Discount Broker Comparison

[sumeetsj]

Nice conversation going on in the thread,

:thumb:

the broker calculator is pathetically designed and full of bugs. if this is how they designed the calculator then god knows about their web trading platform.
transaction charge for futures 185 per cr
And option is 5000 per cr
Hmm lowest and lucrative.
brokerage 20 per order

but stamp duty showing 1000 per Cr with no cap even if they are located in Mumbai.(it should have been 200 per Cr)
(They will make more than double/tripple here)
Chk whther they will allow state wise brokerage. I guess not.

you are over-reacing dude,
trying to judge a book by its cover is not good,

Again not a single screenshot of their so called platform.
NSET/NOW are tried and tested at least I am getting a fare execution but when it comes to custom platform I will take it with a grain of salt.
They own their platform they can skimp some while executing trades. yeah I am a skeptic. :eat:
you need to verify who audited their platform and certified it and how blah blah and how true the datafeed and execution is.
But last not least first the trading platform should be usable at least equal or greter than NEST/NOW web platform.

Order Flow and Order management are a part of OMS,
which cannot be tampered with, in India,

A big red flag from my side for now...:gun2:

I think one should avoid writing a review without a testing

 

[sumeetsj]

There was a big queue outside a bookstore,
everyone wanted to buy this book named:
"101 Mating Positions",
the bookstore owner too was surprised,
But everyone who bought the book were
disappointed when they opened the book
after reaching home.

Why?


It was a book on the game of Chess

:rofl:

 

[bpr]

Nice conversation going on in the thread,

:thumb:






you are over-reacing dude,
trying to judge a book by its cover is not good,



Order Flow and Order management are a part of OMS,
which cannot be tampered with, in India,







I think one should avoid writing a review without a testing

Dude you did not add anything to the questions that I have raised except empty spaces.
I think One should not counteract something without supporting facts.

 

[sumeetsj]

My bad,
did not get your questions,
please elaborate if possible,
Thanks

:thumb:

Dude you did not add anything to the questions that I have raised except empty spaces.
I think One should not counteract something without supporting facts.

 

[nidhi_agarwal]

Where's the calculator? I am not able to see that. Getting "Under Construction" message.

 

[balab]

Any idea regarding India Procon? Its not listed in the brokerage comparison excel?

Edit: I found they are only dealing in commodities and not in other segments. Found in the excel also.

 

[bpr]

Where's the calculator? I am not able to see that. Getting "Under Construction" message.

Yeah they removed it ...
may be they read my post :lol:
Hopefully they come back with a better version..with all accurate figures.

 

[nidhi_agarwal]

May be! Meanwhile I am checking website of leading discount brokers. I guess websites of Zerodha and RKSV looks promising. Other websites are very raw. !

 

[rohit_onkar]

Does anybody have a list of discount brokers? - classified according to year of inception?

 

[ashugnani]

Forex trade brokerage Rates

Can some one tell me the link providing Forex Trade brokerage rates charged in in India

Thank you!