rahulg77 said:
HI amit,
How are you? an interesting twist to your intelluctual image.
I myself am interested in sufi but do not understand urdu a lot. but i keep going to see concerts like jahane khusro and other cultural events that keep happening in delhi. Are u based in delhi too?
Regards
Rahul
Hi Rahul...great to know you are interested in Sufism.
Isn't it the most beautiful way of understanding life and reality in a spiritual way which shies away from all the discordant notes that a rigid following of most religious tenets would lead to. It makes love for humanity and the divine accessible in one go without separating the two.
I’ve lived in Delhi for several years in the past, and tried to visit the Hazrat Nizamuddin Durgah on Thursdays when there was Sufi music performed.
On to mundane matters.
I’ve seen the thread you’ve started under Technical Analysis, and the issues raised there.
1. Yes, when calculating weekly or monthly SMA you’d use the weekly or monthly closing prices.
2. As to the question on time periods, this depends purely on one’s trading objective.
Firstly, SMA work best when a scrip is trending and is ineffective when it is moving in a trading range, as far as entering a trade goes. In fact they are used to establish whether the move is trending or not, and if so, whether the trend is down or up. This can as easily be seen by observing the price chart too, of course.
Now, for using SMAs for making trading decisions, it should be clear that smaller the time unit the more signals would be generated. Meaning, short tome frames are more sensitive to price change. This may suit short term trades.
But then, the issue is whether a sensitive short term SMA is reliable.
A short and sensitive setting would generate more buy/sell signals, but there would also be an increase in false signals leading to whipsaws.
Longer time settings would generate less signals, but they would be more reliable. On the other hand, being less sensitive, the time lag would increase and the signal would come after the trend is well on its way. That’s a tradeoff one has to weigh and measure.
I personally don’t use moving average crossovers for entering trades, but on the price chart I have three settings for SMAs: 20-50-200. I don’t often enter short term trades, and since I try to catch the whole of the move, these help in locating the current price in relation to the time periods.
There is no such thing as ‘Indian stocks’, as stocks are stocks anywhere.
What one has to look for is the historical volatility of a stock. One which is more volatile would require a longer time frame to smoothen out noise and volatility. A more sedate and steady scrip could do with a shorter time frame.
3. As to RSI settings, the logic would be the same as above, but conventionally RSI is not really used for longer time frames. Usually a 21-25 day setting is suggested for intermediate term readings and 7, 9 or 14 for short terms.
4. Understanding the workings of a formula for an indicator is as relevant as understanding the grammatical construction of a new language one begins to learn. They go hand in hand. One would better attain the workings of an indicator by also knowing what exactly it does and how.
Hope this has helped clear your doubts, and do get back for any clarifications.
Bye for now.