Going with the Intraday Mini-Flow!!
- Thread starter Saint
- Start date
- Tags intra day live intraday nifty miniflow miniflow live nifty futures trading nifty intraday trading saint
- Status
Hi Friends, I almost decided to join you all in real trades. The back test shows excellent results consistently. We may get two concecutive loosing days and once in a while even a loosing week (very very rare) but never a loosing calendar month!!!
However while trying to understand the Mini Flow had some doubts yet again and have addressed them to Saint as below!!! It is quiet possible that the same has already been discussed and clarified by Saint, please help me by either clarifying it again or posting a link to where Saint has clarified it!!! Requesting this to minimise the work load we already are giving Saint
and at times he has to answer the same queries again and again!!! If anyone else can help it wud save Saint some trouble!!
Thanks!!!!!
Saint, While trying to have a look at the trades posted by you for August 2008 and matching them with the Rules as understood by me, I could not corelate the trade for a few days!!! Seems I am still lacking the basics!! Have gone through the Rules yet again but seems to be either overlooking something or misenterpreting some rule!!!
Ofcourse there can be data issues also for the difference in trades!!!
On 4th August we are short below the low of 11.30 AM bar less 7!!!
The 12 AM bar makes a HH and later becomes a PH in 30 TF!!
Would it be correct to say :"Now that we have a PH in 30 we do not look for a PH in 20/15 TF!!!"
On 6th August First trade (and Only trade for the day also) taken by you is Short at 4566 and exit at 4527!!!!
A bit hazy about how the level of 4566 was arrived at, maybe 7 points below the low of 11.30 (In my charts it is 4572.45) Also as per my charts this would be the first trade so a filter of 14 was required!!! In case due to data issues this is the secong trade then the matter is clear.
However as per my data the High of 11.30 AM bar is 4598.80, the short is not yet triggered as the Short level is continuously being trailed, So we are to go long at 4598.80 + 7 = 4505.80!!! The high of 12.30 PM bar is 4606.75, why we did not go long!! Further we see that this high of 12.30 PM : 4606.75 becomes a PH in 30 min.TF and this level is breached by the 2.30 PM bar's high of 4620!!!! But going long here also is not reflected in your trades posted along with the chart at :
http://www.traderji.com/day-trading-stocks/24071-going-intraday-mini-flow-78.html#post224562
It is either an ommission by you or plain simple non understanding of the basics by me!!! In eithr case do post your views!!!!
However while trying to understand the Mini Flow had some doubts yet again and have addressed them to Saint as below!!! It is quiet possible that the same has already been discussed and clarified by Saint, please help me by either clarifying it again or posting a link to where Saint has clarified it!!! Requesting this to minimise the work load we already are giving Saint
and at times he has to answer the same queries again and again!!! If anyone else can help it wud save Saint some trouble!! Thanks!!!!!
Saint, While trying to have a look at the trades posted by you for August 2008 and matching them with the Rules as understood by me, I could not corelate the trade for a few days!!! Seems I am still lacking the basics!! Have gone through the Rules yet again but seems to be either overlooking something or misenterpreting some rule!!!
Ofcourse there can be data issues also for the difference in trades!!!
On 4th August we are short below the low of 11.30 AM bar less 7!!!
The 12 AM bar makes a HH and later becomes a PH in 30 TF!!
Would it be correct to say :"Now that we have a PH in 30 we do not look for a PH in 20/15 TF!!!"
On 6th August First trade (and Only trade for the day also) taken by you is Short at 4566 and exit at 4527!!!!
A bit hazy about how the level of 4566 was arrived at, maybe 7 points below the low of 11.30 (In my charts it is 4572.45) Also as per my charts this would be the first trade so a filter of 14 was required!!! In case due to data issues this is the secong trade then the matter is clear.
However as per my data the High of 11.30 AM bar is 4598.80, the short is not yet triggered as the Short level is continuously being trailed, So we are to go long at 4598.80 + 7 = 4505.80!!! The high of 12.30 PM bar is 4606.75, why we did not go long!! Further we see that this high of 12.30 PM : 4606.75 becomes a PH in 30 min.TF and this level is breached by the 2.30 PM bar's high of 4620!!!! But going long here also is not reflected in your trades posted along with the chart at :
http://www.traderji.com/day-trading-stocks/24071-going-intraday-mini-flow-78.html#post224562
It is either an ommission by you or plain simple non understanding of the basics by me!!! In eithr case do post your views!!!!
Hi ST, Believe me , try howsoever I may but there shall remain some diference in actual trades and paper trades and even paper trades and historical analysis!!! Yes, I have tried my best to paper trade as close to the real thing as possible!!!
I need help!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
ST, While finalising plans to enter actual trades from Monday I was trying to corelate my trades with those posted by Saint along with his charts!! and found that I still need to understand the system fully!!!! I have posted my doubts and request you also to help me put the trades in proper perspective!!!
I also request you to have a look at the charts of 14th Aug., there also I have not been able to understand the trades as mentioned by Saint!!! The entry is very clear, (though not triggered as per my data, but that is no issue) The down trend continues till 12 noon bar, which is the 4th bar making LL, though the LH was not made by 11.30 bar, now here you can observe what i was trying to say about a PH being formed in 15 TF if we have LL but miss out a LH in continuous 4 bars!!! We get a small PH in 15 minutes at 4482.50, or if we move our SAR 2 bars back it also comes to 4482.50.... if this is correct then we were to go long at 4490(4482.50+7)...The 1.30PM bar made a high of 4501!!!! But Saint has not gone long!!! So what is it that I am missing here!!!!
Have put my decision to commence actual trades are back on back burner, would like to continue to paper trade only for the time being!!!
Do reply per your convenience!!!
-R K Karnani
ps. : Though addressed to ST, please friends do give your input too!!!
I need help!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
ST, While finalising plans to enter actual trades from Monday I was trying to corelate my trades with those posted by Saint along with his charts!! and found that I still need to understand the system fully!!!! I have posted my doubts and request you also to help me put the trades in proper perspective!!!
I also request you to have a look at the charts of 14th Aug., there also I have not been able to understand the trades as mentioned by Saint!!! The entry is very clear, (though not triggered as per my data, but that is no issue) The down trend continues till 12 noon bar, which is the 4th bar making LL, though the LH was not made by 11.30 bar, now here you can observe what i was trying to say about a PH being formed in 15 TF if we have LL but miss out a LH in continuous 4 bars!!! We get a small PH in 15 minutes at 4482.50, or if we move our SAR 2 bars back it also comes to 4482.50.... if this is correct then we were to go long at 4490(4482.50+7)...The 1.30PM bar made a high of 4501!!!! But Saint has not gone long!!! So what is it that I am missing here!!!!
Have put my decision to commence actual trades are back on back burner, would like to continue to paper trade only for the time being!!!
Do reply per your convenience!!!
-R K Karnani
ps. : Though addressed to ST, please friends do give your input too!!!
Hi Friends, I almost decided to join you all in real trades. The back test shows excellent results consistently. We may get two concecutive loosing days and once in a while even a loosing week (very very rare) but never a loosing calendar month!!!
However while trying to understand the Mini Flow had some doubts yet again and have addressed them to Saint as below!!! It is quiet possible that the same has already been discussed and clarified by Saint, please help me by either clarifying it again or posting a link to where Saint has clarified it!!! Requesting this to minimise the work load we already are giving Saint and at times he has to answer the same queries again and again!!! If anyone else can help it wud save Saint some trouble!!
Thanks!!!!!
Saint, While trying to have a look at the trades posted by you for August 2008 and matching them with the Rules as understood by me, I could not corelate the trade for a few days!!! Seems I am still lacking the basics!! Have gone through the Rules yet again but seems to be either overlooking something or misenterpreting some rule!!!
Ofcourse there can be data issues also for the difference in trades!!!
On 4th August we are short below the low of 11.30 AM bar less 7!!!
The 12 AM bar makes a HH and later becomes a PH in 30 TF!!
Would it be correct to say :"Now that we have a PH in 30 we do not look for a PH in 20/15 TF!!!"
On 6th August First trade (and Only trade for the day also) taken by you is Short at 4566 and exit at 4527!!!!
A bit hazy about how the level of 4566 was arrived at, maybe 7 points below the low of 11.30 (In my charts it is 4572.45) Also as per my charts this would be the first trade so a filter of 14 was required!!! In case due to data issues this is the secong trade then the matter is clear.
However as per my data the High of 11.30 AM bar is 4598.80, the short is not yet triggered as the Short level is continuously being trailed, So we are to go long at 4598.80 + 7 = 4505.80!!! The high of 12.30 PM bar is 4606.75, why we did not go long!! Further we see that this high of 12.30 PM : 4606.75 becomes a PH in 30 min.TF and this level is breached by the 2.30 PM bar's high of 4620!!!! But going long here also is not reflected in your trades posted along with the chart at :
http://www.traderji.com/day-trading-stocks/24071-going-intraday-mini-flow-78.html#post224562
It is either an ommission by you or plain simple non understanding of the basics by me!!! In eithr case do post your views!!!!
However while trying to understand the Mini Flow had some doubts yet again and have addressed them to Saint as below!!! It is quiet possible that the same has already been discussed and clarified by Saint, please help me by either clarifying it again or posting a link to where Saint has clarified it!!! Requesting this to minimise the work load we already are giving Saint
and at times he has to answer the same queries again and again!!! If anyone else can help it wud save Saint some trouble!! Thanks!!!!!
Saint, While trying to have a look at the trades posted by you for August 2008 and matching them with the Rules as understood by me, I could not corelate the trade for a few days!!! Seems I am still lacking the basics!! Have gone through the Rules yet again but seems to be either overlooking something or misenterpreting some rule!!!
Ofcourse there can be data issues also for the difference in trades!!!
On 4th August we are short below the low of 11.30 AM bar less 7!!!
The 12 AM bar makes a HH and later becomes a PH in 30 TF!!
Would it be correct to say :"Now that we have a PH in 30 we do not look for a PH in 20/15 TF!!!"
On 6th August First trade (and Only trade for the day also) taken by you is Short at 4566 and exit at 4527!!!!
A bit hazy about how the level of 4566 was arrived at, maybe 7 points below the low of 11.30 (In my charts it is 4572.45) Also as per my charts this would be the first trade so a filter of 14 was required!!! In case due to data issues this is the secong trade then the matter is clear.
However as per my data the High of 11.30 AM bar is 4598.80, the short is not yet triggered as the Short level is continuously being trailed, So we are to go long at 4598.80 + 7 = 4505.80!!! The high of 12.30 PM bar is 4606.75, why we did not go long!! Further we see that this high of 12.30 PM : 4606.75 becomes a PH in 30 min.TF and this level is breached by the 2.30 PM bar's high of 4620!!!! But going long here also is not reflected in your trades posted along with the chart at :
http://www.traderji.com/day-trading-stocks/24071-going-intraday-mini-flow-78.html#post224562
It is either an ommission by you or plain simple non understanding of the basics by me!!! In eithr case do post your views!!!!
In the case of 4th, the movement was a congestion. To get clarity see the 15 min chart and from 11:30 bar it was rally in 15 min chart. Hence any reversal of trend, room is 7. Hence entering 11:30 bar -7.
I hope you will agree with me that any PH in 30 min bar will always be a pivot in 15 min. Hence your statement is answer itself.
Regarding, 6th aug, 11:30 bar has PL. Entry point is PL-room(here room for PL is 7)
- Status
Similar threads
-
What you feel is nifty going to open negatively positively or flat Monday morning
- Started by Rash123456789
- Replies: 2
-
-
Eros international. Why is share going down
- Started by sudhanshusingh
- Replies: 1
-
Why everybody is going for Amibroker, metatrader etc when scanner software are readily available?
- Started by newtrader101
- Replies: 1
-
What are basic things that everyone should know before going in Intraday trading??
- Started by ishan2i2008
- Replies: 33