Zerodha....
- Thread starter bharath.mang
- Start date
- Tags bakwaas now cheapest brokerage nest nest plus new broker zerodha zerodha trader
- Status
R
@ respectinvestor,
Will you kindly point out the differences (if not all, at least a few) between NOW and all other trading platforms which you think are better than NOW? IMHO, charting is a major drawback. But quotes are very quick and much better than those given by Reliance, IIFL, Sharekhan, Kotak or ODIN. Haven't compared with Indiabulls... But I can assure you PIB doesn't update quotes so many times within a specific time interval (have used PIB 3 years back). But please point out the differences for the benefit of others.
@ reks,
Do you have something else to contribute other than bashing Zerodha in this forum!!!
Will you kindly point out the differences (if not all, at least a few) between NOW and all other trading platforms which you think are better than NOW? IMHO, charting is a major drawback. But quotes are very quick and much better than those given by Reliance, IIFL, Sharekhan, Kotak or ODIN. Haven't compared with Indiabulls... But I can assure you PIB doesn't update quotes so many times within a specific time interval (have used PIB 3 years back). But please point out the differences for the benefit of others.
@ reks,
Do you have something else to contribute other than bashing Zerodha in this forum!!!
kindly point out the differences (if not all, at least a few) between NOW and all other trading platforms:
Coming exclusively to points raised by you:
I will just compare it with KEAT PROXyou can extrapolate it to other platforms and understand the difference:
1.)every 14 days you need to find a new password write ..write first the old passwordthen write new password ..then again confirm the new passwordso one needs to write password three timescompare it to KEATjust loginI understand its for safety concerns .at the same time its a trading inconvenience for which at least ZERODHA is not responsibleone can always argue as to how much time it takes but it is an inconvenienceI can vouch for itand this is the same system which even ICICI USESand I find it inconvenient.
2.)Now have a look at the buy dialog box or sell box which appearswithin that box there are a total of 22 fieldI seriously fail to understand the utility of so many fields In KEAT PRO X..only 12 such fieldalmost half as in NSENOWand the basic p-loss price then by trigger price fieldit seriously appears very clumsy on NSENOW for which again ZERODHA is not responsible..
3.) Again for putting an order in NSENOW everytime exchange needs to be selected from COMBO BOX whether NSE or NFO.in keat there is no such problemu select the security and its doneno need to select the exchange
4.)Under net position what a trader is interested in knowing is simply whether he is in plus or minus by comparing it to the price at which he had bought or sold a particular security.and what is shown is net positionIn keat u get to know by how much you are ahead or falling behind in the game by comparing current price to ones buy or sell priceagain Zerodha is not responsible for this..
I can go on and on.but that does not solve the purposeI was just highlighting the way a trader sees all this
Hi PRaveen,
Data, you can get... you can write to excel and export data on to excel sheet.... If you are tech savy, you can use this data and do anything that you want....
The charting platform on NOW is not the greatest... you can look at TAME if you are alright with a little delay in the quotes...
Cheers..
Data, you can get... you can write to excel and export data on to excel sheet.... If you are tech savy, you can use this data and do anything that you want....
The charting platform on NOW is not the greatest... you can look at TAME if you are alright with a little delay in the quotes...
Cheers..
Hi Zerodha,
Can we trade commodities from Zerodha ?
If yes what is the procedure to enable it !
If no do you intend to start commodities trading in future ?
One advise, This thread has become very long. If you could prepare an index of the thread and post in the beginning of the thread, then readers searching for a particular topic may save the trouble of reading the entire thread.
Regards
Can we trade commodities from Zerodha ?
If yes what is the procedure to enable it !
If no do you intend to start commodities trading in future ?
One advise, This thread has become very long. If you could prepare an index of the thread and post in the beginning of the thread, then readers searching for a particular topic may save the trouble of reading the entire thread.
Regards
Hi Zerodha,
Can we trade commodities from Zerodha ?
If yes what is the procedure to enable it !
If no do you intend to start commodities trading in future ?
One advise, This thread has become very long. If you could prepare an index of the thread and post in the beginning of the thread, then readers searching for a particular topic may save the trouble of reading the entire thread.
Regards
Can we trade commodities from Zerodha ?
If yes what is the procedure to enable it !
If no do you intend to start commodities trading in future ?
One advise, This thread has become very long. If you could prepare an index of the thread and post in the beginning of the thread, then readers searching for a particular topic may save the trouble of reading the entire thread.
Regards
index of the thread!! hmm.. let me figure out how to...
R
:clap::clap:
Coming to your point of view regarding this average trader who trades at least 10 lots of NIFTY FUTURES in a day.An active trader as defined by you does at least 10*20=200 lots of NIFTY in a monthso considering that NIFTY ia @5000 an active trader does a transaction worth 200*50*5000= 5 crores in a monthso for that person to be wiped out completely it requires losses to the tune of only .2% to and I have seen enough of thisso I bet that person will be out of the stock market in the first month of his trading itselfAnybody who has been in the market long enough will vouch for this factso after the first month he wont be in a position to give brokerage either to ZERODHA or some other entities like an ICICI or a KOTAK or a RELIGARE or an INDIAINFOLINEHe has to die
Again ZERODHA has an edge hereif that person wipes out his capital completely he c:clap:an shift the blame to the tune of 20000 to his broker if he has been charged @4paisa.150000 if he has been charged @3 paisa and 10000 if he has been charged @2 paisaZERODHA makes great sense here because if to trade in 200 lots of NIFTY a person has traded only 100 timesthen the maximum blame game he can play is to the tune of 2000 onlyThis is indeed a great value for money
So your break-even concept is full of faulty assumptionsand I take this privilege to challenge ZERODHA to come up with facts regarding even 20 active traders of the variety as mentioned above and whether they were alive in this market after even 2-3 months with the amount of capital they started with
Look here point is very simpleno one makes money just because the brokerage he gave was lessA person who can not make money @3 paisa brokerage charges is definitely not going to make money even @.5 paisaor @RS. 20 flat as brokerage
At the same time ZERODHA makes great sense to a compulsive trader who needs to trade alwaysone would be saving a lot in terms of brokerageso please do not propagate this fallacy of 2.5 lacs of brokerage vs. 25k of brokeragethat person who indeed made money because of low brokerage at least can not be found on this planet earthhe must be on moonat the same time there are a very rare variety of traders who have indeed worked hard and are able to make money.probably 1 in a 100ZERODHA does make immense sense to this rare breed also
@PGDIMESjust wrote what I felttook inspiration from youand I assume you have been in the markets long enough to concur with the facts I have stated..
Again ZERODHA has an edge hereif that person wipes out his capital completely he c:clap:an shift the blame to the tune of 20000 to his broker if he has been charged @4paisa.150000 if he has been charged @3 paisa and 10000 if he has been charged @2 paisaZERODHA makes great sense here because if to trade in 200 lots of NIFTY a person has traded only 100 timesthen the maximum blame game he can play is to the tune of 2000 onlyThis is indeed a great value for money
So your break-even concept is full of faulty assumptionsand I take this privilege to challenge ZERODHA to come up with facts regarding even 20 active traders of the variety as mentioned above and whether they were alive in this market after even 2-3 months with the amount of capital they started with
Look here point is very simpleno one makes money just because the brokerage he gave was lessA person who can not make money @3 paisa brokerage charges is definitely not going to make money even @.5 paisaor @RS. 20 flat as brokerage
At the same time ZERODHA makes great sense to a compulsive trader who needs to trade alwaysone would be saving a lot in terms of brokerageso please do not propagate this fallacy of 2.5 lacs of brokerage vs. 25k of brokeragethat person who indeed made money because of low brokerage at least can not be found on this planet earthhe must be on moonat the same time there are a very rare variety of traders who have indeed worked hard and are able to make money.probably 1 in a 100ZERODHA does make immense sense to this rare breed also
@PGDIMESjust wrote what I felttook inspiration from youand I assume you have been in the markets long enough to concur with the facts I have stated..
- Status
