Zerodha....

[Sridhar795318]

1.zerodha is offering -> flat 20rs offer on transaction
2.sharekhan is offring->0.25% on one transaction;
now considering i am a newbie,and would invest atmost 3000-4000 on one stock,i guess the charges for one transaction comes to:
zerodha= 40 (20+20)
sharekhan=buy(0.25 % of 4000) + sell(0.25% of 5000))=so total i will get around transaction charge atmost 30.
now what are the other charges(additional charges) for sharekhan and zerodha in addition to this?

There is a brokerage calculator on the Zerodha site. That can help clarify a lot of doubts like these. Make sure you add the stamp duty (only once) for all transactions put together at end of day.

and suggest me which is better among two except the charges point of view

Generally Sharekhan is a lot more expensive than Zerodha. For identical trades with close buy & sell price, it is possible that Zerodha will show a profit and Sharekhan will show a loss.
If I were in your position I would go with Zerodha. For charts 1. use free yahoo data feed along with Amibroker or 2. use free web based charts. Lot of people do it like this.

 

[rgshare]

There is a brokerage calculator on the Zerodha site. That can help clarify a lot of doubts like these. Make sure you add the stamp duty (only once) for all transactions put together at end of day.


Generally Sharekhan is a lot more expensive than Zerodha. For identical trades with close buy & sell price, it is possible that Zerodha will show a profit and Sharekhan will show a loss.
If I were in your position I would go with Zerodha. For charts 1. use free yahoo data feed along with Amibroker or 2. use free web based charts. Lot of people do it like this.

ok..i used the brokerage calculator of zerodha.actually i was considering it as a flat 20 rs deal per trade.
for charts,do the free websites like moneycontrol or rediff show realtime results?whats the advantage of using sharekhan (i am asking for charting purposes,not trading)over zerodha?

 

[FXCMholic]

Thanks for the reply. can you please let us know which Gingerbread mobile you have used.

In the supported mobiles PDF present in Zerodha backoffice site, it is mentioned that NSE NOW mobile app is supported only from Android 1.6 to 2.2.
Gingerbread mobiles are not supported. Also in the user reviews in the below link, some people have mentioned that it is not working on some Gingerbread(2.3) mobiles.

https://market.android.com/details?id=com.msf.nse&hl=en

But I have seen it work on Samsung galaxy s2 and galaxy R..

Planning to buy Galaxy Note mainly for google finance charts and NSE now... So just wanted to be sure before I spend 32K...

I am using HTC SensationXE handset with Gingerbread v2.3.5. I didn't face any issue with NSEMobile app. at all at any time, not a single time Force Close. So it SHOULD work on any Android device v1.6x onwards.

 

[jain.er]

Shekhar, the spread order window is used for hedging your bets. My answers to your questions are given below:

To place a spread order please do the following:
1. Press "Ctrl + Shift + F1" to get the order window open. For trading a spread, you have to put your price as the difference between the two contracts. For example, if you want to buy the Nifty spread and the price difference between the two calendar months is 40 points, you have to put 40 as the price in the price window.
2. You can choose the type of order you want:
a. Spread (calendar): This by default chooses one buy and one sell.
b. 2L: You can choose to buy or sell both legs.
c. 3L: You can choose to trade three legs at the same time.
3. Once the order is chosen, decide the quantity and the price. If it's not a spread order, then you have to put the price for each contract individually.
4. Click on submit and you're done.

IOC means Immediate or Cancel

All spread orders are NRML in nature.

Hope this information helps.

Hari

Are spreads orders only IOC , cant we place limit orders ?

 

[ambarish123]

Help i cant c my orders,i want to modify a buy order but i cant c it in my order window im shrt in mnf which gt executed today cant c that either in trade book....bachaaaaao

 

[sumosanammain]

Help i cant c my orders,i want to modify a buy order but i cant c it in my order window im shrt in mnf which gt executed today cant c that either in trade book....bachaaaaao

go to preferences. general. reconcile. click 2 times. then click on display in order window.

 

[shekharinvest]

Are spreads orders only IOC , cant we place limit orders ?

I don't believe that one can place 2L or 3L spread order with price limit. It has to be immediate at whatever price is being offered for all the 2 or 3 instruments you might choose. { except for the main instrument, first one on the list}

Alternatively, you can place 2 or 3 separate limit orders and provide margins for each of them. You won't be able to get the margin benefit of spread orders.

SHEKHAR

 

[ambarish123]

go to preferences. general. reconcile. click 2 times. then click on display in order window.

cant c general

 

[trader.trends]

cant c general

user settings

 

[sumosanammain]

cant c general

Soreeeeeeeee! its preferences-user settings-general...

My mistake