Discount Broker Comparison

Nope... am talking about NSE EQ & FnO

from the WC's brok-calc and also from the information that I have from WC itself:
Their SD is ZERO for KAR & AP for NSE and 50/- max. cap for KAR & AP for MCX!

Thats how their overall cost would beat all others asper my calcs!!!
I have no idea how could they offer SD as Nil for these states, But I assume thats becoz they are a front-end for AliceBlue, they might have negotiated that way!
 

bpr

Well-Known Member
Nope... am talking about NSE EQ & FnO

from the WC's brok-calc and also from the information that I have from WC itself:
Their SD is ZERO for KAR & AP for NSE and 50/- max. cap for KAR & AP for MCX!

Thats how their overall cost would beat all others asper my calcs!!!
I have no idea how could they offer SD as Nil for these states, But I assume thats becoz they are a front-end for AliceBlue, they might have negotiated that way!
Really that is new info to me So they are already charging different stamp duty based on different state. Can you ask them a complete list of stamp duty for all the states and update here.
So the same should be applicable to Aliceblue as well or do they charge differently? This is getting interesting...:D:D
 
I found merit in SAS and I gave my reviews and reason for joining it. I am sure TSO / RKSV / Zerodha are worthy brand names worth mentioning. I am enclosing the copy copy of contract note. This is latest. They donot charge brokerage in Contract but seperatly in Finacial ledger @ Rs 9 plus ST.

av_30

Copy of contract enclosed..
Attached Images in orignal message

http://www.traderji.com/brokers-trading-platforms/90929-sas-online-3.html#post906725
 
Last edited:
hello traders,
I have a confusion.

i know that there are two types of margin for future trading.
One is span margin and the other is exposure margin.
Span margin is deposited by brokers to nse and is changed and reported 5 times a day.
Shortfall of span margin results in penalty into the clients account.:)

Exposure margin is deposited but not reported by brokers.
IS THIS STATEMENT TRUE??
So they have the freedom that they charge it from clients or not.


This is the reason some brokers charge span margin for carry forward position and some charge total margin (span+exposure).Some even charge interest of exposure margin if there is shortfall of that also.

My question-
Brokers who offer 3-4 times intraday limit of futures do they deposit the span margin of those 4 positions from their funds so that the client can take the positions???

Secondly wisdom and astha trade are offering 10 times leverage to clients.
Astha charges only 1.5% of the total cost of the future contract.
For eg nifty is 6200 so the margin will be 6200*50=310000
310000*1.5%=Rs 4650.
They have same calculation for all the futures.

So in this case does the broker have such a large quantity of funds (which i surely doubt for wisdom:D) so that they can deposit to nse and in turn provide this type of leverage.
Or the broker has very small base of clients and those clients have deposited large funds who do not trade (which i again doubt:D) and those funds are used to provide leverage to other clients who trade?

Am i correct in understanding all of this or am i missing something here which i do not know.?:eek:
Kya jhol hai mujhe samaj nahi aaya.:confused:
Its a request to all the members pls throw some light on this.
 
Thats really surprising bcoz i have talked to two branches of globe capital and they were not ready to go below 1 p .
Can post the address and contact num of the office where u have been offered the deal as same as VPS?
Today I received the forms etc of Globe Capital by post. There address is as :
Globe capital Market Ltd,
10, Wood Street,
Near Camac street Pantaloon
1st Floor,
Kolkata- 700016
Ph 03340214023

Hope it will help.
 

bpr

Well-Known Member
hello traders,
I have a confusion.

i know that there are two types of margin for future trading.
One is span margin and the other is exposure margin.
Span margin is deposited by brokers to nse and is changed and reported 5 times a day.
Shortfall of span margin results in penalty into the clients account.:)

Exposure margin is deposited but not reported by brokers.
IS THIS STATEMENT TRUE??
So they have the freedom that they charge it from clients or not.


This is the reason some brokers charge span margin for carry forward position and some charge total margin (span+exposure).Some even charge interest of exposure margin if there is shortfall of that also.

My question-
Brokers who offer 3-4 times intraday limit of futures do they deposit the span margin of those 4 positions from their funds so that the client can take the positions???

Secondly wisdom and astha trade are offering 10 times leverage to clients.
Astha charges only 1.5% of the total cost of the future contract.
For eg nifty is 6200 so the margin will be 6200*50=310000
310000*1.5%=Rs 4650.
They have same calculation for all the futures.

So in this case does the broker have such a large quantity of funds (which i surely doubt for wisdom:D) so that they can deposit to nse and in turn provide this type of leverage.
Or the broker has very small base of clients and those clients have deposited large funds who do not trade (which i again doubt:D) and those funds are used to provide leverage to other clients who trade?

Am i correct in understanding all of this or am i missing something here which i do not know.?:eek:
Kya jhol hai mujhe samaj nahi aaya.:confused:
Its a request to all the members pls throw some light on this.
All these regulation gets kicked in on EOD basis. Intraday it is Jungle raj :D:D
intraday basis there is no regulation. Broker provides leverage based on their risk appetite and they mostly square off @ 80 to 85% MTM loss to protect themselves against fast moving market. So all risk is traders. Brokers are hardly taking any risk.


I am not 100% sure though let others clarify if it is otherwise.
 
Today I received the forms etc of Globe Capital by post. There address is as :
Globe capital Market Ltd,
10, Wood Street,
Near Camac street Pantaloon
1st Floor,
Kolkata- 700016
Ph 03340214023

Hope it will help.
hi,
can u tell the brokerage and exposure u have finalized with globe capital?.