Point and figure chart analysis...!

praveen98

Well-Known Member
#43
Hi,
Thanks for the chart.
which software are u using to plot intraday ?

regds,
s
Hi,
I am using a free excel tool developed by one Mr.Rajiv Lochan Sarkar...:thumb:

I am very grateful to him for developing this tool and sharing it for free to fellow traders....:clapping:
God bless him..
Regards,
praveen
 
#44
Hi,
I am using a free excel tool developed by one Mr.Rajiv Lochan Sarkar...:thumb:

I am very grateful to him for developing this tool and sharing it for free to fellow traders....:clapping:
God bless him..
Regards,
praveen
Hi,
Thanks for the reply. is it possible for your to share it here.

regds,
s
 

Dax Devil

Well-Known Member
#48
Hi,
I am posting NF OCT series pnf chart for today...data is upto 10:50AM ...further i will post whenever i find during the day...its difficult but i will try my level best..See the beautiful bearish resistance lines...chart is 3X3 1Minute high-low chart...
Note : Many are of the opinion that pnf is for positional trading and not for intra day trading....but thats not right....it can be used to perfection for intra day also ...albeit with small box size as linkon sir said in this thread earlie
Happy trading:clap:
It is not a matter of opinion whether PNF is for positional trading or not. It just is. Two things make it so. First, inbuilt S and R filtering that is most effective only with real demand and supply (not the virtual ones in intraday). Second, no time constraints (intraday trading is totally time bound).

Having said that, there is no harm in experimentation and tweaking if tweaking shows more odds to improve upon the original. Point to remember is, using a knife to unscrew a screw when a screwdriver is not available makes sense. But using a knife when all kinds of screwdrivers are available is...well, a matter of choice.

BTW, PNF on EOD or weekly do prove very effective in showing the overall trend.

Good luck. And I hope you will take this post in the right spirit.
 

praveen98

Well-Known Member
#49
It is not a matter of opinion whether PNF is for positional trading or not. It just is. Two things make it so. First, inbuilt S and R filtering that is most effective only with real demand and supply (not the virtual ones in intraday). Second, no time constraints (intraday trading is totally time bound).

Having said that, there is no harm in experimentation and tweaking if tweaking shows more odds to improve upon the original. Point to remember is, using a knife to unscrew a screw when a screwdriver is not available makes sense. But using a knife when all kinds of screwdrivers are available is...well, a matter of choice.

BTW, PNF on EOD or weekly do prove very effective in showing the overall trend.

Good luck. And I hope you will take this post in the right spirit.
Hi Dax Devil,
Yes, of course i will take your view point in right spirit ....having said that like all TA tools pnf is also a tool,with it's genesis on trading floor....as a pure intra day recording method of round number ticks...
Most of the people who are of the opinion that pnf is for positional trading are most probably have never tried it for intra day trading ....Have you ever tried pnf for intra day trading? Most probably you have not....
Please experiment in your free time with it ...if you are really interested how it works in intra day...then come to a conclusion....
Most of the TA followers believe in fractals...if it shows support , resistance demand supply levels clearly in Weekly time frame ...the same thing should work in intra day too...The only difference is box size...we should use smaller box sizes than daily or weekly charts for intra day trading....
please go through the following chart ...of 23rd september intraday chart of NFSEP24 ...see how beautifully pnf kept you in the trade till the end...
http://screencast.com/t/qkaR889yop

Have a nice weekend..
 

Dax Devil

Well-Known Member
#50
Hi Dax Devil,
Yes, of course i will take your view point in right spirit ....having said that like all TA tools pnf is also a tool,with it's genesis on trading floor....as a pure intra day recording method of round number ticks...
Most of the people who are of the opinion that pnf is for positional trading are most probably have never tried it for intra day trading ....Have you ever tried pnf for intra day trading? Most probably you have not....
Please experiment in your free time with it ...if you are really interested how it works in intra day...then come to a conclusion....
Most of the TA followers believe in fractals...if it shows support , resistance demand supply levels clearly in Weekly time frame ...the same thing should work in intra day too...The only difference is box size...we should use smaller box sizes than daily or weekly charts for intra day trading....
please go through the following chart ...of 23rd september intraday chart of NFSEP24 ...see how beautifully pnf kept you in the trade till the end...
http://screencast.com/t/qkaR889yop

Have a nice weekend..
I have tried it, friend, otherwise I wouldn't open my mouth. I only use it while trading stocks (not index) positionally. Its use with intraday data, however in my trading, has never been as effective as I want my trading tool to be.
I take trading business quite seriously, particularly the intraday trading. Little slippages, early exits or late entries are just no no for me. Thankfully I have my own set of precise trading tools to deal with them, so it is ok. However, if PNF works for you, then great. Main thing is, profit. Any whichway it comes from.

You too have a Nice weekend. Take care.
 

Similar threads