It is good if a member posts a method or a teqnique for buy/sell but many times members post that they have bought here and sold there.....and made so much money....I am inviting members views on the following :
1) When a person claims that he has bought and sold at a level, does he need to give evidence unless he posts in real time ? . Or shall we stop all I bought here and sold there type of posts ??
2) When the post is a method then the trader may not have taken all the trades on that method so he need not post trades evidence.
3) When a member posts model trades on a fully disclosed method, he may or maynot have taken all trades as per those model trades. But that post must carry a heading of Model trades not actual trades.This will help people understand what are model trades as per that method but a member posting wont get a chance to boast . We find that most of the tipsters use this route for attracting clients who think that the person has taken all the trades so he wants tips from him.
4) If we make such rules, then members posting levels etc without evidence will have to stop ...are members ready to accept the same ??
Let us get feedback from members so that we can make some rules regarding the same. Feedback should be in the form of guiding principle and not fight and personal accusations by anyone.
Smart_trade
1) When a person claims that he has bought and sold at a level, does he need to give evidence unless he posts in real time ? . Or shall we stop all I bought here and sold there type of posts ??
2) When the post is a method then the trader may not have taken all the trades on that method so he need not post trades evidence.
3) When a member posts model trades on a fully disclosed method, he may or maynot have taken all trades as per those model trades. But that post must carry a heading of Model trades not actual trades.This will help people understand what are model trades as per that method but a member posting wont get a chance to boast . We find that most of the tipsters use this route for attracting clients who think that the person has taken all the trades so he wants tips from him.
4) If we make such rules, then members posting levels etc without evidence will have to stop ...are members ready to accept the same ??
Let us get feedback from members so that we can make some rules regarding the same. Feedback should be in the form of guiding principle and not fight and personal accusations by anyone.
Smart_trade
My feed back to your questions !!!
1) When a person claims that he has bought and sold at a level, does he need to give evidence unless he posts in real time ? . Or shall we stop all I bought here and sold there type of posts ??
Ans) yes !!!need to give evidence or just stop the posts
2) When the post is a method then the trader may not have taken all the trades on that method so he need not post trades evidence.
Ans)Yes need not post evidence !!
3) When a member posts model trades on a fully disclosed method, he may or maynot have taken all trades as per those model trades. But that post must carry a heading of Model trades not actual trades.This will help people understand what are model trades as per that method but a member posting wont get a chance to boast . We find that most of the tipsters use this route for attracting clients who think that the person has taken all the trades so he wants tips from him.
Ans) Agreed
4) If we make such rules, then members posting levels etc without evidence will have to stop ...are members ready to accept the same ??
Ans) yes!! iam ready to accept !!!
Last edited: