Zerodha - Number One Discount Broker in India

[VJAY]

It is safe. Pls don't spread wrong information.. The look of charts is best. Much better than amibroker.. Little better than TT also

I given my personal experience with PI only...and that zerodha too know it

We not need goodlooking chart ...we need chart with low error data

 

[VJAY]

Yusi,

The live chart is formed from the ticks that are captured on the marketwatch. So the quality of data is not the best on the marketwatch, be it any marketwatch (Pi, NEST, FT, whatever).

When you load a chart, the historical chart is formed using our data server which has very high quality of data.

So if you load a chart at 11am, the 11:01 am candle is formed by the ticks the marketwatch gets. At 11.02am, if you close the chart and reopen the chart, the data for the 11.01 am candle comes from the data server. So the
data doesn't match exactly. But like I said, the data server is as close to reality as possible.

@Vjay, if you want to see the most accurate chart, the only way is to get a colo on the exchange, host your charting platform there, subscribe for NSE tick by tick data, and access that platform via a leased line/internet. Only that will be a chart that will be 100% close to reality.

I allready told you that am trading with ZT and data from it ....so am perfectly all right with it....this means you still not get what I am saying...

Also about direct data from NSE we all know it...there is no need advice from you

 

[Zerodha]

[/B]

I allready told you that am trading with ZT and data from it ....so am perfectly all right with it....this means you still not get what I am saying...

Also about direct data from NSE we all know it...there is no need advice from you

But Vjay what I am saying is, how do you know what you get on ZT/NEST is correct?

What I am trying to say is that you can't really say that any charting platform is completely true for intraday. So you can't really compare one against the other and say one is correct and another is wrong.

But yeah we can all agree to disagree.

 

[yusi]

The live chart is formed from the ticks that are captured on the marketwatch. So the quality of data is not the best on the marketwatch, be it any marketwatch (Pi, NEST, FT, whatever).

When you load a chart, the historical chart is formed using our data server which has very high quality of data.

So if you load a chart at 11am, the 11:01 am candle is formed by the ticks the marketwatch gets. At 11.02am, if you close the chart and reopen the chart, the data for the 11.01 am candle comes from the data server. So the
data doesn't match exactly. But like I said, the data server is as close to reality as possible.

Yes, I entirely agree with you. That is why two values were quoted -- one with running charts and one with a chart reload. So if a person were to view the Pi charts from a historical perspective, there would be little to complain. I also concur that various terminals have their small differences in value, and that is valid and acceptable.

The ticks that the market watch gets are, at best, an approximation of the bar. Here, if you could just think through "candle is formed by the ticks the marketwatch gets" the problem is self-explanatory. In your case, since you have server based accurate data from the source, you should have a fairly easy fix wherein your running charts are not (grossly) mismatched with the refreshed ones. Users would be trading from the running chart.

 

[NJ23]

Why won't the NSE Authorized vendors' data match with each other? E-signal, Neo, GDFL, Omnesys should match with each other.

 

[VJAY]

Yes, I entirely agree with you. That is why two values were quoted -- one with running charts and one with a chart reload. So if a person were to view the Pi charts from a historical perspective, there would be little to complain. I also concur that various terminals have their small differences in value, and that is valid and acceptable.

The ticks that the market watch gets are, at best, an approximation of the bar. Here, if you could just think through "candle is formed by the ticks the marketwatch gets" the problem is self-explanatory. In your case, since you have server based accurate data from the source, you should have a fairly easy fix wherein your running charts are not (grossly) mismatched with the refreshed ones. Users would be trading from the running chart.

Exactly....:thumb::clapping:
thats why am try to explain....I posted my exp in that day which am traded PI...but missed to save pi chart that day

 

[VJAY]

But Vjay what I am saying is, how do you know what you get on ZT/NEST is correct?

What I am trying to say is that you can't really say that any charting platform is completely true for intraday. So you can't really compare one against the other and say one is correct and another is wrong.

But yeah we can all agree to disagree.

Here not about correctness of data....happens problems when putting of our Sl for our trade...anyway am not arguing with this matter in future as you not ready to accept any thing against PI

 

[msa5678]

Not able to login to NSE NOW. Anybody else facing same problem?

Am getting message : User already logged in

When I click on Logout Now , I am getting message User already logged out.

Very funny situation.

Hi Zerodha,

Can u please look into this. Why this problem is
coming only for certain ID's and not for all. As I am
able to login through my brother's ID , But I am facing
this problem with my ID.

Regrads

 

[Zerodha]

Hi Zerodha,

Can u please look into this. Why this problem is
coming only for certain ID's and not for all. As I am
able to login through my brother's ID , But I am facing
this problem with my ID.

Regrads

have u sent an email to [email protected]?, if you have, can u PM your ticket number

 

[msa5678]

have u sent an email to [email protected]?, if you have, can u PM your ticket number

I have been discussing with the tele-support.
I am being told that the issue is with NSE, has
been reported and they are looking into. My
query is how come certain ID's are able to login
and others are not able to.