..

 

[VICKY_SEEKINGINR]

Hi,

You can get information using this link below what POA game is all about.

http://fecolumnists.expressindia.com/full_column.php?content_id=110557

Thanks Ranjit

Hi

its Power Of Attorny

Whereby you handover power of decision to somebody else.
Pankaj

Thanks Pankaj

 

[VICKY_SEEKINGINR]

Check utisecurities provided by UTI bank. They are providing tradeanywhere.exe for trading brokerage is 0.5 paisa one side for square off type and 0.40 paisa for delivery..... they provide UTI bank zero balance acoount trading account and DP account for amount Rs. 300 only..

Hi Silly

Its a one time charges. Is there any monthly comitment for brokerage
and other charges? how about the speed of tradeanywhere? can u post the
screen shot of this software,.

Thanks

 

[trader31339]

speed is great .

tradeanywhere.asiancerc.com