General Trading Chat

[newuser_RK]

@Smart_trade,

This is bit off-topic. But I got interested to know as your are the most reputed and successful trader around here. Please delete this post if these are not comfortable..

At what age did you come to trading world ?
At what age did you start trading full-time ?
After what years of starting trading you could say yourself of being profitable ?

He has shared this 100 time at least in this forum. I am sure he won't be tired in replying this again. Hats off to you sir, such patient and selflessness. This is what is called giving back. All successful people should practice this and they would have done their bit...

Thanks Da....

Sent from my AO5510 using Tapatalk

 

[vijkris]

@Smart_trade,

This is bit off-topic. But I got interested to know as your are the most reputed and successful trader around here. Please delete this post if these are not comfortable..

At what age did you come to trading world ?
At what age did you start trading full-time ?
After what years of starting trading you could say yourself of being profitable ?

ya, he shared his experience sometime back. i remember he said his family supported him a lot. once he lost 5lakhs something in a day. also gained few lakhs in a day. then he started trading properly. has some 25 yrs experience as full time trader.
(no offence, hope ST sir will not get angry,i think now he is almost 60 yrs of age )
PS: the above lines may just be a speculation as well.

 

[headstrong007]

source ::: money control

source ::::: http://www.moneycontrol.com/news/ma...ks-would-have-made-you-crorepati_6465821.html

No one can identify a single trader who bought any 3 of them intentionally.. 10 years ago..no method to identify them..even fundamentals changes completely in 10yrs..

out of 1000s stocks.. 10-20 in lime light..but in last 10 yrs but more than 100 such stocks almost vanished..
also there is no grantee for same performance in next 10yrs..like suzlon, unitech, kingfisher, satyam,Jaiprakash Associates... endless list..:lol:

I remember Suzlon Energy was a fev for many TV Star few years back..when Tulsan said fundamentally great stock.. buy buy buy.. Sukhani said long term tech up up up....

Stock market me paisa banana itna easy to nahi hai..jitna dikhta hai.. yeah sab list main..

 

[newuser_RK]

No one can identify a single trader who bought any 3 of them intentionally.. 10 years ago..no method to identify them..even fundamentals changes completely in 10yrs..

out of 1000s stocks.. 10-20 in lime light..but in last 10 yrs but more than 100 such stocks almost vanished..
also there is no grantee for same performance in next 10yrs..like suzlon, unitech, kingfisher, satyam,Jaiprakash Associates... endless list..

I remember Suzlon Energy was a fev for many TV Star few years back..when Tulsan said fundamentally great stock.. buy buy buy.. Sukhani said long term tech up up up....

Stock market me paisa banana itna easy to nahi hai..jitna dikhta hai.. yeah sab list main..

One of my Uncle says ki Stock market ek legalized satta market hai. Jo kuch nahi kar sarkta woh stock market mein ghusta hai. What should I say to him

Sent from my AO5510 using Tapatalk

 

[amandeep86]

Charts are fine, but to trade through kite on a mobile device is horrible.

Regards
Vivek

Need only charts .Is their any lag on Cash Scripts and Options data

 

[vivektrader]

Need only charts .Is their any lag on Cash Scripts and Options data

In cash and futures, never faced a problem, options can't say (never traded them)

Regards
Vivek

 

[vijkris]

One of my Uncle says ki Stock market ek legalized satta market hai. Jo kuch nahi kar sarkta woh stock market mein ghusta hai. What should I say to him

Sent from my AO5510 using Tapatalk

atleast it is legal na... unlike IPL betting where police can arrest anyone.
if its legalised satta then in income tax rules it should have been along with horse racing,winning lottery section.
But IT dept dosen consider it satta and has separate section specially income from fno speculation ,stcg,ltcg, etc.

BTW many LIC policies invests some amount of premium in Equities. r they playing satta?

 

[Smart_trade]

One of my Uncle says ki Stock market ek legalized satta market hai. Jo kuch nahi kar sarkta woh stock market mein ghusta hai. What should I say to him

Sent from my AO5510 using Tapatalk

You dont have to convince anything to your uncle, let your success and the material acquisitions which come along with success do the talking.This is why making money consistantly every month is important.

But from the question you asked ,are you sure that you are definate about your success or you also have some doubts about trading as a profession ?

Smart_trade

 

[wisp]

In this thread often there are silly questions asked which are really unrelated to learning trading and also some silly answers given by others who seem to know all the details... It baffles me whether people are here to learn trading or to delve into the private lives of others. Interesting that such questions never show up in serious trading forums such as james method, big mike or forex D&S etc. Why? because people are there to learn trading and the students respect those who teach them enough not to indulge in such silly questions and answers. I see these type conjectures in private chats also...anyway its just a reflection of those who indulge in this, nothing more. Traderji is a great place to learn and hats off to the teachers who teach in spite of all this. Sorry if I disrupted the thread by posting this, but I had to get this off my chest.

 

[timepass]

In this thread often there are silly questions asked which are really unrelated to learning trading and also some silly answers given by others who seem to know all the details... It baffles me whether people are here to learn trading or to delve into the private lives of others. Interesting that such questions never show up in serious trading forums such as james method, big mike or forex D&S etc. Why? because people are there to learn trading and the students respect those who teach them enough not to indulge in such silly questions and answers. I see these type conjectures in private chats also...anyway its just a reflection of those who indulge in this, nothing more. Traderji is a great place to learn and hats off to the teachers who teach in spite of all this. Sorry if I disrupted the thread by posting this, but I had to get this off my chest.

It's a place of learning through sharing, not a disciplined school, so there is a lot of leeway in the teaching/questioning/learning methods. It's cool.