how much return you expect from commodity market

[cotton]

except the stop loss value which u calculated with fluke and it comes near universal stop loss due to good luck of ur fluke.
Rest all 100% wrong ,u made ur own formula, once again check ur atr value calculated and see and tell what is the (mistake of principal )in ur calculation of atr stop loss and answer .
Atr is 100 % correct but formula which u used for caculating stop loss is 100 % wrong (i will explain shortly once listen from u )BUT STILL, I APPRECIATE UR EFFORT!!!!!!(I USED WEEPING ICON FIRST TIME ,AT THIS THREAD,AFTER UR THIS FORMULA)

Ashwani the value i calculated I used reference from your earlier post where u suggested 2.5 for EOD and 4 times from 4 hr intraday...thats why i calculated the same...otherwise we can use the standard pivot also to calculate...

 

[ashwani chadha]

Hi all... Sorry I'm off for the last few days....

I have been seriously working on starting Sub-broker business for commodities. I have at present 10 to 20 clients ready to invest minimum of 50K.

Kindly advise is that a good business and can i earn good monthly income.

Pls give your valuable suggestions.

thank you
Sairam

i dont think it is a good business,good clints trade just on line,brokerage which one get are very low.i dont recommend to start this business,your over head will be more then your income,if dont start at a very large scale

 

[cotton]

dear cotton.,as my lap top dont print y and j,so since a month i was using i in place of y in various words of my post
to day i have baught new desk top with 17 inch screen
firstly it will solve my problem if my lap top is some time under repair,other wise i was not trading on those days,when lap top is under repair
secondly i will still be writing my posts at lap top but i will try to adit my post for y and j at this desk top,to day it is my first post from my new desk top and i adited few of my previous posts for replacing y in place of y

I myself using desktop only..office is yet to provide me my new laptop..should be getting on monday i suppose...

 

[cotton]

except the stop loss value which u calculated with fluke and it comes near universal stop loss due to good luck of ur fluke.
Rest all 100% wrong ,u made ur own formula, once again check ur atr value calculated and see and tell what is the (mistake of principal )in ur calculation of atr stop loss and answer .
Atr is 100 % correct but formula which u used for caculating stop loss is 100 % wrong (i will explain shortly once listen from u )BUT STILL, I APPRECIATE UR EFFORT!!!!!!(I USED WEEPING ICON FIRST TIME ,AT THIS THREAD,AFTER UR THIS FORMULA)

I used the pivot calculator and here are the values..

Pivot : 107.85
R1 : 108.88
S1 : 105.35

 

[cotton]

And these are todays values after closing..

Pivot : 104.22
R1 : 106.68
S1 : 100.73

So is is right to say our SL for monday would be 106.68

 

[ashwani chadha]

Ashwani the value i calculated I used reference from your earlier post where u suggested 2.5 for EOD and 4 times from 4 hr intraday...thats why i calculated the same...otherwise we can use the standard pivot also to calculate...

i just told you at my post that use 2.5 atr as eod stop loss bUT( first)i did not told you
that atr is adjusted in buying price and you did it your self IT IS ADDED OR SUBTRACTED FROM LAST CLOSING PRICE
TWO---WHEN YOU ARE SHORT YOU WILL ADD 2.5 ATR IN LAST CLOSING PRICE BUT AS YOU ARE SHORT IN LEAD ,IN STEAD OF ADDING 2.5 ATR VALUE IN LAST CLOSING PRICE ,YOU SUBSTRACTED 2.5 ATR FROM YOUR SELLING PRICE
NOW I THINK YOU CAN REALISE YOUR MISTAKE
NOW AGAIN CALKCULATE AND GIVE STOP LOSS FOR LEAD FOR MONDAY WHICH YOU WILL BE USING,SO THAT I CAN CHECK WHEATHER THIS TIME YOU ARE WRITE OR NOT ,CAN STILL CLEAR ANY CONFUSION

 

[cotton]

i just told you at my post that use 2.5 atr as eod stop loss bUT( first)i did not told you
that atr is adjusted in buying price and you did it your self IT IS ADDED OR SUBTRACTED FROM LAST CLOSING PRICE
TWO---WHEN YOU ARE SHORT YOU WILL ADD 2.5 ATR IN LAST CLOSING PRICE BUT AS YOU ARE SHORT IN LEAD ,IN STEAD OF ADDING 2.5 ATR VALUE IN LAST CLOSING PRICE ,YOU SUBSTRACTED 2.5 ATR FROM YOUR SELLING PRICE
NOW I THINK YOU CAN REALISE YOUR MISTAKE
NOW AGAIN CALKCULATE AND GIVE STOP LOSS FOR LEAD FOR MONDAY WHICH YOU WILL BE USING,SO THAT I CAN CHECK WHEATHER THIS TIME YOU ARE WRITE OR NOT ,CAN STILL CLEAR ANY CONFUSION

Todays ATR : 2.46
Closing Price : 103.20
Monday SL : 103.20+2.46=105.66

 

[ashwani chadha]

Todays ATR : 2.46
Closing Price : 103.20
Monday SL : 103.20+2.46=105.66

wrong 2.46x2.5=6.15+103.20=109.35 this is your stop loss for lead for monday,the same way you will shift your stop loss every day in the morning or buy instructing your broker at mobile at 10 from your office

 

[ashwani chadha]

And these are todays values after closing..

Pivot : 104.22
R1 : 106.68
S1 : 100.73

So is is right to say our SL for monday would be 106.68

no you can use it for intraday trading at five minute or one hour time frame,for using it for eod it require more expert knowledge so at present use 2.5 atr

 

[ashwani chadha]

no you can use it for intraday trading at five minute or one hour time frame,for using it for eod it require more expert knowledge so at present use 2.5 atr

i am going out for few hours