how much return you expect from commodity market

[ashwani chadha]

it is s follows...
On 03 Oct BOUGHT GOLD at 26462 target 26725 achieved,Profit Rs.26300

On 03 Oct BOUGHT SILVER at 51988 target 52755 achieved,Profit Rs.23010

On 03 Oct SOLD LEAD at 96.70 target 95.75 achieved,Profit Rs.4750

On 03 Oct SOLD NICKEL at 865.10 stop loss 873.9 triggered, Loss Rs.2200

On 04 Oct BOUGHT GOLD at 26839 target 26972 achieved,Profit Rs.13300

On 04 Oct SOLD CRUDE at 3785 target 3728 achieved,Profit Rs.5700

On 04 Oct BOUGHT NICKEL at 949.20 target 958.40 achieved,Profit Rs.2300

On 04 Oct SOLD LEAD at 96.10 target 94.70 achieved,Profit Rs.7000

On 05 Oct BOUGHT CRUDE at 3833 target 3870 achieved,Profit Rs.3700

On 05 Oct SOLD COPPER at 335.20 stop loss 338.65 triggered, Loss Rs.3450

On 05 Oct BOUGHT ZINC at 93.10 stop loss 92.15 triggered, Loss Rs.4750

On 06 Oct BOUGHT NAT.GAS at 175.50 target 178.00 achieved,Profit Rs.3125

On 06 Oct BOUGHT LEAD at 96.55 stop loss 95.60 triggered, Loss Rs.4750

On 07 Oct SOLD GOLD at 26296 target 26165 achieved,Profit Rs.13100

On 07 Oct BOUGHT CRUDE at 4077 target 4117 achieved,Profit Rs.4000

On 07 Oct STBT NAT.GAS at 175.20 target 170.80 achieved,Profit Rs.5500

On 07 Oct BOUGHT NICKEL at 947.0 stop loss 937.60 triggered, Loss Rs.2350

On 10 Oct BTST GOLD at 26444 target 26706 achieved,Profit Rs.26200

On 10 Oct BOUGHT SILVER at 52879 target 53401 achieved,Profit Rs.15660

On 10 Oct SOLD NAT.GAS at 170.60 stop loss 172.40 triggered, Loss Rs.2250

On 10 Oct BOUGHT CRUDE at 4118 target 4179 achieved,Profit Rs.6100

On 10 Oct BOUGHT NICKEL at 938.30 target 952.20 achieved,Profit Rs.3475

On 11 Oct SOLD NICKEL at 948.20 target 933.90 achieved,Profit Rs.3575

On 11 Oct SOLD ZINC at 93.90 target 92.50 achieved,Profit Rs.7000

On 11 Oct SOLD LEAD at 97.00 target 96.10 achieved,Profit Rs.4500

On 11 Oct SOLD CRUDE at 4155 stop loss 4197 triggered, Loss Rs.4200

On 12 Oct BOUGHT SILVER at 53552 target 54350 achieved,Profit Rs.23940

On 12 Oct STBT CRUDE at 4203 target 4140 achieved,Profit Rs.6300

On 12 Oct SOLD NAT.GAS at 176.60 target 172.30 achieved,Profit Rs.5375

On 13 Oct BOUGHT COPPER at 362.60 target 366.20 achieved,Profit Rs.3600

On 13 Oct BOUGHT CRUDE at 4146 target 4187 achieved,Profit Rs.4100

On 13 Oct SOLD NICKEL at 928.90 target 905.60 achieved,Profit Rs.5825

On 13 Oct SOLD ZINC at 94.45 target 93.50 achieved,Profit Rs.4750

On 13 Oct SOLD LEAD at 99.25 target 97.80 achieved,Profit Rs.7250

On 14 Oct BOUGHT COPPER at 366.20 target 371.60 achieved,Profit Rs.5400

On 14 Oct SOLD CRUDE at 4164 stop loss 4205 triggered, Loss Rs.4100

On 14 Oct BOUGHT NICKEL at 917.30 target 930.80 achieved,Profit Rs.3375

On 14 Oct BOUGHT NAT.GAS at 176.30 target 180.50 achieved,Profit Rs.5250

On 17 Oct STBT ZINC at 94.00 target 91.75 achieved,Profit Rs.11250

On 17 Oct SOLD LEAD at 98.15 target 96.70 achieved,Profit Rs.7250

On 18 Oct BOUGHT LEAD at 94.80 target 95.70 achieved,Profit Rs.4500

On 18 Oct SOLD GOLD at 26751 target 26447 achieved,Profit Rs.30400

On 18 Oct SOLD SILVER at 52407 target 51616 achieved,Profit Rs.23730

On 19 Oct SOLD SILVER at 52817 target 52552 achieved,Profit Rs.7950

On 19 Oct SOLD COPPER at 366.20 target 357.05 achieved,Profit Rs.9150

On 19 Oct SOLD ZINC at 91.85 target 90.50 achieved,Profit Rs.6750

On 19 Oct SOLD LEAD at 94.40 target 92.05 achieved,Profit Rs.11750

On 19 Oct BOUGHT NAT.GAS at 178.1 stop loss 176.2 triggered, Loss Rs.2375

On 20 Oct BOUGHT GOLD at 26233 target 26309 achieved,Profit Rs.7600

On 20 Oct BOUGHT NAT.GAS at 180.60 target 185.00 achieved,Profit Rs.5500

On 21 Oct BOUGHT SILVER at 52068 target 52844 achieved,Profit Rs.23280

On 21 Oct SOLD LEAD at 91.10 stop loss 92.00 triggered, Loss Rs.4500

On 21 Oct BOUGHT NICKEL at 915.50 target 938.10 achieved,Profit Rs.5650

On 21 Oct SOLD NAT.GAS at 181.30 target 178.60 achieved,Profit Rs.3375

On 24 Oct SOLD LEAD at 97.80 target 96.75 achieved,Profit Rs.5250

On 24 Oct BOUGHT CRUDE at 4413 target 4522 achieved,Profit Rs.10900

On 24 Oct BOUGHT NICKEL at 946.60 target 970.10 achieved,Profit Rs.5875

On 24 Oct BOUGHT ZINC at 91.90 target 93.20 achieved,Profit Rs.6500

On 25 Oct BOUGHT GOLD at 26825 target 27285 achieved,Profit Rs.46000

On 25 Oct SOLD COPPER at 375.75 target 370.05 achieved,Profit Rs.5700

On 25 Oct BOUGHT CRUDE at 4582 target 4650 achieved,Profit Rs.6800

On 25 Oct SOLD ZINC at 92.05 target 90.70 achieved,Profit Rs.6750

On 27 Oct BOUGHT NICKEL at 963.80 target 978.20 achieved,Profit Rs.3600

On 27 Oct BOUGHT COPPER at 396.65 target 402.45 achieved,Profit Rs.5800

On 27 Oct BOUGHT ZINC at 93.80 stop loss 92.85 triggered, Loss Rs.4750

On 27 Oct BOUGHT NAT.GAS at 188.0 stop loss 186.1 triggered, Loss Rs.2375

On 28 Oct BOUGHT NICKEL at 958.30 target 967.80 achieved,Profit Rs.2375

On 28 Oct SOLD COPPER at 397.50 target 391.50 achieved,Profit Rs.6000

On 28 Oct SOLD CRUDE at 4571 target 4504 achieved,Profit Rs.6700

On 28 Oct SOLD LEAD at 98.55 target 97.10 achieved,Profit Rs.7250

On 31 Oct SOLD GOLD at 27366 target 27254 achieved,Profit Rs.11200

On 31 Oct SOLD SILVER at 56427 target 56141 achieved,Profit Rs.8580

On 31 Oct SOLD CRUDE at 4511 target 4466 achieved,Profit Rs.4500

On 31 Oct BOUGHT COPPER at 389.40 target 393.25 achieved,Profit Rs.3850

On 31 Oct BOUGHT ZINC at 94.50 target 96.85 achieved,Profit Rs.11750

i checked 6 to seven data so far,but it looks data are for oct contract ,which are already expired so can not be checked
please give only those lots,who are still not expired Nov lots so that i can check them ,please also give which month contract data is.
you can give just 10 to 20 trades -i will give you complete report ,where he stands,but still i am not giving any comment(also mention that when trade given what was the stop loss,if he has not given detail of the stop loses in his spread sheet,then remember every thing is 100 %fake-if some one gives detail of profits,with out showing stop loses used, while taking trades ,it means as a trader ,he deserve minus rating,he can not be awarded even zero out of 100 marks.

 

[ashwani chadha]

Ashwani sir , please continue

dear vishu mahajan,,in last one week when i noticed that in my demo Forex trading account,charts on silver/gold/copper/crude oil were also available,so i concentrated on the movement of these commodities in international market in dollars and now i am in a position to trade in Indian market but by taking signal for entry and exit from international market,during those 14 hour when our market and international market both are open and it is giving better signals for entry and in the morning i knew that what happened in inter national market when our market was closed from 12pm to 10 am next day,let us see how we can take benefit of this pre hand information of price before opening of Indian market

 

[ashwani chadha]

dear vishu mahajan,,in last one week when i noticed that in my demo Forex trading account,charts on silver/gold/copper/crude oil were also available,so i concentrated on the movement of these commodities in international market in dollars and now i am in a position to trade in Indian market but by taking signal for entry and exit from international market,during those 14 hour when our market and international market both are open and it is giving better signals for entry and in the morning i knew that what happened in inter national market when our market was closed from 12pm to 10 am next day,let us see how we can take benefit of this pre hand information of price before opening of Indian market

dear hills 5000 and ayush 2020
just tell me now i should load,which forex demo a/c from where i can get data of zink lead n.gas.nickel aluminum and nifty also
second thing is my demo a/c is not permitting me to trade in metal,copper crude etc although it provide data of these commodities,so which demo a/c will permit me to trade in commodity also,even if any other viewer can guide ,i will be thank full

 

[Trader Singh]

Dear Sir thanks a lot for your valuable posts. Can you explain a little more for EOD strategy technique to trade in commodities with an example to take a positional trade. Please advise for trades on monday 14/11/2011 for EOD technique especially in LEADMINI, any other base metals.

 

[ashwani chadha]

Dear Sir thanks a lot for your valuable posts. Can you explain a little more for EOD strategy technique to trade in commodities with an example to take a positional trade. Please advise for trades on monday 14/11/2011 for EOD technique especially in LEADMINI, any other base metals.

dear trader Singh,
first thing i would like to tell you that even if we do not want to take higher risks in commodity market,but if we will concentrate on five small lots the risk is equal
FOR TRADING IN ZINK MINI/LEAD MINI/ALUMINI MINI WE REQUIRE 1% STOP LOSS AT THE TIME OF ENTRY WHICH COMES APP 1000/- PER LOT TRADED
IN SILVER MICRO DUE TO OVER VOLATILITY,WE REQUIRE 2% WHICH ALSO COMES APP 1200/- PER MICRO LOT
IN CASE OF GOLD,DUE TO VERY LOWER VOLATILITY,WE REQUIRE JUST 1/2 %STOP LOSS WHICH IS AGAIN APP 1500/- PER MINI LOT
SO WHAT I WANT TO EXPLAIN IS ,THAT AS RISK AT THE TIME OF ENTRY IN ALL THE ABOVE FIVE IS APP EQUAL,SO ALL THE TIME CONCENTRATE ON ALL THE FIVE,NOT ON ANY ONE OR TWO SPECIFIC LIKE LEAD OR ZINK
AT PRESENT OUT OF THE ABOVE FIVE FOUR ARE IN RANGE BOUND BUT GOLD IS IN CLEAR UPPER MOMENTUM
SO AT PRESENT JUST CONCENTRATE ON GOLD MINI AND IF YOU CAN TRADE IN BIG LOTS THEN IN CRUDE OIL,WHICH IS IN CLEAR UPPER MOMENTUM
WHEN EVER GOLD GIVE DIP TRY TO GO LONG IN THAT WITH 150 POINT STOP LOSS ,YOU WILL BE VERY COMFORTABLE
TRY TO TAKE HELP OF RSI INDICATOR AT FIVE MINUTE TIME FRAME ,WHEN IT COMES NEAR 30 AND GIVES YOU LONG SIGNAL AT FIVE MINUTE ,GO LONG IN IT,WITH 150 POINT AS STOP LOSS
TAKE 100 TO 150 POINT AS TARGET PROFIT
AND REPEAT THIS PROCESS AGAIN AND AGAIN
FOR YOUR HELP ,I WILL GIVE LOWER SUPPORTS OF ALL THE FIVE AT EOD ,IN MY NEXT POST TO DAY,FROM WHERE YOU CAN GO LONG IN ANY OF THE FIVE,WITH ABOVE MENTIONED STOP LOSES

 

[anand14may]

dear hills 5000 and ayush 2020
just tell me now i should load,which forex demo a/c from where i can get data of zink lead n.gas.nickel aluminum and nifty also
second thing is my demo a/c is not permitting me to trade in metal,copper crude etc although it provide data of these commodities,so which demo a/c will permit me to trade in commodity also,even if any other viewer can guide ,i will be thank full

Dear Ashwani Sir,
For demo trading in Metals/Energy sector use demo account of Broco Trader. This demo account will let you place orders in real market with virtual money, a great tool to test your strategy. Quotes are real time.
I am a big fan of Metatrader Platform and do all my commodity trading in Indian market based on the signals generated by MT4. Very accurate results till date.
I also like to say thanks to you for your guidance and knowledge sharing in this forum.
Rgds

 

[hills_5000]

I Sir..just got back today. Was away for the last one week. Travelling on work and could not access the internet. Like I had mentioned before I use GCI MT4 which allows copper , natural gas and crude oil. Aluminium and Zinc I am not sure if anyone else offers.

having just gotten back I would look forward to your advice on nifty. Gold mini I have read.

regards

dear hills 5000 and ayush 2020
just tell me now i should load,which forex demo a/c from where i can get data of zink lead n.gas.nickel aluminum and nifty also
second thing is my demo a/c is not permitting me to trade in metal,copper crude etc although it provide data of these commodities,so which demo a/c will permit me to trade in commodity also,even if any other viewer can guide ,i will be thank full

 

[ashwani chadha]

Dear Ashwani Sir,
For demo trading in Metals/Energy sector use demo account of Broco Trader. This demo account will let you place orders in real market with virtual money, a great tool to test your strategy. Quotes are real time.
I am a big fan of Metatrader Platform and do all my commodity trading in Indian market based on the signals generated by MT4. Very accurate results till date.
I also like to say thanks to you for your guidance and knowledge sharing in this forum.
Rgds

dear anand you are most welcome!!!

 

[ashwani chadha]

i sir..just got back today. Was away for the last one week. Travelling on work and could not access the internet. Like i had mentioned before i use gci mt4 which allows copper , natural gas and crude oil. Aluminium and zinc i am not sure if anyone else offers.

Having just gotten back i would look forward to your advice on nifty. Gold mini i have read.

Regards

lower support lead nov 98/40
----do--------- zink nov 95/70
----do-------alumini nov 106/50
----do-------silver 56900
----do-------gold 28547
in lead /zink/alumini/silver we will try to go long from lower support as per stop loss mentioned in previous post
but gold is in long momentum so we will try to go long from 28751 which is its pivot support with 28547 as stop loss
all supports are on end of day basis

 

[ashwani chadha]

lower support lead nov 98/40
----do--------- zink nov 95/70
----do-------alumini nov 106/50
----do-------silver 56900
----do-------gold 28547
in lead /zink/alumini/silver we will try to go long from lower support as per stop loss mentioned in previous post
but gold is in long momentum so we will try to go long from 28751 which is its pivot support with 28547 as stop loss
all supports are on end of day basis

i would like to clarify that we may not get positions to day,but when we get positions at eod then their profit per trade comes in thousands not in hundreds and normally we get positions when their is a major gap down opening in the morning at that time normally eod long are accumulated and they stay for next few days and gives good profit after 5 to 15 days of holding them,your average trade will come hardly one per day ,but each eod trade profit will be equal to ten intra day trades