Zerodha....

[BUZZ]

Re: Zerodha Stamp Duty....

no u lie...sebi turnover fee not is there...stamp duty they r not including in brokerage calc, hidden fee?:annoyed::annoyed::annoyed:...for low turnover trading stamp duty too high...no mention of sebi turnover fee and expensive stamp duty...why they are in karnataka... maharasthra stamp duty is very good

Hi Desi7893,

This calculator issue I raised long back. But I did not get the satisfied answer but was surprised other fellow member jumped into and made a mess saying Zerodha is the best bla bla.. So I left it as it is.

I always wonder why other people jumped into and would not let Zerodha answer the query?

We know very well, There are lots of lapses in Zerodha. We should know the other side of the coin too.

Other brokers provide complete platform. So they charge accordingly.

For example, one of the broker charges just 12 Rs. more than Zerodha per trade but of course I get all the investment option with it and very big this is I can get Margin against my investment shares which makes a lots of difference when you trade.

In fact, I don't even need money in my ledger book sometime for at least 5-8 nifty futures trading intra-day. However, With zerodha, if you need to trade 5-8 Nifty Futures you know how much money you need to block in their ledger book?

I let Zerodha to say how much money require in clients ledger book for 5-8 nifty futures ( NF50).

Then you might have a clear picture, what is the major difference.

For example Zerodha is not a complete platform. In Zerodha -> NO IPO, NO mutual fund, NO NCD, NO Bond, no margin given against your invested shares etc.

Their calculator is still the same and horrible. It's miss-guiding too.

 

[vikrit]

Yes m doing that. I cannot install from browser.

why cannot? i tried yesterday on a friend's old phone (samsung) java supported. in that also it installed directly from browser, but yeah after installation it get closed before login. may be his phone's java is old. so try it directly from phone, what msg it is giving?

 

[Subhadip]

when commodity is starting?

 

[murthyavr]

Re: Zerodha Stamp Duty....

Hi Desi7893,

I always wonder why other people jumped into and would not let Zerodha answer the query?

It's true, I realized it today - with reference to quotes.

I keep observing the comments of a particular person on the market movements,
particulary NIFTY. Today, I get a message from him - "Gone.." in the second
half. My Amibroker chart sees no such thing, thanks to ManshiRT. I look at
NOW's market watch, the price remained almost the same. Then, after 3 or
4 seconds, a big fall started below the support area.

Now, the person who sent the message must have taken atleast a second to
type it, and the transmission might have taken another one second. Three
seconds after I receive the message, I notice the fall in Market Watch. So,
there is atleast a lag of 5 seconds, with reference to the watch window of
the person who has sent the message.

All along, we have been listening to Zerodha about the co-located servers,
and we have been believing them. Friends who have multiple systems could
have observed this, but who knows? their other systems might be worse than
Zerodha.

Then, I thought. May be, there was some truth in what Buzz said, but no one
was caring to listen to him.

Ultimately - how really "real" are the real quotes from NOW?

 

[desi7893]

Re: Zerodha Stamp Duty....

Hi Desi7893,

This calculator issue I raised long back. But I did not get the satisfied answer but was surprised other fellow member jumped into and made a mess saying Zerodha is the best bla bla.. So I left it as it is.

I always wonder why other people jumped into and would not let Zerodha answer the query?

We know very well, There are lots of lapses in Zerodha. We should know the other side of the coin too.

Other brokers provide complete platform. So they charge accordingly.

For example, one of the broker charges just 12 Rs. more than Zerodha per trade but of course I get all the investment option with it and very big this is I can get Margin against my investment shares which makes a lots of difference when you trade.

In fact, I don't even need money in my ledger book sometime for at least 5-8 nifty futures trading intra-day. However, With zerodha, if you need to trade 5-8 Nifty Futures you know how much money you need to block in their ledger book?

I let Zerodha to say how much money require in clients ledger book for 5-8 nifty futures ( NF50).

Then you might have a clear picture, what is the major difference.

For example Zerodha is not a complete platform. In Zerodha -> NO IPO, NO mutual fund, NO NCD, NO Bond, no margin given against your invested shares etc.

Their calculator is still the same and horrible. It's miss-guiding too.

not just horrible n misguiding...they lie...they do not mention sebi charges. wonder what other things they lie about

 

[GTji]

Re: Zerodha Stamp Duty....

It's true, I realized it today - with reference to quotes.

I keep observing the comments of a particular person on the market movements,
particulary NIFTY. Today, I get a message from him - "Gone.." in the second
half. My Amibroker chart sees no such thing, thanks to ManshiRT. I look at
NOW's market watch, the price remained almost the same. Then, after 3 or
4 seconds, a big fall started below the support area.

Now, the person who sent the message must have taken atleast a second to
type it, and the transmission might have taken another one second. Three
seconds after I receive the message, I notice the fall in Market Watch. So,
there is atleast a lag of 5 seconds, with reference to the watch window of
the person who has sent the message.

All along, we have been listening to Zerodha about the co-located servers,
and we have been believing them. Friends who have multiple systems could
have observed this, but who knows? their other systems might be worse than
Zerodha.

Then, I thought. May be, there was some truth in what Buzz said, but no one
was caring to listen to him.

Ultimately - how really "real" are the real quotes from NOW?

Yes, this very important. Quotes need to be compared and we need to find out, I guess the only way to do that would be to compare it with some other data feed. Maybe someone with Global Data feed subscription can compare with Now.exe quotes and let us know?

 

[sansarva]

1. I have a garmin asus windows mobile. It is jawa enabled. Can zerodha takeup with NOW team for mobile NOW to work on windows mobile

2. Secondly can Zerodha comment on the time lag issue of quotes.

 

[mithoon]

Query resolved,spoke to NOW-02226567700,was adviced that as i was using WIN 7 ,i would have to login as admin by right clicking on the NOW icon and before you do that right click on NOW icon-click on properties-click on open location file-delete file by name dialogpos.

Doing the above has not helped :annoyed:,was asked to reinstall NOW,but that has not helped either

 

[msa5678]

How to translate AFL code to NestPlus code ?

 

[mithoon]

Doing the above has not helped :annoyed:,was asked to reinstall NOW,but that has not helped either

Spoke to NOW was asked to check net speed at http://us.mcafee.com/root/speedometer/default.asp it showed 500kbps ,was advised that the latest NOW 1.6 needs constant speed of 500kbps and since i was using 2 applications(NOW and AMIBROKER) speed was being divided,spoke to my internet provider(BSNL bangalore) was advised that unlimited plans have variable speed though my internet plan was to get speeds of 2-4 mbps,switched to 2mbps ,15GB plan.