Zerodha - Number One Discount Broker in India

columbus

Well-Known Member
Hey Zerodha,
It will be very much helpful if a user can resize and move windows as per there wish.
When I open order-book window it covers whole chart, and it's affecting on information I am getting from chart.
So if I can able to detach & resize it, I can minimize it as per my requirement and modify my orders while looking at chart.

Hope you will consider this in your further improvements..........
Hi,

LEFT click on the order book window, you will see '+' mark thing.By choosing
Left- Right-Top -Bottom, the new window will be added.In this way you can
watch both Order and Chart window at the same time.If you choose middle
portion then the current chart will be replaced by NEW.
 
Vjay, check this: http://tradingqna.com/8843/technical-charts-google-finance-yahoo-finance-amibroker-match

NEST is not a benchmark for data. Every platform provider manages the millions of ticks that come on the server in a particular way. We are trying to benchmark most of our rules very close to what esignal follows.

So for example if you are looking at a min candle, you can start the min at 9.15 - 00 to 59 (secs) or 9.15 - 01 to 60.

We follow what esignal follows, so 00 to 59, whereas NEST follows 01 to 60. So if you are looking at 1 min chart, there might be a variance.


Also the 1st min of every day, there are going to be zillion ticks, so every platform forms that 1min candle with the ticks it is able to capture. n

One thing that will be fixed that calic was asked, we currently form the daily candles from all the 1 min candles. This will soon change to based on exchange bhavcopy. So this will ensure daily candles exactly matches with NSE and also most other platforms.

But intraday, there is no way all platforms can match each other exactly. Do check that link above.
Beg to differ here zerodha.If you start the candle at 0-59 and others 0-60;there should not be a variance,if the candle close or open is not at exact high or low;but unfortunately that is not the case with PI.I mean to say for eg if a candle starts at 0 seconds at value 8000 and at 59 seconds it is 8020,at 50 seconds it is 8025,and finally at 60 seconds it is 8019;then both the candles must be of the same size ,am I right?But in PI charts 70-90% of the swing highs&lows differ from nse tame data or Icharts data.So there definitely is some error in data.I think Iam talking sense.If not please correct me
Zerodha.Apart from criticism let me add one more thing.As far as I have seen PI is much more stable lightweight in comparison with NEST and if you fix this issue,it really is a beatiful software.Take it as positive criticism as I have been trading with you for the last three years and been a beetatester of PI too.
 

VJAY

Well-Known Member
Beg to differ here zerodha.If you start the candle at 0-59 and others 0-60;there should not be a variance,if the candle close or open is not at exact high or low;but unfortunately that is not the case with PI.I mean to say for eg if a candle starts at 0 seconds at value 8000 and at 59 seconds it is 8020,at 50 seconds it is 8025,and finally at 60 seconds it is 8019;then both the candles must be of the same size ,am I right?But in PI charts 70-90% of the swing highs&lows differ from nse tame data or Icharts data.So there definitely is some error in data.I think Iam talking sense.If not please correct me
Zerodha.Apart from criticism let me add one more thing.As far as I have seen PI is much more stable lightweight in comparison with NEST and if you fix this issue,it really is a beatiful software.Take it as positive criticism as I have been trading with you for the last three years and been a beetatester of PI too.
Exactly......High & lows of bar differe ...
 
Hi friends,

Below story is not related to this thread sorry in advance but this is simply inspirational...

NEVER GIVE UP. NEVER, NEVER GIVE UP !
An amazing story on Marvan Attapattu Srilankan Cricketer. It’s a story that Harsha Bhogle, India’s most loved cricket commentator, loves to tell, over and over again. Making his debut in Test cricket for Sri Lanka, Marvan scored a duck in his first innings. And again, in his second innings.
They dropped him. So he went back to the nets for more practice. More first-class cricket. More runs. Waiting for that elusive call. And after twenty-one months, he got a second chance.
This time, he tried harder. His scores: 0 in the first innings, 1 in the second Dropped again, he went back to the grind. And scored tonnes of runs in first-class cricket. Runs that seemed inadequate to erase the painful memories of the Test failures. Well, seventeen months later, opportunity knocked yet again. Marvan got to bat in both innings of the Test. His scores: 0 and 0. Phew!
Back to the grind. Would the selectors ever give him another chance? They said he lacked big-match temperament. His technique wasn’t good enough at the highest level. Undaunted, Marvan kept trying.
Three years later, he got another chance. This time, he made runs. He came good. And in an illustrious career thereafter, Marvan went on to score over 5000 runs for Sri Lanka. That included sixteen centuries and six double hundreds. And he went on to captain his country. All this despite taking over six years to score his second run in Test cricket. Wow! What a guy!
How many of us can handle failure as well as he did? Six years of trying, and failing. He must have been tempted to pursue another career. Change his sport perhaps. Play county cricket. Or, oh well, just give up. But he didn’t. And that made the difference.
We all hear stories of talented people who gave up before their potential was realized. People who changed jobs and careers when success seemed elusive.
The next time you are staring at possible failure or rejection, think of Marvan. And remember this: If you don’t give up, if you believe in yourself, if you stay the course, the run will eventually come. What more you could even become captain some day.
NEVER GIVE UP. NEVER, NEVER GIVE UP ! :clap::clapping::thumb:
 

Zerodha

Well-Known Member
Beg to differ here zerodha.If you start the candle at 0-59 and others 0-60;there should not be a variance,if the candle close or open is not at exact high or low;but unfortunately that is not the case with PI.I mean to say for eg if a candle starts at 0 seconds at value 8000 and at 59 seconds it is 8020,at 50 seconds it is 8025,and finally at 60 seconds it is 8019;then both the candles must be of the same size ,am I right?But in PI charts 70-90% of the swing highs&lows differ from nse tame data or Icharts data.So there definitely is some error in data.I think Iam talking sense.If not please correct me
Zerodha.Apart from criticism let me add one more thing.As far as I have seen PI is much more stable lightweight in comparison with NEST and if you fix this issue,it really is a beatiful software.Take it as positive criticism as I have been trading with you for the last three years and been a beetatester of PI too.
All criticism taken in right spirit. :)

About the EOD thing you had pointed out, we will soon start EOD based on Bhavcopy and not use 1 min candles to plot.

Data on two intraday charts are very very tough to match exactly, as explained here: http://tradingqna.com/8843/technical-charts-google-finance-yahoo-finance-amibroker-match

Cheers,
 

xsis

Active Member
@calic - they wont understand it as they dont trade and i wont be surprised if next time they have the audacity to reply by saying - so what if 1-2 points are here and there in candle OHLC, but our EOD candle would match the NSE Bhavcopy :lol:


Beg to differ here zerodha.If you start the candle at 0-59 and others 0-60;there should not be a variance,if the candle close or open is not at exact high or low;but unfortunately that is not the case with PI.I mean to say for eg if a candle starts at 0 seconds at value 8000 and at 59 seconds it is 8020,at 50 seconds it is 8025,and finally at 60 seconds it is 8019;then both the candles must be of the same size ,am I right?But in PI charts 70-90% of the swing highs&lows differ from nse tame data or Icharts data.So there definitely is some error in data.I think Iam talking sense.If not please correct me
Zerodha.Apart from criticism let me add one more thing.As far as I have seen PI is much more stable lightweight in comparison with NEST and if you fix this issue,it really is a beatiful software.Take it as positive criticism as I have been trading with you for the last three years and been a beetatester of PI too.
 
Last edited:
just downloaded and installed pi but unable to login after giving right answers to 2FA security Questions. Getting message "not able to log in, please restart again to continue"
While I am able to log in to nest trader
 

Similar threads