Status
Not open for further replies.

Subhadip

Well-Known Member
yesterday i have first traded in zerodha along with my sharekhan in commodity to see how it works,

but i am stunned to see in my contract note that i have traded with 2 lots of copper mini, whereas i have traded with only 1 lot of copper mini,

that also only 2 trades , whereas in contract note it is 8 trades.

i do not understand the discrepancies.

called them, but told to mail them, which is already been done.

waiting for their reply.

also as the trade quantity is big as per contract note( which is actually very less) so the Stump duty also got increased.

any one faced the similar kind of trouble before..

one thing more..i covered all trade , but as per contract note i am long with 2 lots of copper mini

do not know what should i do..


waiting for reply
 
yesterday i have first traded in zerodha along with my sharekhan in commodity to see how it works,

but i am stunned to see in my contract note that i have traded with 2 lots of copper mini, whereas i have traded with only 1 lot of copper mini,

that also only 2 trades , whereas in contract note it is 8 trades.

i do not understand the discrepancies.

called them, but told to mail them, which is already been done.

waiting for their reply.

also as the trade quantity is big as per contract note( which is actually very less) so the Stump duty also got increased.

any one faced the similar kind of trouble before..

one thing more..i covered all trade , but as per contract note i am long with 2 lots of copper mini

do not know what should i do..


waiting for reply
Dont get me wrong, but since it was your first day on their platform, it could be a a case of fat fingers. Maybe some options like market order were set at no confirmations required, and got executed? Have zerodha take teamviewer and check those settings too.
 

Subhadip

Well-Known Member
Dont get me wrong, but since it was your first day on their platform, it could be a a case of fat fingers. Maybe some options like market order were set at no confirmations required, and got executed? Have zerodha take teamviewer and check those settings too.
no..i am not that dull dear.

also in terminal and trade.zerodha.com is stating that one lot has been traded all through out..

NB : i am active trader in NSE now
 

Subhadip

Well-Known Member
Cannot comment on the discrepencies, only zerodha can clarify that, i wanted to point out that if by any case u are still long on copper,pls keep an eye on the international charts, they have formed a H& S pattern on 5 mnt chart and incase its breaks ,its a straight line drop from there.So watch out.

Happy Trading.
already covered it..

by call & trade..

in marginal loss

but i am very annoyed in it..
 

Zerodha

Well-Known Member
Hi Sachin,

Transaction charges on options unlike futures is not on the contract value, but the premium value... The Transaction charges from NSE is 5000 + ST per crore (around 5600) and the clearing charges... Hence it is different for futures and options...

For eg, when you buy and sell 1 lot of nifty future(5000), your turnover is 5lks...

When you buy and sell 1 lot of nifty 5000 calls( assume at Rs 100), though your turnover is 5lks, your transaction charge is only on the premium turnover( on Rs 10,000)...Transaction charge therefore is much lesser for options than futures...
Had answered this already sachin...
 

Zerodha

Well-Known Member
yesterday i have first traded in zerodha along with my sharekhan in commodity to see how it works,

but i am stunned to see in my contract note that i have traded with 2 lots of copper mini, whereas i have traded with only 1 lot of copper mini,

that also only 2 trades , whereas in contract note it is 8 trades.

i do not understand the discrepancies.

called them, but told to mail them, which is already been done.

waiting for their reply.

also as the trade quantity is big as per contract note( which is actually very less) so the Stump duty also got increased.

any one faced the similar kind of trouble before..

one thing more..i covered all trade , but as per contract note i am long with 2 lots of copper mini

do not know what should i do..


waiting for reply
Hi Dr,

Someone must have already spoken to you about this:

1. The reason a lot was showing open today morning was because, you had bought 1 lot as MIS and Sold as NRML yesterday. What happens is all MIS positions get squared off at 11.05pm. The NRML positions remain open.

MIS is used for only intraday positions(with extra leverage). Ensure that if you have bought as MIS, you also sell it as MIS. If you have bought as NRML, sell it a NRML.

Go to CTRL+ P and set the default product type as MIS, if you trade intraday and NRML if you trade overnight.. The position can be converted anytime by going to Trade book and clicking on position conversion.

2. Contract note is showing a few extra trades. If you check it out, it is the same trade showing twice. This is an error from our side and we will send you new contract notes in the next couple of hours. If you look at the ledger, you will see that the posting is absolutely right, but on the contract note same trades have shown twice.

The reason for the error was because we had not been charging any call n trade for commodity trading till date. We started yesterday and our programming of contract note for commodity was affected. Thanks for pointing it out...

Cheers..
 

Aarav11

Well-Known Member
I am not able to view the order book window even after pressing F3 or directly clicking on it.

Please help
 

Aarav11

Well-Known Member
I am not able to view the order book window even after pressing F3 or directly clicking on it.

Please help
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads