You asked a very inspiring question in a simple way.
" if a strategy is failing 80 % of time why not use it opposite way and make money "
Virtually it looks correct. But i think its not possible consistently.
There are many aspects to, why this logic wont work. But one simple answer is already there in your question.
You said lot of wrong signals in range bound market. This is not enough.
If you see lot of wrong signals in every kind of market ( trending/choppy --not just range bound ) then your idea of opposite signals may work.
A Rain coat for a rainy Day. And umbrella for a sunny day.
Is Rain coat useful .. YES on a Rainy day
Is Rain coat useful ..NO on a Sunny day
Problem is not with rain coat ..its with the climate.
Problem is not with the strategy... its with market.
What kind of Move in market( trending/choppy etc ) - will decide the success/failure of the strategy. So even if we take opposite signals of our strategy they wont work consistently beacuse market movement wont be consistent.
Here enters the Analysts - They say -
"Follow this strategy for trending market" " Follow that strategy for range bound market" .......... :lol:isn't it ?
" if a strategy is failing 80 % of time why not use it opposite way and make money "
Virtually it looks correct. But i think its not possible consistently.
There are many aspects to, why this logic wont work. But one simple answer is already there in your question.
You said lot of wrong signals in range bound market. This is not enough.
If you see lot of wrong signals in every kind of market ( trending/choppy --not just range bound ) then your idea of opposite signals may work.
A Rain coat for a rainy Day. And umbrella for a sunny day.
Is Rain coat useful .. YES on a Rainy day
Is Rain coat useful ..NO on a Sunny day
Problem is not with rain coat ..its with the climate.
Problem is not with the strategy... its with market.
What kind of Move in market( trending/choppy etc ) - will decide the success/failure of the strategy. So even if we take opposite signals of our strategy they wont work consistently beacuse market movement wont be consistent.
Here enters the Analysts - They say -
"Follow this strategy for trending market" " Follow that strategy for range bound market" .......... :lol:isn't it ?
Can you please tell something about how to predict that commodity market trending or rangebound.
Or give some idea about it.