Zerodha - Number One Discount Broker in India

I believe you were filing ITR 4. If yes, can you share if the CA provides online services like Audit of TO. And also his fees.
Yes, since I'd done intraday stocks as well as futures trading. I'll be paying him 4k. I don't really know him that well, so I'll just PM you his mobile & e-mail, so that you can personally talk to him about your specific situation.
 

comm4300

Well-Known Member
Yes, since I'd done intraday stocks as well as futures trading. I'll be paying him 4k. I don't really know him that well, so I'll just PM you his mobile & e-mail, so that you can personally talk to him about your specific situation.
4k is 1/3rd of what iam paying right now. Sounds like a good deal. Need to ensure that this is indeed his fees for "Audit"
 

Raj232

Well-Known Member
Hey,

I am using kite now a days and liking it a lot. One issue is that only the current/latest value of the indicator is visible in charts.

Please make changes to show the value of indicators based on the mouse position on previous bars as well !
Although many are liking KITE, it is because they have not seen other trading platforms like Sharekhan TradeTiger or KotakSecurities KEAT terminal. The KITE web interface is for newbies who are trying to understand the stock market .. a good start but definitely cannot be used for professional trading, like using indicators etc. as orders need to be be typed in manually.

Also, in KITE there is an option of Bracket Order (BO), Unfortunately not many traders know that they are supposed to be continuously connected to the internet for BO functionality to work :annoyed: :annoyed:
A trader mentioned "prime intention of a bracket is that our order is protected, so incase power goes off or internet disconnects or anything of this sort happens, mentally we are calm because we know that our order is protected. but sadly, thats not the case with this bracket. apart from this, i don't see any other reason that too for a day trader to use bracket."

Also, a single order for 750 Nifty Futures (10 lots) may get traded in 10 different trades, Zerodha Discount brokerage will charge you as 10 orders (10 X 20 = Rs 200) instead of Rs 20 for 1 order even though you placed 1 order.
Initially it was said: Zerodha charge Rs.20 Per executed order or 0.01 whichever is lower . but does not seem to be true in reality.. .. Zerodha should clarify...

That's the fine print my friend :mad: which most traders have overlooked, which may cost as Rs 20 per lot instead of Rs 20 per order.. nobody read the fine print :D:D while Zerodha (so called Discount brokerage) is laughing its way to the bank :clap:

... hope this will help Zerodha to correct the incorrect policy it applies related to Bracket order.:)
 
Last edited:
Although many are liking KITE, it is because they have not seen other trading platforms like Sharekhan TradeTiger or KotakSecurities KEAT terminal. The KITE web interface is for newbies who are trying to understand the stock market .. a good start but definitely cannot be used for professional trading, like using indicators etc. as orders need to be be typed in manually.

Also, in KITE there is an option of Bracket Order (BO), Unfortunately not many traders know that they are supposed to be continuously connected to the internet for BO functionality to work :annoyed: :annoyed:

Also, a single order for 750 Nifty Futures (10 lots) may get traded in 10 different trades, Zerodha Discount brokerage will charge you as 10 orders (10 X 20 = Rs 200) instead of 1 order even though you inputted 1 order.

That's the fine print my friend :mad: which most traders have overlooked, which may cost as Rs 20 per lot instead of Rs 20 per order.. nobody read the fine print :D:D while Zerodha (so called Discount brokerage) is laughing its way to the bank :clap:

... hope this will help Zerodha to correct the incorrect policy it applies related to Bracket order.:)
Not really. It will be charged for one order only as far as I know.
 

Raj232

Well-Known Member
Not really. It will be charged for one order only as far as I know.
Are you stating out of experience or out of interpretation. Refer Zerodha's blog on Tradingqna

"Disadvantages of BRACKET ORDER" http://tradingqna.com/1418/what-advantage-and-disadvantage-bracket-order-for-traders

Limit orders are not possible during exit. Executed exit price will be market price and can slightly move up or down and form a slippage from your assumption.
Entry through Stop Loss trigger is not allowed so you have to submit the Bracket Order at exactly the right moment.
Order cancellation is not possible, you need to close your position once you have entered.
You need to be logged in while your target or SL order executes, it seems. In cover order you can do your routine job without worrying, since you have already set the stop loss and that will execute even if you are logged off.
It is possible that Bracket Orders execute as multiple chunks of small quanities charging you with higher brokerage. Example you order 10 lots of Nifty, if it gets executed as 3+3+2+2, then you need to pay 20+20+20+20 as brokerage instead of flat 20 rs for 10 lots as in cover orders." :):):)
 
Are you stating out of experience or out of interpretation. Refer Zerodha's blog on Tradingqna

"Disadvantages of BRACKET ORDER" http://tradingqna.com/1418/what-advantage-and-disadvantage-bracket-order-for-traders

Limit orders are not possible during exit. Executed exit price will be market price and can slightly move up or down and form a slippage from your assumption.
Entry through Stop Loss trigger is not allowed so you have to submit the Bracket Order at exactly the right moment.
Order cancellation is not possible, you need to close your position once you have entered.
You need to be logged in while your target or SL order executes, it seems. In cover order you can do your routine job without worrying, since you have already set the stop loss and that will execute even if you are logged off.
It is possible that Bracket Orders execute as multiple chunks of small quanities charging you with higher brokerage. Example you order 10 lots of Nifty, if it gets executed as 3+3+2+2, then you need to pay 20+20+20+20 as brokerage instead of flat 20 rs for 10 lots as in cover orders." :):):)
Many were/are indeed unaware of this. Good you made this clear. Needs to be told and retold. Bracket order seems to be of little use with discount brokers. No wonder Z has vamoosed :lol:
 
Every now and then I fave an error message in Zerodha Q - "Connection timed out. Please refresh the page."

Anyone else out there who is facing the same problem?
Oh yes, very frequently. Also, error 502.

BTW, I am eagerly waiting for the contract notes today because I think there is an issue with STT calculation. Spoke to them on seeing the ledger, but they said wait for the contract note and then check the calculations.
 

Similar threads