Zerodha - Number One Discount Broker in India

[sana]

Pls Zrdha, don't misguide traders by saying Omnyses is d best of three as for U r providing NEST terminal. Just compare the features of ODIN charts with NEST.
It is very much advanced compared to NEST. See the Indicators, customize Timeframe & Colors, Zoom IN Out, Multichart windows, Template etc. which is very easy for a trader to use. The main issue of Nest is : 1) Lacking of Advanced features & 2) Formation of last candle, which is a big confusion to trade.
Pls don't mind for harsh words as I am just keeping forth the Facts of NEST terminal.

:thumb::thumb:

 

[agsuresh]

"THE best.." Umm. Boss, you too rest assure of distinction marks from us if your trading platform comes anywhere near to the Sharekhan's trading platform. Promise.

Zerodha had written in an earlier msg that only three software vendors are available in India for Indian exchanges - trading + charting

Has sherkhan developed their own software or are they using any of the three pointed out here ?

Whose software are they using?

 

[agsuresh]

Trading is "1% Luck + 19% Strategy + 40% Risk Management + 40% Psychology"

Zerodha,

You have about 30000 customers. Can you tell how much percentage of clients make money month on month or are in profits till now since they joined.

 

[agsuresh]

//The other issue you have now is the data, that will be fixed soon, we have been telling that our data servers will take a few days to be operational. So if there is anything that you want to be fixed, let us know and that will help us. //

Zerodha,

This the crux of the issue

Most of the problems on Pi , as I understand it, are centered around your servers, which will take a few days, weeks, months.......

So what can we test ?

The only thing we can request or ask or suggest are the features on charts. But then I do not think you want others to tell you that, Since you have highly experienced traders amongst you and more over lots of charting tools are available to look for examples.

Again on the trading front, you can't make something that is not exchange complaint.

The only thing what hundreds of clients can do is to point out errors in the operations. Again this is most unnecessary if the design of the software is robust. This depends on the code designers. they are supposed to implement error trapping mechanisms in the right from the beginning itself. Otherwise there will not be an end to error problem.

Prevention is better than cure ! the design should be robust enough that errors would not occur in the first place and even if it occur, it is trapped effectively. The key lies in the ability of the code designer to anticipate the issues and the way an ordinary user of that software would blunder.

The issues includes the language capabilities or deficiencies, compatibility with a variety of windows platforms and office combined, machine configuration etc etc.

The way I see it, the design team, whoever they are, may know coding of .Net languages. But I am skeptical about their ability on design integrity.

Any way take care.

 

[pavan15589]

Zerodha...

Pi is going through the developmental process. Yes!! But please do not change the interface. It takes a while to get acquainted with the interface only to end up searching for couple of options in the next release. The thing is an interface restructures an users behavior and by changing the interface often, it is a huge stress on the user even for a small option. Pi does not have the reconcile in the quick order box anymore. And the chart tools are removed from the right click menu. Chart tools are supposed to have a drop down menu on the chart and that should be primary while chart tools menu in the menu bar should be secondary access to the tools. Hope you will place them back in order like before.

And the new Nest chart is super *rap. I am still not able to zoom into a particular area by double clicking and selecting the region. Ctrl+Z does not seem to work. Although scrolling is quicker.
Please post the changes from the previous version of Nest Chart and the workaround introduced for those basic interface options.

One more thing. Few sign up with Zerodha for their service and the free charting and trading platforms. If Zerodha did not exist, most of us would be paying a price monthly for these but thanks to you we are not paying. But I did sign up because of the customer service and the platform.
Customer Service..!! No word..!! Impeccable.
Pi..!! In process of being the best...
The problem arises when we are counting on your trading platforms and there's not one day we log in and log out of the platforms without any problem. There is Pi which is in process but it works just about fine for me. And then there's data problem which appears all of a sudden which is acceptable because its a work in progress. Now, if I want to trade on Nest cos the data for the day isn't all that fine on Pi, Nest does't work. If a person's income depended on this, how would you feel being responsible for him not being able to pay his mortgage or any sort of bill.
No complaints about Pi (again since its in progress) but Nest is unacceptable. You have partnered with Omnesys and you are equally responsible for the problems your clients face. You cannot tell us that any broker using Nest will be facing the issue. If we signed up with that broker, we would be pushing them as much as we would push you. We put a trade out and then Nest hangs or just freezes, a scalper might lose a fortune. A person who might be making 100 to 1000 bucks a day may hit a bad loss which he may take a week to recover from. And starters like me, I cannot just improve upon my intraday trading. You need to have at least one thing running well. Either Pi (beta is fine) with good data or Nest without problems.

And in the end, it's not hard to admit that Zerodha is one of the better companies out there and may be you guys have left a lot of others in the dust. Many people above speak of the competition and catching up. There's not catching up because your company feels more personal, more in tune with customers. I am sure you guys are far ahead and as a customer, I wouldn't think of signing up with anyone else at all as long as you guys exist. But you need to know that most we are putting up with your problems. Not because of Pi, but because of Nest.
It will be great if you get more help on your data servers and fix them quickly for Pi.
And to help yourself as a firm, do give customers a date, so we look forward to it while you may just to meet the customers' deadline sweat more than 20hrs a day and efficiently. It's hard to have anything new up and running.

Have a good week ahead....
Thank You..

 

[doshiv]

What happened in BSE ?????????

 

[doshiv]

What is happening in BSE ???????????????????????????????????????????????

 

[timepass]

I try to change the TF and it hangs up.. that happens even if I try to change the time frame from the menu

If any uninstall/reinstall is needed, I better do that over the weekend.

I think we will have to wait a day or two till Omnesys sees their Lite version in action, before they do something more with it. For me, the charts hang up when I change the time frame. So it is google charts for me till a working version is available from Nest Plus.

Have mailed Zerodha about this problem, and received a support ticket. Hopefully they will follow it up. I suggest the remaining members too to send them a mail at [email protected]

 

[sarfarazfresh]

Hello Zerodha

I am having the following issues with new white background nestplus .
1. parabolic SAR showing as dots and not as a line
2. the chart blinks almost every second
3. uncomfortable to zoom in and zoom out
4. the last candle (the most recent one) is almost sticking to the border . its uncomfortable to view and painful .

Kindly look into these issues. Looking for a response
Also is there any way to get back the old black background nest plus which was working last week ?

Thanks

 

[doonbulls]

Zerodha

I rarely post messages on forums but this is the second time u have forced me to do so within few months. I dont know how other traders manage with ur trading software. Ur system is not stable u keep on releasing updates and patches which always result in newer issues. Now I m facing following issues with the current update nest chart 2.9.3.0 ------

First, why white charts when no one likes it. I'm talking of nestchart update.

Second, the second last candle keeps on changing until it becomes third last. How am i supposed to trade. Check out the 15 minute chart of Dec nifty future.

I m not happy.
doonbulls