Zerodha - Number One Discount Broker in India

[krab]

Guess you haven't yet checked out Pi. http://zerodha.com/z-connect/category/tradezerodha/pi-tradezerodha

Zerodha

I can get data from ZT as well as NSE NOW using Josh sir utility to amibroker. what about Pi? how to get data from PI to amibroker and one more the feed back which i have read about Pi in this forum is not great, because still it is not stable, i think it is in the process.

 

[shri_r3]

Zerodha,

In Pi how to get option chain for selected scrip.
In Zt by using ctrl+alt+d used to get option chain on selected scrip.

Also how to change colors for marketwatch scrips like in ZT. Both for buying and selling of any scrip I only see red colour. Is it possible to change blinking to blue for buy and red for sell.

Thank you

 

[ethan hunt]

@Zerodha

Ref: TAX P/L from q.zerodha.com

Seems the calculation for T.O. is done on avg buy / sell price whereas it should be done on FIFO basis.

Eg:
1 trade Buy = 100 shares x Rs. 100 = 10000
2 trade Sell = 25 shares x Rs. 90 = 2250
3 trade Sell = 75 shares x 110 = 8250
T.O on avg = -10000+2250+8250 = 500 (profit) = 500
T.O. on FIFO = 250 (loss) + 750 (profit) = 1000

 

[Zerodha]

Zerodha

I can get data from ZT as well as NSE NOW using Josh sir utility to amibroker. what about Pi? how to get data from PI to amibroker and one more the feed back which i have read about Pi in this forum is not great, because still it is not stable, i think it is in the process.

I think there is yusi who has shared a way to pull data out of Pi. Can't find the link.
There are no trading issues on Pi as such. Even the data, have already told that NEST or Icharts can't really be the benchmarks. The daily chart data, we are forming based on 1 min candles, we will soon start using exchange EOD bhavcopy.

 

[Zerodha]

Zerodha,

In Pi how to get option chain for selected scrip.
In Zt by using ctrl+alt+d used to get option chain on selected scrip.

Also how to change colors for marketwatch scrips like in ZT. Both for buying and selling of any scrip I only see red colour. Is it possible to change blinking to blue for buy and red for sell.

Thank you

Currently no option chain. You shouldn't be seeing buying/selling as red. It is red and green. (you can't choose colors for marketwatch as of now). If you are seeing only red, can you pm your client ID.

 

[Zerodha]

@Zerodha

Ref: TAX P/L from q.zerodha.com

Seems the calculation for T.O. is done on avg buy / sell price whereas it should be done on FIFO basis.

Eg:
1 trade Buy = 100 shares x Rs. 100 = 10000
2 trade Sell = 25 shares x Rs. 90 = 2250
3 trade Sell = 75 shares x 110 = 8250
T.O on avg = -10000+2250+8250 = 500 (profit) = 500
T.O. on FIFO = 250 (loss) + 750 (profit) = 1000

Can you pm your client ID? we will have this checked right now. It should be on FIFO.

 

[earth]

Can you PM your client ID we will call back.

When this happened, your technical support agent had taken remote control of my laptop, but no resolution was offered

 

[ethan hunt]

Can you pm your client ID? we will have this checked right now. It should be on FIFO.

It can not be an isolated incident.
You may try anyones account statement at your end where multiple trades have been done in a contract.
Maybe a few members here can check their T.O.
I have rechecked, it is incorrect.

 

[timepass]

Hello Zerodha,

PI : Bracket Orders.
it doesn't remember the previous values of target and SL/trailing SL ticks, as does ZTrader. This is a big help in placing quick orders.​

 

[Zerodha]

It can not be an isolated incident.
You may try anyones account statement at your end where multiple trades have been done in a contract.
Maybe a few members here can check their T.O.
I have rechecked, it is incorrect.

hmm.. Just checked a few with multiple trades, seems alright. If you can let us know ur client ID, we can have this fixed if there is an issue. You can send an email to [email protected] mentioning this issue.