Experiments in Technical Analysis

[kkseal]

This is not recommendation thread but a experimentation one

At least it's a query on a good stock. But not here please, there are plenty of threads in the Equities section where you'll get an answer. (Be more specific about your time horizon etc.)

Regards,
Kalyan.

 

[Aman1]

hi ,
Could you guys please give macd histogram divergence formula for metastock so that I could select stocks that show
macd histogram +/- divegence

regards,
aman1

 

[skillz2invest]

Hello KarthikSir / SoumyaSir;

I am new to TA and have recently started experimenting with Fibotrader;I have been reading your posts and learning a wealth of information. It's really amazing.

I am trying to use Mabiuts with FT and testing with simulations however I am not getting the results one would expect;
Out of 23 trades only 8-9 winning trades;

I also downloaded Mabiuts template from Traderji forum (one of the Soumya sir's post)however not getting good results;

Can you please check (if you can, I know Karthik sir do not use FT) if / what is wrong or give me some directions / pointers.

Thanks,
Skillz

 

[karthikmarar]

Hello KarthikSir / SoumyaSir;

I am new to TA and have recently started experimenting with Fibotrader;I have been reading your posts and learning a wealth of information. It's really amazing.

Thanks,
Skillz

Dear Amarnath

This one post is enough to justify the 1000 posts...

regards

Karthik

 

[amarnath]

Dear Amarnath

This one post is enough to justify the 1000 posts...

regards

Karthik

Instead of refering a single url investopedia i feel you are wasting 180 pages of discussion for MACD and to show you are something so special than newbies here?? and if your MACD have 3000 downloads in which you see only one newbie to make your justification for 1000 post and let me see where this scarficial experimentation end in

 

[amarnath]

Sorry i don't have time to count how many pages here have word MACD and MA etc and digital doesn't means something so special and only experts can exploit them ?? and conventional doesn't mean its so simple that experts can ignore them totally say quantum mechanic looks so simple to physicist which doesn't mean it should be treated as complex subject or something no one will master.

And Mr.Karthik i thought you are focusing on quality but at end its seems your are looking more just at quantity of download and no of post you contributed like a average broker who counts for his comission

And at moment i dont need any TIPSTERS so even if you start one i cant subscribe for it sorry, as its just now you started to explore MACD i cant risk my funds based it

And you never justified why you looked at quantity than quality of contribution

 

[amarnath]

Hello KarthikSir / SoumyaSir;

I am new to TA and have recently started experimenting with Fibotrader;I have been reading your posts and learning a wealth of information. It's really amazing.

I am trying to use Mabiuts with FT and testing with simulations however I am not getting the results one would expect;
Out of 23 trades only 8-9 winning trades;

I also downloaded Mabiuts template from Traderji forum (one of the Soumya sir's post)however not getting good results;

Can you please check (if you can, I know Karthik sir do not use FT) if / what is wrong or give me some directions / pointers.

Thanks,
Skillz

Dont expect any result from experimentation which is groundless, try investopedia if you need seen some basic TA stuff in life so far

 

[karthikmarar]

Instead of refering a single url investopedia i feel you are wasting 180 pages of discussion for MACD

My dear,It is apparant that you have no clue what are forums are for. They are for healthy discussions, sharing of knowledge etc.

...and to show you are something so special than newbies here?? ...

mmmmmm........... Is there a burning smell in the air...

And you never justified why you looked at quantity than quality of contribution

Also my Friend if there is no quality there will be no quantity either...

 

[amarnath]

My dear,It is apparant that you have no clue what are forums are for. They are for healthy discussions, sharing of knowledge etc.

yes i have no clue and to learn waste time and bandwidth rather than refering some work which was already done well and contributed @ investopedia



mmmmmm........... Is there a burning smell in the air...

I just see smoke at moment and you can hear explosion later when account burst on margin calls



Also my Friend if there is no quality there will be no quantity either...

If offer some thing for free, quantity is always exist there irrespective of their quality and i call quality if i see +ve equity curve and not based on 1000 or millions of downloads

And you justify quantity to quality??

 

[karthikmarar]

My Friend, Quantity will follow Quality. No Quality..NO quantity.. Universal phenomenon

Talking about Quality, We are still awaiting some quality posts from you, Hope you will oblige