Discount Broker Comparison

[bpr]

I talked with them and what they sent me is a model contract notes of MCX. It is not of NSE. but I do not know how to upload them. Another broker is Action financial and it is at there website https://www.actionfin.com/Product-Services.aspx. Here it is compulsory to have demat with them. In the meantime I talked with Globe capital; the firm that is offering demat service tothe clients of VPS share company and Alice Blue. It is there website http://www.globecapital.com/. Their Kolkata office told me that they will offere same brokerage as I was getting from VPS shares. They are offering both trading platform : Odin and NOW

use wiki send dot com to upload the file and share the link here

 

[Trade2Learn]

I talked with them and what they sent me is a model contract notes of MCX. It is not of NSE. but I do not know how to upload them. Another broker is Action financial and it is at there website https://www.actionfin.com/Product-Services.aspx. Here it is compulsory to have demat with them. In the meantime I talked with Globe capital; the firm that is offering demat service tothe clients of VPS share company and Alice Blue. It is there website http://www.globecapital.com/. Their Kolkata office told me that they will offere same brokerage as I was getting from VPS shares. They are offering both trading platform : Odin and NOW

Thats really surprising bcoz i have talked to two branches of globe capital and they were not ready to go below 1 p .
Can post the address and contact num of the office where u have been offered the deal as same as VPS?

 

[ksp191]

I am A satisfied customer of sasonline.I think sasonline is the best for traders.They are cheap and reliable.I already have trading experience with zerodha, rksv.Finally I settled with sas online.Their other charges are least with no hidden charges.

 

[MonyFx]

Alice Blue / Wisdom Capital seem to have sorted out issues with the server. Past couple of weeks behaving well and I forget that I am not with Zerodha anymore. But contract note reminds me with the cheap brokerage

@Balab,

I am interested in opening/testing an account with Aliceblue thro' WC with small fund, since its the lowest brokerage ever..!
Happy to hear its all right now with AB with their platform and execution from your last post...
any more positive & negative reviews about them from you, since you have been trading with them from quite sometime now, would be highly appreciated and welcomed!!

Please let us know!!!

Thanks a lot!

 

[Grules]

I am planning to move to a discount broker and i am confused which one to go with. Can you elaborate the reasons why SAS is better than Zerodha and RKSV (apart from costing of the 999 plan). Basically looking for a sound differentiator.

I am A satisfied customer of sasonline.I think sasonline is the best for traders.They are cheap and reliable.I already have trading experience with zerodha, rksv.Finally I settled with sas online.Their other charges are least with no hidden charges.

 

[MonyFx]

@bpr

Thank You so much for the great effort and information gathering & dissipation!

As for WC, which I have been tracking developments from 2 months, your post about AB/WC makes sense and you are spot-on!!!

I have an account with ZD and they are good overall, however of all disc. brokers the BE for every trade is higher than all other disc. brokers..! so I have been looking for zero brok & less TO charges... WC's plans seems best so far for their lowest overall charges thence rendering lower BE for every trade...!!!

waiting @balab for whats he says...!!

Best Regards,
Mony

 

[MonyFx]

@ksp191...

Thanks for the review...

I concur with Grules...
rksv is larger and also well reviewed 'overall'... (1000 bucks costlier than SAS apart) they've got better rating & service!

@bpr,
I also heard that rksv is going to tailor the Stamp Duty to the client's state shortly... if this they deliver then I see that they would be the best in unlimited category...

 

[bpr]

I am planning to move to a discount broker and i am confused which one to go with. Can you elaborate the reasons why SAS is better than Zerodha and RKSV (apart from costing of the 999 plan). Basically looking for a sound differentiator.

There is no other difference apart from the cost. Think of Discount broking is like daily essential commodity just like potatoes , tomatoes you buy from the shop who can provide you the cheapest as long as you are satisfied with the quality.

 

[bpr]

@bpr

Thank You so much for the great effort and information gathering & dissipation!

As for WC, which I have been tracking developments from 2 months, your post about AB/WC makes sense and you are spot-on!!!

I have an account with ZD and they are good overall, however of all disc. brokers the BE for every trade is higher than all other disc. brokers..! so I have been looking for zero brok & less TO charges... WC's plans seems best so far for their lowest overall charges thence rendering lower BE for every trade...!!!

waiting @balab for whats he says...!!

Best Regards,
Mony

Hello MonyFx I am assuming you are talking about MCX. In NSE SAS seems the cheapest overall.

 

[bpr]

@bpr,
I also heard that rksv is going to tailor the Stamp Duty to the client's state shortly... if this they deliver then I see that they would be the best in unlimited category...

Good to know this. This can be the next game changer.