Paul, this brings about a theoretical question for you. BTW, the previous Q&A was great.
Some markets are more continuous than others. I think you yourself have mentioned about forex markets being open almost all the time. Is the definition of monthly / weekly purely arbitrary?
There is nothing arbitrary about my monthlies and weeklies. They come solely from a mathematical derivation. OTOH, another look at past history, and you would think they are based on chart S&R's. A look at the 4-hour chart of the AUD/USD bears that fact out. The basic trend of a market is always consistent, and this is why today's price action is an indication of what will happen tomorrow.
If we wanted to, and if we had great software to churn out these numbers in no time, would we not be able to always have a look ahead of next 4 weeks? Will those forecasts be as good as the forecasts generated at the month end?
Yes, you might have being to make a program that could copy my S&R's, but the forecasts for any 4-week period will be different than for a calendar month. First of all, there is 4.3482 weeks in a month. If you go from the 15th to the 15th, those levels will be different than the calendar month.
Another thing you could do is make the monthlies arbitrary by having 30 levels every month (1st--1st, 2nd-2nd, 3rd-3rd, etc.) All of those 30 levels could not possibly be right. At the least, most of them would have to be wrong.
There is a better way to explain myself using the weeklies as an analogy. I could easily prove how aimless the S&R's appear (And don't forget, I'm used to a high degree of accuracy and predictability with them.) by showing what they look like if I went from, i.e, Wednesday to Wednesday, but it is too much grunt work, so I'm asking you to just believe me.
Notice in my Weekly Review how that most of the times the final levels are hit on Fridays, yet on Thursdays they seem so far away. This is because Fridays is a very strong hi-lo move on the range, because of all the volume that is generated on Fridays. Also, Mondays--Wednesdays are easy to trade the bounce using solely the S&R's. If the week started on Fridays, there would be continuations on most markets, and the levels would be blown out of the water the first day of the week if the week started on Friday.
Since many traders use this arbitrary definition, and since many contracts roll over at specified time of the month, I would expect there to be a difference because everyone is using the same frame of reference. Using a different frame of reference, say from 15th of a month to next 15th might not work out equally well. What are your thoughts on this?
I have no thoughts concerning contracts and when they rollover. I don't trade options, so I'm oblivious to how they work. All my convictions are based solely on what I see on the charts. After all, if you read back in this thread, Eagle gave me a blank chart (No name of the market and no rates.) with my methodology plotted on it, and then asked me to forecast it, which I did. I use my methodology to forecast local weather with a high degree of accuracy. Those events certainly had nothing to do with options or expiries.