Zerodha....
- Thread starter bharath.mang
- Start date
- Tags bakwaas now cheapest brokerage nest nest plus new broker zerodha zerodha trader
- Status
Hi,
I'm unable to log in to Zerodha NOW platform... cleared cookies and all... still... Anybody else facing the problem?
I'm unable to log in to Zerodha NOW platform... cleared cookies and all... still... Anybody else facing the problem?
Zerodha: Freak Trade in Minifty Triggering Stop Loss
A very freak incident happened today and i want to know if other traders in this forum using Zerodha faced the same thing:
I would like readers to go thru this carefully and give their views... i also expect Zerodha to reply on this:
Today i bought 1 lot of Minifty April Futures at 9:30 am.
After price crossed 5300 i placed stop loss limit order.
Even though my trigger price was never reached, my order got executed at 12:42pm.
When i contacted Zerodha guys, they showed me a freak trade that happened at 12:42pm at the price of 3512
They said that this trade triggered your stop loss.
Now, i am completely bemused that how come such a trade can happen at such a low price. Shouldn't NSE prevent such incidents, because such freak trades will take out everybody's stop losses and most traders will end up red faced.
If such a freak trade has happened, then there are bound to be other traders who also faced the same situation. I would like them to come forward and express themselves.
If such things are going to happen, then nobody's stop loss will ever be safe.
Another thing of concern is that when i checked Minifty values on NSE website, it shows today's low as 5238. If a freak trade happened at 3512, then that should have been shown as the day's low. So, i am in doubt whether this is error on NSE's side or Zerodha's side.
I have already raised this issue with Zerodha but i am posting here so that if there are others who faced this problem, we can voice it together.
- Akash.
A very freak incident happened today and i want to know if other traders in this forum using Zerodha faced the same thing:
I would like readers to go thru this carefully and give their views... i also expect Zerodha to reply on this:
Today i bought 1 lot of Minifty April Futures at 9:30 am.
After price crossed 5300 i placed stop loss limit order.
Even though my trigger price was never reached, my order got executed at 12:42pm.
When i contacted Zerodha guys, they showed me a freak trade that happened at 12:42pm at the price of 3512
They said that this trade triggered your stop loss.
Now, i am completely bemused that how come such a trade can happen at such a low price. Shouldn't NSE prevent such incidents, because such freak trades will take out everybody's stop losses and most traders will end up red faced.
If such a freak trade has happened, then there are bound to be other traders who also faced the same situation. I would like them to come forward and express themselves.
If such things are going to happen, then nobody's stop loss will ever be safe.
Another thing of concern is that when i checked Minifty values on NSE website, it shows today's low as 5238. If a freak trade happened at 3512, then that should have been shown as the day's low. So, i am in doubt whether this is error on NSE's side or Zerodha's side.
I have already raised this issue with Zerodha but i am posting here so that if there are others who faced this problem, we can voice it together.
- Akash.
Re: Zerodha: Freak Trade in Minifty Triggering Stop Loss
What was your SL Limit order you placed... at what price....??
Because if you place a order above/below certain price range ..... then your order tend to get freezed....
BTW I really don't believe that your SL order was below the days low and still got triggered.... can you post screenshots....?
First use reconcile option.. (Preferences--- User Settings---General---Reconcile)
Just goto orderbook by pressing F3 and then click display button in bottom... then double click on the order you are talking about...it will show you order history window....make it full screen and take screen shot and post for members of traderji.
It will show its journey of how it is gone under execution.......
Pls post Images .... so that if such things are really happened... then these are serious... but still I don't believe that...
Let's see your images if it is really happened.
A very freak incident happened today and i want to know if other traders in this forum using Zerodha faced the same thing:
I would like readers to go thru this carefully and give their views... i also expect Zerodha to reply on this:
Today i bought 1 lot of Minifty April Futures at 9:30 am.
After price crossed 5300 i placed stop loss limit order.
Even though my trigger price was never reached, my order got executed at 12:42pm.
When i contacted Zerodha guys, they showed me a freak trade that happened at 12:42pm at the price of 3512
They said that this trade triggered your stop loss.
Now, i am completely bemused that how come such a trade can happen at such a low price. Shouldn't NSE prevent such incidents, because such freak trades will take out everybody's stop losses and most traders will end up red faced.
If such a freak trade has happened, then there are bound to be other traders who also faced the same situation. I would like them to come forward and express themselves.
If such things are going to happen, then nobody's stop loss will ever be safe.
Another thing of concern is that when i checked Minifty values on NSE website, it shows today's low as 5238. If a freak trade happened at 3512, then that should have been shown as the day's low. So, i am in doubt whether this is error on NSE's side or Zerodha's side.
I have already raised this issue with Zerodha but i am posting here so that if there are others who faced this problem, we can voice it together.
- Akash.
I would like readers to go thru this carefully and give their views... i also expect Zerodha to reply on this:
Today i bought 1 lot of Minifty April Futures at 9:30 am.
After price crossed 5300 i placed stop loss limit order.
Even though my trigger price was never reached, my order got executed at 12:42pm.
When i contacted Zerodha guys, they showed me a freak trade that happened at 12:42pm at the price of 3512
They said that this trade triggered your stop loss.
Now, i am completely bemused that how come such a trade can happen at such a low price. Shouldn't NSE prevent such incidents, because such freak trades will take out everybody's stop losses and most traders will end up red faced.
If such a freak trade has happened, then there are bound to be other traders who also faced the same situation. I would like them to come forward and express themselves.
If such things are going to happen, then nobody's stop loss will ever be safe.
Another thing of concern is that when i checked Minifty values on NSE website, it shows today's low as 5238. If a freak trade happened at 3512, then that should have been shown as the day's low. So, i am in doubt whether this is error on NSE's side or Zerodha's side.
I have already raised this issue with Zerodha but i am posting here so that if there are others who faced this problem, we can voice it together.
- Akash.
Because if you place a order above/below certain price range ..... then your order tend to get freezed....
BTW I really don't believe that your SL order was below the days low and still got triggered.... can you post screenshots....?
First use reconcile option.. (Preferences--- User Settings---General---Reconcile)
Just goto orderbook by pressing F3 and then click display button in bottom... then double click on the order you are talking about...it will show you order history window....make it full screen and take screen shot and post for members of traderji.
It will show its journey of how it is gone under execution.......
Pls post Images .... so that if such things are really happened... then these are serious... but still I don't believe that...
Let's see your images if it is really happened.
Last edited:
1:08:25 PM rakesh kaushik: mini nifty ka low dekh
1:08:28 PM rakesh kaushik: how cud it be
1:08:32 PM rakesh kaushik: is it a mistakre
1:08:38 PM linkon7: kitna hai
1:08:42 PM rakesh kaushik: 3512
1:08:51 PM linkon7: 3512
1:09:01 PM rakesh kaushik: u heard ryt
1:09:03 PM rakesh kaushik: 3512
1:09:16 PM linkon7: some idiot must be crying his heart out
1:09:26 PM rakesh kaushik:
1:09:31 PM rakesh kaushik: how cud it be
1:09:36 PM rakesh kaushik: lc 10%
1:09:52 PM linkon7: freak trade hoga
1:10:03 PM rakesh kaushik: how
1:10:07 PM rakesh kaushik: nse doesnt evena ccept
1:10:10 PM rakesh kaushik: try putting
1:10:14 PM linkon7: some guy must have put big qty at market
1:10:14 PM rakesh kaushik: u will see
1:10:17 PM linkon7: at open
1:10:23 PM rakesh kaushik: bt exchange doesnt accept
1:10:25 PM rakesh kaushik: nah
1:10:28 PM rakesh kaushik: it never accpets
1:10:32 PM linkon7: buy accept karega na
1:10:35 PM rakesh kaushik: nah
1:10:41 PM rakesh kaushik: exchange will reject
1:10:45 PM rakesh kaushik: its a technical mistake
later LOW was adjusted...!
1:08:28 PM rakesh kaushik: how cud it be
1:08:32 PM rakesh kaushik: is it a mistakre
1:08:38 PM linkon7: kitna hai
1:08:42 PM rakesh kaushik: 3512
1:08:51 PM linkon7: 3512
1:09:01 PM rakesh kaushik: u heard ryt
1:09:03 PM rakesh kaushik: 3512
1:09:16 PM linkon7: some idiot must be crying his heart out
1:09:26 PM rakesh kaushik:
1:09:31 PM rakesh kaushik: how cud it be
1:09:36 PM rakesh kaushik: lc 10%
1:09:52 PM linkon7: freak trade hoga
1:10:03 PM rakesh kaushik: how
1:10:07 PM rakesh kaushik: nse doesnt evena ccept
1:10:10 PM rakesh kaushik: try putting
1:10:14 PM linkon7: some guy must have put big qty at market
1:10:14 PM rakesh kaushik: u will see
1:10:17 PM linkon7: at open
1:10:23 PM rakesh kaushik: bt exchange doesnt accept
1:10:25 PM rakesh kaushik: nah
1:10:28 PM rakesh kaushik: it never accpets
1:10:32 PM linkon7: buy accept karega na
1:10:35 PM rakesh kaushik: nah
1:10:41 PM rakesh kaushik: exchange will reject
1:10:45 PM rakesh kaushik: its a technical mistake
later LOW was adjusted...!
- Status
